From 22c00fa9cf52d696080b0859e752e361f6dc90cc Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Jason Woltje Date: Thu, 22 Oct 2026 05:20:53 -0500 Subject: [PATCH] duckworth: row 264a r5 static review (duckworth-0122) no blockers on Gizmoduck 5cb234285 --- .../duckworth/work/row264/REVIEW-r5-static.md | 59 +++++++++++++++++++ docs/SESSIONS.md | 1 + 2 files changed, 60 insertions(+) create mode 100644 agents/duckworth/work/row264/REVIEW-r5-static.md diff --git a/agents/duckworth/work/row264/REVIEW-r5-static.md b/agents/duckworth/work/row264/REVIEW-r5-static.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7a373ecb8 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/duckworth/work/row264/REVIEW-r5-static.md @@ -0,0 +1,59 @@ +# Row 264a (#1769) r5 static review (duckworth-0122) + +- Reviewer: Duckworth (Opus 5.5), 2026-10-22. +- Request: gizmoduck-0181 (10:16Z) and gizmoduck-0183 (10:19Z). +- Candidate: gizmoduck/row264-r5, tip 5cb234285 (c4c75b6b4 plus one BUILD.md commit), base 47a35bf43. The base is the origin/refactor tip, so there's no drift. +- Method: git reads, plus python3 -B -I on git blobs. Nothing ran. The runs wait for Sage's CLEAR. + +## Verdict: no blockers. Ready for the round 5 gate. C1-C3 apply at the manifest round. + +## Checks + +- **Range-diff against r4 (86f95bb27..e2968681e).** Commits 1-3 and 5-6 are `=`. Commit 4 is `!` (3055c6e59 → 55c32c66c, patch-id 4bf2d706 → a32d2b2d), as stated. Commits 7-9 and 5cb234285 touch only BUILD.md. None of the commits has an attribution line. +- **The 3k-3l step.** + - Each version label shifts by one: r4 3j/3k maps to r5 3k/3l. + - Under that mapping, r5's migrations/3k-3l.sql is the same text as r4's 3j-3k.sql. The copy tables are `*_3k`, and the op values are `legacy-3l` and `migration-3l` (sage-2415). + - The 0106 checks (1)-(7) carry over unchanged. + - The only migration file r5 adds is 3k-3l.sql. 236's 3j-3k.sql is untouched. +- **Schema.** + - The two diffs, 86f95bb27→e2968681e and 47a35bf43→5cb234285, have the same changed lines. So 264a's schema change is the same on both bases, and 236's gitea tables are untouched. + - store.mjs pins `3l` and cd685122…f162a, which matches schema.sql at the tip. + - fixtures/schema-3k.sql is the same blob as 47a35bf43's schema.sql (aba92408). sessions.test pins that hash, and its 3k engine checks that `3j-3k` is present and `3k-3l` is absent. + - Apart from the relabel and this hash pin, sessions.test matches r4. No assertion was dropped. +- **DEFAULT_SESSION.** + - At r4, threads.test:13-14, end-launch.test:14-15 and webui chat.test:11-12 closed their single-quoted strings at `'default'`, `'legacy-3k'` and `'migration-3k'`. Those three files could not parse. + - At r5 the quotes are `\'`, and all three blocks match message-filter.test:20-23. + - The two cli files use double quotes and were always fine. + - Static control: a quote walker over every changed .mjs flags all six r4 lines and none at r5. That covers only lines that start with a quote. The parse proof is the gate (C1). +- **TESTER_VERBS** (broker.mjs:124-130). 194's `instance.launch`, `instance.end` and `instance.request` come first, then `session.list` and `session.create`. tester-writes.test pins the same list in the same order. +- **message-filter.test.** + - `threadOf` now writes both DEFAULT_SESSION rows for each hand-made thread. + - `put` writes `message_threads(message,thread,session)` with session = thread id, the legacy default id. + - This is the 19th test file. Counted at the tip: 19 `*.test.mjs` plus fixtures/schema-3k.sql. +- **Writers.** + - Only two places insert into `thread_claims`, `thread_opens` or `message_threads`: broker.mjs (:4242, :5158, :5301, :5371) and 3k-3l.sql. Every one of them names a session. + - In other tests, the only session-less inserts are name-, spec- and usage-migration.test. They write old-version fixtures before migrating, as in r4. +- **Migration tests.** + - gitea-migration.test now reads its store after both steps. `rows()` skips `sessions` and `session_defaults`, and `master` filters out `later3l`. That's correct because neither the 3j fixture nor the 3i fixture has thread rows, so the rebuilt tables' extra columns can't change a row compare. + - grant- and account-migration filter both 236's objects and 264a's. +- **Pins.** + - schema.test counts 22 tables and 86 triggers. + - COUNTED (stack-release.sh:420) and LISTED (stack-release.test:861) add `sessions` and `session_defaults` in schema order. 236's `gitea_users`/`gitea_grants` stay in T46's untimed list. +- **Manifest.** 27 paths differ from the base, 26 outside agents/. That matches Gizmoduck's 27-path manifest. I haven't checked the fbaada6d digest. That's a manifest-round check. + +## Conditions for the manifest round + +- C1. threads.test, end-launch.test and webui chat.test have never run in any round. Each must run whole on its own with a nonzero pass count, zero fails, and every skip named. Sage's 2581 order covers this. +- C2. The log must show gitea-migration.test whole, all three 3j tests green on the 3l chain, and T45/T46 green in stack-release.test. +- C3. Re-run mutants M1-M3 on the committed bytes. No earlier round has a kill result, because the Runs section was empty through r4. + +## Notes (don't block) + +- N1. README says 87 triggers and schema.test says 86. The base had the same one-trigger offset (72/71), so this isn't new. +- N2. The 0107 item 2 (assistant.stop output lacks the session) is still with 264e, as ruled in 0108. + +## Next + +1. Sage grants the CLEAR, and Gizmoduck runs the round 5 gate (sage-2581). +2. Manifest round on 5cb234285 or a later tip. I check C1-C3 and the fbaada6d digest. +3. I record in a gap Sage names. --candidate must be the round's key, so I check queue show first. diff --git a/docs/SESSIONS.md b/docs/SESSIONS.md index da0bd31bb..fc35655b9 100644 --- a/docs/SESSIONS.md +++ b/docs/SESSIONS.md @@ -1462,3 +1462,4 @@ are never rewritten or removed; corrections are new entries. 2026-10-22T05:27Z | Duckworth (Opus 5.5) | row 277 (#1782) build early static look on Morgana c050bb90b, digest eedc783f (duckworth-0119) | no blockers, C1-C3 met, M1-M7 each have a killing test; approve waits on gate; N1-N2 | 2026-10-22T07:19Z | Duckworth (Opus 5.5) | row 280 (#1785) scratch sshd port design r1 (duckworth-0120), Rocko BUILD.md 22653ed8 on da5d3651d | approve with C1 (M2 on the injected random source, deterministic kill), C2 (regression asserts attempt one used P), C3 (X5 stub keeps ~30 s, exits once dir gone); N1 host-run remote sleeps :280/:372/:382/:437, N2 attempt log names, N3 live ports below range | 2026-10-22T07:54Z | Duckworth (Opus 5.5) | row 280 (#1785) manifest review (duckworth-0121), Rocko b765f5cb8 + packet d6c924764 on da5d3651d | approve, manifest 27806c05; C1-C3 met; M1/M2 assertion kills 4/4, repeats 2010/2010 + cli 1588/1588, 0 skips; N1 evidence tree size, N2 M2 kill range-bound, N3 evidence hook comment, N4 blank lines | +2026-10-22T10:20Z | Duckworth (Opus 5.5) | row 264a r5 static review (duckworth-0122), Gizmoduck 5cb234285 on 47a35bf43 | no blockers, ready for the gate; C1-C3 at the manifest round (three never-parsed files run whole, gitea-migration on 3l, mutants re-run) |