Record verified publication and owner acceptance handoff (#1497)

2026-09-08 17:20:12 -05:00
parent 29c1defe29
commit 10448e41a2
7 changed files with 103 additions and 4 deletions
@@ -1874,3 +1874,7 @@ Before: remaining launchers/agent definitions, WUI drafts, skill and shared reco
 ## 2026-09-08 — #1497 recovery evidence and source-review candidate

 Rocko reports one reserved post-restart isolated test invocation, 1 pass/0 fail exit 0 after operator restart/neutral continue. Filbert independently SUPPORTS bounded recovery and APPROVES curated summary 0e17757c with raw records withheld; exact resume mode inferred and execution count worker-reported, not runtime guarantees. Independent ten-file snapshot manifest b52a6215. Coordinator corrected Pi fixture recursive-copy coupling (four tests passed), TOOLS flag gap and added inactive-skill compatibility/provenance note; original Rocko test/launcher pins unchanged. Final 23-candidate launcher/source snapshot manifest 8900faf1 submitted for independent review. No commit/push or owner trial acceptance yet.
+
+## 2026-09-08 — #1497 reviewed publication delivered
+
+Filbert final aggregation APPROVED: 90 files at 3f8e765b plus two metadata units. Exact 92-path commit 29c1defe29e5793022e1d3820b265bfc0f7f628a pushed to refactor; fresh origin/refactor matches. Coordinator verified committed bytes and reran isolated committed-tree fixtures 5/5 pass. Full staged whitespace diagnostic failed only on three original OFL notices; preserved licensed bytes, authored-path check passed. Prior disposable-mode fixture failure and reviewer wrong-directory attempt remain documented, not counted green. Raw runtime evidence and newer unreviewed skill drift excluded. Final review registration occurs after the 92-file pin release. Publication receipt: docs/plans/reviews/2026-09-08_publication-trial-publication-receipt.md. Jason retains trial acceptance; no deployment or held-queue advancement.
@@ -139,3 +139,5 @@ are never rewritten or removed; corrections are new entries.
 - 2026-09-08 | Filbert | PUB-REC-FILBERT-SONNET-2 focused sonnet-delta round-2 review | APPROVED: three one-line Fable-to-Sonnet repairs verified minimal (rocko CONTEXT.md, agents/README.md, darkwing SOUL.md); no fable references remain in the seven-file snapshot at manifest c5ad6306; combined fixtures rerun independently 5/5 pass in disposable harness over approved dependencies; exactly six changed candidates vs original approval; R1 rejection preserved; verdict docs/plans/reviews/2026-09-08_publication-trial-sonnet-r2-verdict.md; no live launches or private reads.

 - 2026-09-08 — darkwing — PUB-REC-FILBERT-SONNET-2 independently APPROVED six revised publication candidates at c5ad6306, combined reviewer fixtures 5/5 passed. Coordinator verified seven frozen/live file hashes, no drift. R1 rejection and historical recovery bytes preserved. Acknowledgement transport exit 0, application acceptance unknown; no reply requested. Final selective publication remains pending.
+
+- 2026-09-08 — darkwing for Filbert — PUB-REC-FILBERT-FINAL-1 APPROVED 92 exact publication units at manifest 3f8e765b; final-verdict receipt preserved. Published at 29c1defe29e5793022e1d3820b265bfc0f7f628a, committed-tree fixtures 5/5 passed, push and fresh origin/refactor identity verified. Upstream OFL whitespace preserved; authored-path whitespace check passes, full check does not. Raw/unreviewed drift remains local. Jason trial acceptance pending; no deployment.
@@ -29,7 +29,7 @@ Design drafts may be published with explicit pending-owner-acceptance labels. Pu
 - Worker assignment and author boundary: complete. WUI exact 53-file draft independently approved at a585c1ee, pending owner design acceptance.
 - Planned checkpoint recovery: independently SUPPORTED; curated summary 0e17757c APPROVED. Operator-reported restart, inferred resume mode and worker-reported execution count remain qualified. Raw runtime records stay local.
 - Source approval: 23 original candidates at 8900faf1, with six Sonnet revisions superseded by approved c5ad6306. Independent isolated tests 5/5 passed.
- Final publication inventory and candidate-tree verification: in progress. Since approval, the executive-update skill changed, the tracked ms-agent-watch skill was deleted locally, and additional untracked skills appeared. These newer changes have no trial review or ownership handoff; preserve and exclude them, including the executive-update compatibility note. Do not restore deleted files or silently publish stale skill bytes.
- Publication / remote verification / owner trial acceptance: pending. No live launches or unrelated skill migration is authorized.
+- Final publication inventory and candidate-tree verification: complete. Filbert approved 90 frozen files at 3f8e765b plus two metadata units, total 92. Since approval, the executive-update skill changed, the tracked ms-agent-watch skill was deleted locally, and additional untracked skills appeared. These newer changes have no trial review or ownership handoff; preserve and exclude them, including the executive-update compatibility note. Do not restore deleted files or silently publish stale skill bytes.
+- Publication and remote verification: complete at 29c1defe29e5793022e1d3820b265bfc0f7f628a. Exact committed paths/bytes verified; committed-tree isolated fixtures 5/5 passed; push succeeded and fresh origin/refactor SHA matched. Owner trial acceptance remains pending. No live launches or unrelated skill migration is authorized.

 No new /goal lifecycle is claimed by this document. Use this task plan and artifacts for tracking; an operator-set goal extension remains sole lifecycle owner.
@@ -22,8 +22,11 @@ PUB-REC-FILBERT-SONNET-2 APPROVED the six revised candidates at c5ad6306;
 coordinator verified all seven R2 snapshot/live files unchanged. Remaining original
 candidate approvals stand. Independent combined fixtures passed 5/5. Preserve
 R1 REQUEST CHANGES and the historical Fable recovery evidence unchanged.
-Next gate: final tests and exact selective publication inventory with private raw
-records excluded, then commit/push refactor and request Jason's trial acceptance.
+Publication completed at 29c1defe29e5793022e1d3820b265bfc0f7f628a on refactor;
+92 exact approved units committed, committed-tree fixtures 5/5 passed, push succeeded
+and fresh origin/refactor identity matched. Final aggregation APPROVED at 3f8e765b.
+Next action: present the bounded publication/recovery trial to Jason for acceptance.
+Do not close #1497 or resume the registry queue before that acceptance.
 Newer executive-update skill edits, local ms-agent-watch deletion and additional
 untracked skills are outside the pinned trial candidate. Preserve them uncommitted;
 exclude both executive-update files rather than publish unreviewed or stale bytes.
@@ -0,0 +1,23 @@
+# PUB-REC-FILBERT-CLOSEOUT-1 — documentation closeout verdict
+
+Reviewer: Filbert (independent). Coordinator: Darkwing. Trial #1497, docs-only closeout. My prior final verdict is included here as an evidence receipt, byte-unchanged; this closeout review is a factual verification of status/receipt documents, not a self-review of new implementation.
+
+## Verdict: APPROVED
+
+Six frozen closeout units at `/tmp/pub-rec-closeout-review-ef7gm069`, manifest SHA-256 `2da95540036c90f281eb57b7713373c556872eeed451609c3003589814846525`; all six hashes verified before and after review; snapshot unchanged. No source changes, shared-log writes while frozen, real launches, private reads, config edits, or deployment.
+
+## Independently verified facts
+
+- Publication commit `29c1defe29e5793022e1d3820b265bfc0f7f628a` (parent `3b7fd19d…`) changed exactly the 92 approved units: the committed path set equals the final inventory plus the two metadata units, with nothing extra and nothing omitted. Every committed file byte-matches the frozen final snapshot `/tmp/pub-rec-final-review-f5br4ch4`; both metadata units byte-match their durable copies.
+- Push verified independently: fresh `git ls-remote origin refs/heads/refactor` returns the full publication SHA. No force push or other-branch motion appears in the history between baseline and publication.
+- Committed-tree fixtures: I extracted `git archive 29c1defe` into a disposable tree and reran both suites — 5 tests, 5 pass, 0 fail, exit 0 — independently reproducing the coordinator's committed-tree result (his log `/tmp/pub-rec-committed-fixtures.log` shows the same).
+- Whitespace qualification verified precisely and honestly: the full check between baseline and publication returns exit 2 with 187 diagnostics, every one confined to the three upstream OFL notices (93 CRLF lines each in DM Sans and IBM Plex Sans, one trailing-space line in Manrope; all three carry the upstream trailing space on line 21). The path-scoped check excluding only those three files has zero findings. The licensed bytes were retained exactly as reviewed rather than normalized. Consistent with the receipt's instruction, the full whitespace check is reported here as NOT passing, with this qualification — not as green.
+- Closeout deltas versus the committed versions are documentation-only and accurate: CURRENT.md sets the next action to presenting the trial to Jason with no closure or registry resumption before acceptance; the BUILD-LOG phase entry records the publication facts and keeps the earlier disposable-mode failure and my wrong-directory attempt documented as not-counted-green; the SESSIONS line registers my final verdict accurately; the trial-plan gates now read complete with exact identities and owner acceptance pending.
+- The closeout copy of my final verdict byte-matches my live file.
+- Identifier scan of the added closeout lines: zero UUIDs, hosted links, home paths, token shapes, or `.pi` references; the receipt's zero-UUID claim for added lines is true.
+- Qualifications preserved as required: bounded single-trial recovery limits (owner-reported restart, inferred resume mode, worker-reported run count), WUI pending-acceptance label, drift exclusions (executive-update change, ms-agent-watch deletion, untracked skills stay local), live-launch readiness not established by publication tests, R1 rejection and failed fixture attempts retained in the record.
+
+## Conditions
+
+1. Register the six units as reviewed (`2da95540…`) after pin release, exactly as planned; any byte change requires re-review.
+2. The handoff to Jason stands as documented: bounded publication plus planned-recovery trial, #1497 open until he accepts or names a failed criterion. No owner acceptance is inferred by this verdict, and none of it advances held queues (registry, C1, ACT-1).
@@ -0,0 +1,42 @@
+# PUB-REC-FILBERT-FINAL-1 — final selective publication verdict
+
+Reviewer: Filbert (independent). Coordinator: Darkwing. Trial #1497. Authorship conflicts: none; I authored none of the 90 files' non-verdict content, and my five verdict files are included as reviewed evidence bytes (they match my live files exactly, including the appended WUI correction).
+
+## Verdict: APPROVED for selective publication
+
+Exact units: the 90-file snapshot `/tmp/pub-rec-final-review-f5br4ch4` at manifest SHA-256 `3f8e765bded8bbd66d791f7fb761cb6ee3c438b5318a115baa9cc9c0ec75d2e4`, plus two metadata units: the durable manifest `docs/plans/reviews/2026-09-08_publication-trial-final.sha256` (byte-identical to the snapshot SHA256SUMS; hashes to the same `3f8e765b…`) and the inventory `docs/plans/reviews/2026-09-08_publication-trial-final-inventory.json` (SHA-256 `1889871b5aace9d475204f666b95b6998ef28c06c6a77185fa28edeb6fc7babb`). Total 92. This verdict is a separate later receipt, not part of the pin. All 90 hashes verified before and after review; snapshot unchanged.
+
+## Aggregation and pin continuity
+
+Every one of the 90 files matches a prior frozen approval or is a declared new unit; zero mismatches:
+
+- 53 WUI files byte-match the approved `a585c1ee…` manifest, plus the coordinator-added `PUBLICATION.md` pending-acceptance label as a separate unit (the reviewed 53 are unchanged).
+- 15 source candidates byte-match the original launcher approval `8900faf1…`.
+- 6 source candidates byte-match the approved Sonnet R2 snapshot `c5ad6306…` (rocko launcher/README/CONTEXT, rocko test, agents README, darkwing SOUL).
+- The curated recovery summary byte-matches its approved `0e17757c…` pin.
+- Exactly one file differs from every prior pin: the trial plan, whose delta is a gates-status update (pending items replaced by the recorded outcomes, drift exclusions, and still-pending publication/owner acceptance). Every statement in that delta is consistent with the recorded verdicts.
+- R1 rejected Sonnet verdict preserved verbatim (`REQUEST CHANGES` present); the live first-failure fixture log is preserved as declared.
+
+## New-unit content review
+
+- `PUBLICATION.md` states the label accurately: pending owner acceptance, original draft with provisional defaults, owner feedback recorded but not implemented, no dashboards, candid-feedback framing, font OFL retention, excluded evidence not attached, no trademark, license, or accessibility-certification claims.
+- The launcher approval receipt accurately records my verdict, the hash re-verification, the preserved cosmetic duplicate, and the transport-only acknowledgement; it claims no push authority.
+- Shared logs and plan/status files (BUILD-LOG, SESSIONS, CURRENT, TOOLS) contain no credentials, hosted conversation links, or `.pi` paths. They do contain local session UUIDs, home-directory paths, and a fleet socket name — local-only identifiers with no access path published, consistent with the repository's existing published posture; raw session/transcript/state content remains excluded.
+- `/tmp` locators in published verdicts are historical evidence pointers, not attachments; raw local evidence is not published.
+- Exclusions verified structurally: no `skills/` paths among the 90 (both executive-update files and all live skill drift excluded), no raw Rocko checkpoint/inventory/recovery records, no nonallowlisted WUI evidence, no `.pi` content.
+
+## Live drift handling
+
+The unreviewed live changes (executive-update skill edit, ms-agent-watch deletion, six new untracked skill directories) are preserved uncommitted and excluded from publication. The prospective committed tree correctly retains the baseline tracked ms-agent-watch file. Nothing was restored, adopted, or staged by this review.
+
+## Prospective-tree verification
+
+I built my own disposable tree from the public Git baseline `3b7fd19d…` plus the 90-file overlay and reran both fixture suites: `node --test scripts/test-rocko-launch.mjs scripts/test-darkwing-launch.mjs` — 5 tests, 5 pass, 0 fail, exit 0. This independently reproduces the coordinator's corrected result. The coordinator's preserved first-run log ends in `EACCES` on the fixture's temporary SOUL copy (read-only export modes), matching the declared 4-pass/1-fail cause; it is correctly not counted as a passing test or a launcher failure.
+
+Procedural note, recorded honestly: my first overlay command failed to create its target directory and the fixture run fell through to the live drifted tree. It mutated nothing (the fixtures write only to temp roots; live `git status` shows pre-existing drift only) and its assertion failure is consistent with the declared missing-skill drift, which I confirmed directly (`skills/ms-agent-watch/SKILL.md` absent live). The 5/5 result above is from the correctly built disposable tree, not that incidental run, and I did not rerun against the live tree.
+
+## Conditions
+
+1. Publish exactly the 92 units at the identities above; any byte change requires new review.
+2. All prior conditions remain in force: WUI pending-acceptance labeling, raw runtime records local, recovery outcome bounded, no branding or product acceptance inferred.
+3. This approval covers the selective publication inventory only. Integration proceeds under the owner's publication mandate with applicable tests; no deployment, live change, push authority, or overall trial acceptance is granted or implied here. Jason's trial acceptance remains the open gate.
@@ -0,0 +1,25 @@
+# Publication receipt and owner acceptance handoff
+
+Issue #1497. Source publication commit: 29c1defe29e5793022e1d3820b265bfc0f7f628a, refactor. Parent: 3b7fd19d087226b1887bf017fc10ef16b044f6aa.
+
+## Verified integration
+
+Filbert independently APPROVED the final 90-file manifest 3f8e765bded8bbd66d791f7fb761cb6ee3c438b5318a115baa9cc9c0ec75d2e4 and two metadata units, exactly 92. Coordinator verified every live hash before staging, exact staged path set, then exact committed path set and byte equality. No other change was staged. Final reviewer verdict is a separate later receipt.
+
+Committed-tree archive, not drifted live dependencies: `node --test scripts/test-rocko-launch.mjs scripts/test-darkwing-launch.mjs` passed five tests, zero failures, exit 0. Log /tmp/pub-rec-committed-fixtures.log. This is source-fixture verification without model calls, not a fresh planned restart. Earlier independent prospective-tree runs also passed 5/5; failed disposable-mode/coordinator and wrong-directory/reviewer attempts remain disclosed in the final review records.
+
+`git push origin refactor` succeeded from 3b7fd19d to 29c1defe. Fresh `git ls-remote origin refs/heads/refactor` returned the full publication SHA above. No force push, other-branch merge, deployment or live launch.
+
+## Whitespace diagnostic qualification
+
+First full staged `git diff --cached --check` returned 2. Every diagnostic was confined to the three original reviewed font OFL notices: DM Sans and IBM Plex contain CRLF line endings; all three contain a trailing space in the upstream license text. No source defect or hash drift was found. Those licensed provenance bytes were deliberately retained exactly as reviewed rather than normalized. A path-scoped check excluding only the three OFL notices passed for every authored candidate. Full diagnostic log remains /tmp/pub-rec-final-whitespace.log. Do not report the full whitespace check as passing.
+
+## Exclusions and limits
+
+Raw checkpoint/inventory/recovery, private state, nonallowlisted WUI evidence, changed executive-update skill and note, local ms-agent-watch deletion, and additional untracked skills remain local. Existing baseline shared-log identifiers were not rewritten; added log/status lines contain zero UUID matches. The prospective committed tree retains its baseline watch skill; the live helper still references a locally deleted file, so publication tests do not establish live-launch readiness.
+
+WUI is a labeled pending-acceptance draft, not branding/design completion or dashboards. The planned restart demonstrates one bounded checkpoint recovery with owner-reported restart, inferred resume mode and worker-reported run count. No crash-recovery, authenticated incarnation or reliability guarantee.
+
+## Jason's acceptance
+
+Review the published recovery summary and its independent verdict, the Sonnet launcher review, and the labeled WUI draft. The requested decision is whether this bounded publication/planned-recovery trial meets the agreed outcome. No further restart is required for this handoff. #1497 remains open until Jason accepts or supplies a specific failed criterion. Registry work, C1 and ACT-1 remain held. Review-byte pinning applies to the original publication commit; later append-only closeout records do not rewrite that evidence.