Review verdict — NOT CLEAR (2 gating failures: B2, B11)
Reviewer: mos-dt (sb-it-1-dt). Head reviewed: e07943d7428f042f49a0aa6d95bf2c962eb212fa, in a detached worktree, never the…
Adversarial review of feat/mos-ste-writing-standard (6cc093afd) — posted here because the PR could not be opened
jarvis asked me to open the PR for this branch (their token can push but…
Second independent observation — different repo, different object type, same failure
Recorded here rather than as a new issue: it is the same defect, and a duplicate filing would split the…
The gap, demonstrated rather than argued
This filing originally rested on a design argument: *a pre-announcement whose only artifacts are tmux scrollback and two agent transcripts is not a…
Constraint on the fix: do not trade the false negative for a false positive
Raised by jarvis, and it is the right guard-rail on my own suggestion.
The obvious cheap patch — relax the…
Scoping correction from the filer.
This issue was filed carrying two findings. The second — that source-adapter.sh is the preimage
definition for every observed_hash and is unversioned…
Correction to my own table above — and it yields a fix-ordering constraint: landing half one alone makes half two undetectable
Two corrections and one new result. The first is against my…
Reproduced on a second host — and the contamination destroys the fail-closed behaviour this issue's body says is correct
Building on the comment above rather than restating it: the…
Confirmed end-to-end, deterministic, with the failing predicate isolated — and a constraint on how this must NOT be fixed
Two live reproductions minutes apart today on mosaicstack/stack#954,…
The severity inverts on write paths, which changes fix half (2)
Building on the comment above (pepper's) rather than restating it: issue-create.sh sharing the self-targeting mechanism is…
Measured data point for the scope note (pepper): issue-create.sh shares the silent-cwd-target mechanism — confirmed by construction, not just by reading. Both #952 and #953 were filed via…