From 30644a3dd5d67cb00baf0bfe4f50d3103cb2f9cc Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Jason Woltje Date: Mon, 26 Oct 2026 13:02:39 -0500 Subject: [PATCH] docs: preserve real postlanding reviews and human factory policy scope --- BUILD-LOG.md | 8 + .../boyd-0063-exact-verdict.md | 18 + ...oyd-metadata-real-postlanding-verdict.json | 36 ++ .../boyd-real-postlanding-verdict.md | 52 +++ .../conditional-closure-plan-mos1917.json | 30 ++ .../work/postlanding-330-331/coordination.md | 22 ++ .../dewey-real-postlanding-verdict.md | 31 ++ .../filbert-real-postlanding-verdict.md | 71 ++++ .../gladstone-real-postlanding-verdict.md | 47 +++ .../journal-prefix-preservation.json | 16 + .../new-330-01-task-receipt.json | 12 + .../own-posting-route-inspection.json | 239 +++++++++++++ .../prepared-manifest.json | 142 ++++++++ .../queue-after-file-citations.json | 314 ++++++++++++++++++ .../queue-before-new-rounds.json | 278 ++++++++++++++++ .../queue-post-request-observation.json | 284 ++++++++++++++++ .../queue-verdict-file-note-receipts.json | 36 ++ .../repair-task-scope-index.json | 71 ++++ .../review-completion-summary.json | 21 ++ .../postlanding-330-331/task646-before.json | 40 +++ .../postlanding-330-331/task647-before.json | 40 +++ .../postlanding-330-331/task648-before.json | 40 +++ .../postlanding-330-331/task652-before.json | 40 +++ .../postlanding-330-331/task653-before.json | 40 +++ .../postlanding-330-331/task654-before.json | 40 +++ .../postlanding-330-331/task655-before.json | 40 +++ .../postlanding-330-331/task656-before.json | 40 +++ .../verified-review-files.json | 52 +++ .../task662-scope/scope-post-receipt.json | 25 ++ agents/sage/work/task662-scope/scope.md | 59 ++++ docs/SESSIONS.md | 8 + 31 files changed, 2192 insertions(+) create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/boyd-0063-exact-verdict.md create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/boyd-metadata-real-postlanding-verdict.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/boyd-real-postlanding-verdict.md create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/conditional-closure-plan-mos1917.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/coordination.md create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/dewey-real-postlanding-verdict.md create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/filbert-real-postlanding-verdict.md create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/gladstone-real-postlanding-verdict.md create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/journal-prefix-preservation.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/new-330-01-task-receipt.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/own-posting-route-inspection.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/prepared-manifest.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/queue-after-file-citations.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/queue-before-new-rounds.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/queue-post-request-observation.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/queue-verdict-file-note-receipts.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/repair-task-scope-index.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/review-completion-summary.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task646-before.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task647-before.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task648-before.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task652-before.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task653-before.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task654-before.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task655-before.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task656-before.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/verified-review-files.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/task662-scope/scope-post-receipt.json create mode 100644 agents/sage/work/task662-scope/scope.md diff --git a/BUILD-LOG.md b/BUILD-LOG.md index 67e9baf51..b912071b1 100644 --- a/BUILD-LOG.md +++ b/BUILD-LOG.md @@ -5808,3 +5808,11 @@ Before: agents can read the library; supporting-path and push-credential depende 2026-10-26 Sage Mos1864/1881 model join AFTER verification: reviewed330/331 product362893d043ff96fdd35f18e326cce683db031471/treea7f7fcd7fc2cc4ba06efad78627f5f04929a0740 has321whole-file native PASS plus actual FEDR7 1/1; originalR2 orchestratorrc1 counter defect preserved separately. Whole bus1349/model-proxy100/webui490 PASS on unchanged product. Final PIN8.0.42, config55, all4P4+4P2 exact named mutant kills and whole restored controls PASS. Counter independent Codex review found2P2, reproduced7RED then23/23fixtures GREEN; failclosed unknown/missing summary and either-format failures. Commit/tree recorded before/end same; all1968 current+committed inputs mapped49c162c99 before later artifacts. Source join fix isolates runner-safe vocabulary from host ProxyPage imports; exact graph expectations retained. Original setup/timeouts/cleanup failures preserved; no657/658 installed/backlog remains. Documented Poe acceptance alias is byte-identical tested helper, not separately executed. Authorized landing next; source frozen. 2026-10-26 Sage LANDING Mos1864/1881: origin/refactor52ba14c5f now contains product362893 plus map/evidence49c162c99 and documented acceptance alias. Canonicalrefactor fast-forwarded by CAS with only136 exact accepted paths restored; unrelated8Rocko staged deletions and all untracked preserved, source/index clean for packages/scripts. Product1968hashes still match before/end freeze. Full source641–643/row288 previously63ec/acd; now330/331 landed same authorized window with applicable gates complete. Actual queue331 done refused rc2: round3 no recorded Boyd/Dewey approval;330 remains Poe in-progress with no formal round. No review impersonation/bypass; metadata closure is separate hard-rule wait. Tasks655/656 comments1336/1337 exact wholebody/author13 GET-verified, remainOPEN;657/658backlog unchanged. Ops660 runner update1334 independently GET-verified; no heavy gate active/no VM selected. No further source or gate work needed for this landing. + +2026-10-26T17:51:50Z Dewey POST-LANDING REVIEW Mos1909/Mos1915 (retrospective review-phase receipt, not a build): BEFORE code already landed under1864 at52ba14c5f/product362893d04; historical round3 CHANGES and missing approvals preserved. AFTER independent source/original-task/evidence review saved agents/dewey/work/queue-331/postlanding-mos1909/REVIEW.md; sha256 ab7edcb484a32093e9cb541032def275665f1572aa97bb118d2742f1f29fa97c. Scoped APPROVE;646-648/652-655 FIXCONFIRMED,656 PARTIAL against broader original wording with matching-revoking-tmp/single-final-completion repair confirmed. All1968map inputs match current+committed product;339existing raw log hashes verified; relevant owner execution outcomes inspected with FED skip/dedicated native1/1 and original R2rc1 distinctions preserved. New findings none;657/658 remain backlog. FILE ONLY: no actual verdict comment, queue approval, task closure, source/helper/test changes, Node experiments or new gate. + +2026-10-26T17:56:44Z Filbert POST-LANDING REVIEW Mos1909/1915 #1828 row330 (retrospective review receipt): BEFORE product362893d04 already landed underMos1864 at52ba14c5f; canonicalround1 request4137/4138 failed pre-send, no comment/approval. AFTER independent static source/brief/evidence review APPROVE for landed originalP4 repairs/current-generation P2join; saved agents/filbert/work/queue-330/postlanding-mos1909/REVIEW.md sha256 0f93bc883f1db2d2e136323040eaff2ad79aa184fa5ab140c94a0ae906f70ffe. All1968committed mapped blobs/bytes/SHA256 match product/candidate/cited0e1dd0a95; current1966match plus2queue-tracking differences; all43 evidence hashes match. OriginalR2rc1 preserved separately from supplied321whole+FEDR7/native1 and completed package/PIN/config/eightmutant+restore phases. NEW-330-01 retiring-key Console metadata gap is task-ready separate follow-up only, no reopening/newgate. No test/helper/source edit or run, live/secret access, formalpost/queue mutation, commit/push/closure;657/658 BACKLOG unchanged. + +2026-10-26 | Sage | mos1884/#662 scope after330/331landing | ReadQ222/Q261/Q263 and659/660/662; posted bounded human-only factory settings/triage/defaulttwo-roundmandate/trackedno-exemptionflake scope with10acceptance criteria, task662comment1338 exactwholebody/author13GETverified. No implementation/review/gate launched.660c1335notready(review/merge, noVM); gatefacts1329/1334 retained; target integration/fullrunner confirmation follows readiness, no localfallback. Landedproduct/evidence unchanged;657/658backlog. + +2026-10-26 | Sage | Mos1909/1915/1917 real postlanding reviews | Boyd/Dewey/Filbert/Gladstone real authored candidate52ba verdictfiles independently byte/hash-verified, allAPPROVE scoped; Dewey656broaderPARTIAL retained. Formal330R1/331R4 requests failedpre-send/no comments or approvals; no borrowed/copied/mintedkeys. LegacyhelperGETname jason.woltje is NOT ownJarvis, ownslotabsent; rows tracking-open/#436, files cited via normalqueue. NewFilbertNEW-330-01 filedtask665 exactreadback, notlandingreopen/gate. Repair646-648/652-656 remainOPEN untilactualcomments;1917 conditionalbacklog routing retained. #662scope1338posted;660PR405REVISE/notready. Product1968inputs unchanged; no source/helper/test/gate edits/runs; peerjournal prefixes preserved. diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/boyd-0063-exact-verdict.md b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/boyd-0063-exact-verdict.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0a0e47d85 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/boyd-0063-exact-verdict.md @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +[from: boyd (48a3ae38-83aa-4d3f-9064-64e911ec4547) -> to: sage (1ef1e4f8-3ead-4208-beca-38f9f1add079) class=report re=Mos1909-row331 key=boyd-0063, 2026-10-26] +POST-LANDING R4 SOURCE/EVIDENCE RESULT: APPROVE for the originator repair findings assessed below at candidate52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1/product362893d043ff96fdd35f18e326cce683db031471. No new actionable finding from this scoped review. This is a REAL postlanding assessment; it does NOT rewrite round3 CHANGES c31707/rev4135 or pretend approval preceded landing under1864. No gate/code/helper/test edit, run, Node/proxy/live/credential/rawscratch access or queue operation. + +653 launcher R3-B1: FIXCONFIRMED. launcher144 now explicitly imports writeFileSync;519 enable publication can execute. model-managed-launch.test.mjs has five actual createLauncher controls: successful proxy preflight/0600 enable-before-spawn/bind/registered confined live runner, idle unarmed beyond budget, first silent real adapter turn -> trusted modelStall/normal exit, output cancellation/one timestamp, nonproxy, refused preflight and no-launch. Fixture forwards actual runtime methods and uses real confined runner; fake harness/local HTTP, not provider traffic. Committed model-join-r2-full-receipts row159 records5/5, zero skips/cancel/fail; unlike historical helper-only greens this reaches the missing-binding caller. This confirms the original high blocker, not every production model/provider configuration. + +654 pending-wrapper R3-L1: FIXCONFIRMED. New model-organization-pending whole4 explicitly asserts organization-busy while same-business first operation waits, second effects unchanged, first success and finally gate release, independent-business queue behavior, failed-first issue release and actor refusal. Receipt row66:4/4 zero skip/fail. Branch now at model-keys289; no refusal widening or reinterpretation of old file-lock organization-busy is needed. This was coverage-only/currently reachable; no invented pre-fix RED claim. + +655 hire cleanup ownership R3-L2: FIXCONFIRMED. instance-settings354-389 shares prepareHire between checkHire and actual hire; runtime546 dispatches internal read-only hireCheck. Wrapper model-keys295-307 checks before registration/HTTP; controller138-153 encloses check/ownership sample/issue/recheck/publish and failed-new-generation cleanup inside SAME exclusive slot. Listed duplicate refuses before any generation; queued preflight cannot acquire a failed hire generation before cleanup. Before-queue existed sampling is no longer hire cleanup authority. Whole model-hire-ownership18/18 row6 tests actual bound P survives duplicate H, shared duplicate/retired/definition/vars/authority refusals, queue and postHTTP revision changes, failed-cleanup revoking hold, preexisting retiring metadata and explicit-end-before-fire; zero skips/fail. Prior bound-consumer effect was latent atfff due653; this evidence exercises repaired actual launch path, not a claimed reproduction at brokenfff. No new stop authority. + +656 recognized tmp/final completion R3-L3: FIXCONFIRMED WITH EXPLICIT SCOPED ACCEPTANCE. Credentials271-327 uses private opaque current-epoch proof, strict private-directory/file identity+full-record snapshots, nofollow/nonblocking/bounded reads, recognized matching durable revoking final+optional matching tmp; model-keys69-102/171-195 checks fresh inventory before removal, confirms GET/PUT/GET and EVERY current+retiring401, prepares tmp cleanup and completes final once under unchanged writer path. Failed verification/unlink retains revoking cache/local intent; issue/reload/ref/hold/inflight/close invalidates proof. Generic remove569-585 skips only already-finished exact model proof and leaves unknown-file fence unchanged; this avoids a second final unlink on delete. Current completion/remove tests cover retry/invalidation/forged proof/directory epoch/mixed services. Source expressly disclaims pathname-unlink CAS against arbitrary same-UID replacement after final verification; no blanket model/tmp deletion authority. Receipts: model-tmp-recovery39/39; model-final-completion21/21; model-completion-remove21/21, zero skips/fail. Temp-only/no-final, corrupt/mismatched/unknown files and cold uncertain discovery remain refused, intentionally outside recognized proof—not a universal crash-file cleanup claim. Broader657/658 backlog remains OPEN, not closed by this confirmation. + +646 sandbox import-closure: FIXCONFIRMED for YOUR supplied exact historical acceptance. validation owns SAME four reexported bindings, only validateHeaderValue import; Broker loads validation, not common/PIN. Original exact two P2 individual ro code additions validation+first-output remain; purity/no-lazy/error-identity/recursive closure guards retained. Current joined P4 additionally imports pure proxy-page-vocabulary.mjs and adds precisely its runner code file (no imports or host data); this is a DISCLOSED later join, not falsely exactly-two additions to current joined tree. No hostProxyPage/common/PIN/secret/config/state/directory mount. Joined receipts validation3/3, project-runtime3/3, sandbox11/11, session13/13, confined marker2/2 support source; no assertion/deadline relaxation inferred. Not a new independent Q246 review or portability proof. + +647 original restart/grace B1: FIXCONFIRMED (12/12 restart receipts). Host-private checked boot+fresh+trusted-bound inventory survives Registry[]/endLaunch map deletion; uncertain discovery retains; checks at remote/local mutation boundaries remain; discovered-only cannot signal. 648 terminal proof M1: FIXCONFIRMED (7/7 terminal tests). Outer/runner independently sticky only after strict absence/reaped proof, same immutable snapshot guard remains; initial mismatches HOLD, synthetic reuse is not real OS reuse. 652 warm provenance/key-loss: FIXCONFIRMED for warm-context scope (key-loss13/13, provenance7/7). Staged exact eight-field validation commits only after whole same-instance view/bind/unpublished checks; after association loss prior proof permits strict terminal confirmation, never live-run stop/unknown bypass. Cold/unassociated/null-record and all-generation liveness remain limited/backlog. Related historical-cleanup M2 (task649 if that mapping remains): source still Broker-owned exact old unended actor/body proof, fixed host-lost/null end/release, no cap/modelRuns binding; cleanup17/17 and actual trusted IPC9/9 receipts, no-launch inert. D17 first-turn amendment (task650 if mapping): actual653 caller evidence now closes previous actual-caller-source-only limitation for fake harness + confined runner; no realprovider claim. + +EVIDENCE CHECKS MY OWN: independently rehashed all1968 tested-map source inputs against committed product362893d0, bytes/SHA all match; product treea7f7fcd... agrees and product->candidate packages/scripts delta empty. Read committed model-join-final-result and r2/full receipts; task rows above are actual whole-file rc0/no-skip records, not inferred from source counts. Final-result distinguishes321whole+dedicatedFED nativePASS from R2 orchestration rc1 counter defect; three native package phases1349/100/490 and config55 plus required named mutants/controls remain SEPARATE builder phases, not one invented orchestrator rc0. I did NOT reopen raw scratch hashes/TAP; parent raw/order/source-restoration audit remains attributed. Original scoped33 and pre-fixRED/stopped records remain historical, not new reviewer runs or composite acceptance. No deployment/liveprovider/globalcleanup/process/lock census; no broad657/658 recovery design or task edits. + +REQUIRED POSTING BOUNDARY: no actor Gitea identity configured/available per your supplied metadata finding; I will not search or borrow. Request Sage-attributed relay of THIS actual originator verdict (not fakeDewey/Claude) after actual canonicalround4/request/comment is durable. Please return exact request/candidate/round and my relay issuecomment/readback artifacts; I can verify then record own approve through separately authorized normal queue. NO approvalrecord attempted before realcomment; task closures require this real originator confirmation/comment and your workflow, not source counts. Until comment exists, these are my source task confirmations awaiting publication. diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/boyd-metadata-real-postlanding-verdict.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/boyd-metadata-real-postlanding-verdict.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..40f9ec065 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/boyd-metadata-real-postlanding-verdict.json @@ -0,0 +1,36 @@ +{ + "author": "Boyd", + "threadId": "48a3ae38-83aa-4d3f-9064-64e911ec4547", + "savedAtUTC": "2026-10-26T17:51:52Z", + "candidate": "52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1", + "product": "362893d043ff96fdd35f18e326cce683db031471", + "sourceMessage": "boyd-0063", + "verdict": "approve-scoped-source-repairs", + "canonicalVerdictRecorded": false, + "issueComment": null, + "taskClosurePerformed": false, + "sourceCapture": { + "path": "/home/jwoltje/.t3/worktrees/mosaic-stack/sage-fix-641-643-run4/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/boyd-0063-exact-verdict.md", + "bytes": 8275, + "sha256": "c1fa6fdac3cc69dc653448022ac6130cab7f7672b58f5980120799f7fc5cee58" + }, + "artifact": { + "path": "/home/jwoltje/.t3/worktrees/mosaic-stack/boyd-row298/agents/boyd/work/queue-331/POSTLANDING-r4-REVIEW.md", + "bytes": 10136, + "sha256": "3d070b329f2b9f03e4e7aefaad965cb01e64b1dfe7b44465d068e285bbc2e7b8" + }, + "scopeTasks": [ + 646, + 647, + 648, + 652, + 653, + 654, + 655, + 656 + ], + "preservedBacklog": [ + 657, + 658 + ] +} diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/boyd-real-postlanding-verdict.md b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/boyd-real-postlanding-verdict.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9a26f49d7 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/boyd-real-postlanding-verdict.md @@ -0,0 +1,52 @@ +# Row 331 post-landing originator review + +Author: Boyd (48a3ae38-83aa-4d3f-9064-64e911ec4547). +Saved UTC: 2026-10-26T17:51:52Z. +Verdict: APPROVE for the scoped repair findings below; no canonical approval recorded. +Candidate: `52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1`. +Product: `362893d043ff96fdd35f18e326cce683db031471`. +Authority: Mos1909 source review; Mos1915 artifact preservation. + +Scope: originator confirmation of landed repairs 653–656 and 646–648/652; +related historical cleanup/D17 responses are qualified in the verbatim report. +This is post-landing review: landing occurred first under Mos1864. Round-3 +CHANGES c31707/rev4135 remains historical evidence. It is not retroactively +converted into approval. At preservation, formal round-4 opening/request is +still pending; this file is not a queue receipt or issue comment. + +Evidence: committed Git objects at the exact candidate/product; +`agents/sage/work/fix-641-643-run4/model-join-final-result.json`, +`model-join-tested-product-map.json`, and committed whole-file receipts. +I independently checked all 1,968 map entries against product Git blobs. +Owner test receipts remain attributed evidence, not tests executed by Boyd. + +Limits: no code/helper/test/gate execution or edits, Node/proxy/provider traffic, +credentials, live data, raw scratch logs, or new recovery design. No global +cleanup/process census or all-generation liveness claim. Strict recognized +revocation recovery only; broader 657/658 remain backlog. No issue posting, +canonical verdict, repair-task closure, or deployment is authorized by this file. +Detailed per-task evidence and limits remain in the verbatim report below. + +## Verbatim actual Boyd report boyd-0063 + +Source capture SHA256: `c1fa6fdac3cc69dc653448022ac6130cab7f7672b58f5980120799f7fc5cee58`. +Observed capture bytes: 8275 UTF-8 bytes (measured, not inferred). + +[from: boyd (48a3ae38-83aa-4d3f-9064-64e911ec4547) -> to: sage (1ef1e4f8-3ead-4208-beca-38f9f1add079) class=report re=Mos1909-row331 key=boyd-0063, 2026-10-26] +POST-LANDING R4 SOURCE/EVIDENCE RESULT: APPROVE for the originator repair findings assessed below at candidate52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1/product362893d043ff96fdd35f18e326cce683db031471. No new actionable finding from this scoped review. This is a REAL postlanding assessment; it does NOT rewrite round3 CHANGES c31707/rev4135 or pretend approval preceded landing under1864. No gate/code/helper/test edit, run, Node/proxy/live/credential/rawscratch access or queue operation. + +653 launcher R3-B1: FIXCONFIRMED. launcher144 now explicitly imports writeFileSync;519 enable publication can execute. model-managed-launch.test.mjs has five actual createLauncher controls: successful proxy preflight/0600 enable-before-spawn/bind/registered confined live runner, idle unarmed beyond budget, first silent real adapter turn -> trusted modelStall/normal exit, output cancellation/one timestamp, nonproxy, refused preflight and no-launch. Fixture forwards actual runtime methods and uses real confined runner; fake harness/local HTTP, not provider traffic. Committed model-join-r2-full-receipts row159 records5/5, zero skips/cancel/fail; unlike historical helper-only greens this reaches the missing-binding caller. This confirms the original high blocker, not every production model/provider configuration. + +654 pending-wrapper R3-L1: FIXCONFIRMED. New model-organization-pending whole4 explicitly asserts organization-busy while same-business first operation waits, second effects unchanged, first success and finally gate release, independent-business queue behavior, failed-first issue release and actor refusal. Receipt row66:4/4 zero skip/fail. Branch now at model-keys289; no refusal widening or reinterpretation of old file-lock organization-busy is needed. This was coverage-only/currently reachable; no invented pre-fix RED claim. + +655 hire cleanup ownership R3-L2: FIXCONFIRMED. instance-settings354-389 shares prepareHire between checkHire and actual hire; runtime546 dispatches internal read-only hireCheck. Wrapper model-keys295-307 checks before registration/HTTP; controller138-153 encloses check/ownership sample/issue/recheck/publish and failed-new-generation cleanup inside SAME exclusive slot. Listed duplicate refuses before any generation; queued preflight cannot acquire a failed hire generation before cleanup. Before-queue existed sampling is no longer hire cleanup authority. Whole model-hire-ownership18/18 row6 tests actual bound P survives duplicate H, shared duplicate/retired/definition/vars/authority refusals, queue and postHTTP revision changes, failed-cleanup revoking hold, preexisting retiring metadata and explicit-end-before-fire; zero skips/fail. Prior bound-consumer effect was latent atfff due653; this evidence exercises repaired actual launch path, not a claimed reproduction at brokenfff. No new stop authority. + +656 recognized tmp/final completion R3-L3: FIXCONFIRMED WITH EXPLICIT SCOPED ACCEPTANCE. Credentials271-327 uses private opaque current-epoch proof, strict private-directory/file identity+full-record snapshots, nofollow/nonblocking/bounded reads, recognized matching durable revoking final+optional matching tmp; model-keys69-102/171-195 checks fresh inventory before removal, confirms GET/PUT/GET and EVERY current+retiring401, prepares tmp cleanup and completes final once under unchanged writer path. Failed verification/unlink retains revoking cache/local intent; issue/reload/ref/hold/inflight/close invalidates proof. Generic remove569-585 skips only already-finished exact model proof and leaves unknown-file fence unchanged; this avoids a second final unlink on delete. Current completion/remove tests cover retry/invalidation/forged proof/directory epoch/mixed services. Source expressly disclaims pathname-unlink CAS against arbitrary same-UID replacement after final verification; no blanket model/tmp deletion authority. Receipts: model-tmp-recovery39/39; model-final-completion21/21; model-completion-remove21/21, zero skips/fail. Temp-only/no-final, corrupt/mismatched/unknown files and cold uncertain discovery remain refused, intentionally outside recognized proof—not a universal crash-file cleanup claim. Broader657/658 backlog remains OPEN, not closed by this confirmation. + +646 sandbox import-closure: FIXCONFIRMED for YOUR supplied exact historical acceptance. validation owns SAME four reexported bindings, only validateHeaderValue import; Broker loads validation, not common/PIN. Original exact two P2 individual ro code additions validation+first-output remain; purity/no-lazy/error-identity/recursive closure guards retained. Current joined P4 additionally imports pure proxy-page-vocabulary.mjs and adds precisely its runner code file (no imports or host data); this is a DISCLOSED later join, not falsely exactly-two additions to current joined tree. No hostProxyPage/common/PIN/secret/config/state/directory mount. Joined receipts validation3/3, project-runtime3/3, sandbox11/11, session13/13, confined marker2/2 support source; no assertion/deadline relaxation inferred. Not a new independent Q246 review or portability proof. + +647 original restart/grace B1: FIXCONFIRMED (12/12 restart receipts). Host-private checked boot+fresh+trusted-bound inventory survives Registry[]/endLaunch map deletion; uncertain discovery retains; checks at remote/local mutation boundaries remain; discovered-only cannot signal. 648 terminal proof M1: FIXCONFIRMED (7/7 terminal tests). Outer/runner independently sticky only after strict absence/reaped proof, same immutable snapshot guard remains; initial mismatches HOLD, synthetic reuse is not real OS reuse. 652 warm provenance/key-loss: FIXCONFIRMED for warm-context scope (key-loss13/13, provenance7/7). Staged exact eight-field validation commits only after whole same-instance view/bind/unpublished checks; after association loss prior proof permits strict terminal confirmation, never live-run stop/unknown bypass. Cold/unassociated/null-record and all-generation liveness remain limited/backlog. Related historical-cleanup M2 (task649 if that mapping remains): source still Broker-owned exact old unended actor/body proof, fixed host-lost/null end/release, no cap/modelRuns binding; cleanup17/17 and actual trusted IPC9/9 receipts, no-launch inert. D17 first-turn amendment (task650 if mapping): actual653 caller evidence now closes previous actual-caller-source-only limitation for fake harness + confined runner; no realprovider claim. + +EVIDENCE CHECKS MY OWN: independently rehashed all1968 tested-map source inputs against committed product362893d0, bytes/SHA all match; product treea7f7fcd... agrees and product->candidate packages/scripts delta empty. Read committed model-join-final-result and r2/full receipts; task rows above are actual whole-file rc0/no-skip records, not inferred from source counts. Final-result distinguishes321whole+dedicatedFED nativePASS from R2 orchestration rc1 counter defect; three native package phases1349/100/490 and config55 plus required named mutants/controls remain SEPARATE builder phases, not one invented orchestrator rc0. I did NOT reopen raw scratch hashes/TAP; parent raw/order/source-restoration audit remains attributed. Original scoped33 and pre-fixRED/stopped records remain historical, not new reviewer runs or composite acceptance. No deployment/liveprovider/globalcleanup/process/lock census; no broad657/658 recovery design or task edits. + +REQUIRED POSTING BOUNDARY: no actor Gitea identity configured/available per your supplied metadata finding; I will not search or borrow. Request Sage-attributed relay of THIS actual originator verdict (not fakeDewey/Claude) after actual canonicalround4/request/comment is durable. Please return exact request/candidate/round and my relay issuecomment/readback artifacts; I can verify then record own approve through separately authorized normal queue. NO approvalrecord attempted before realcomment; task closures require this real originator confirmation/comment and your workflow, not source counts. Until comment exists, these are my source task confirmations awaiting publication. diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/conditional-closure-plan-mos1917.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/conditional-closure-plan-mos1917.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1cb608a14 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/conditional-closure-plan-mos1917.json @@ -0,0 +1,30 @@ +{ + "authority": "Mos1909/1915/1917", + "status": "conditional plan only; no task closure from file-only reviews", + "candidate": "52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1", + "confirmedAfterRealComment": [ + 646, + 647, + 648, + 652, + 653, + 654, + 655 + ], + "task656": { + "closeOnlyAfterActualPostedOriginatorConfirmation": true, + "confirmedScope": "matching durable revoking-final/tmp and single-final completion", + "unclaimedBacklogVerbatim": [ + "tmp-only or malformed partial-write recovery", + "same-UID final-syscall TOCTOU" + ], + "laterRouting": [ + "657 if tmp-only/malformed scope fits; otherwise new backlog task", + "new backlog task for same-UID final-syscall TOCTOU" + ], + "noExecutionNow": true + }, + "rows330331": "tracking-onlyOPEN; real verdict files cited, no actual queue approvals without real comments", + "tasks657658": "OPEN BACKLOG and no landing blocker", + "noNewGate": true +} diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/coordination.md b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/coordination.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f6915b06f --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/coordination.md @@ -0,0 +1,22 @@ +# Mos1909 post-landing review coordination + +Candidate: 52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1; product362893d043ff96fdd35f18e326cce683db031471; current code-equivalent tip0e1dd0a95ba6399a8f70e0412393cca2d28e07cd. + +Landing already occurred underMos1864. This review supplies real queue records; it neither retroactively invents approvals nor starts another gate. New findings receive separate tasks and do not reopen the landing. + +- Row331: actual claimantMagica asked to preserve round3, return toin-progress and request new round4 with actualBoyd/Dewey. Boyd48a3ae38 andDewey84fb346c are independently reading source/evidence. Actual postedrequest/candidate/round still required before verdictrecord. +- Row330: actual claimantPoe asked to request first formal round withFilbert048f3c63 andGladstone433058fc. Poe coordinates their actual review; no duplicate review threads. +- Repair646: runner dependency closure, pure validation/erroridentity; nohostcommon/PIN/secretmount expansion. +- Repair647: persisted-session/whole-instance identity view protects retiring generations, unknown/readerror holds, no-launch retained. +- Repair648: distinguish previously verified dead process/PIDreuse from corruptinitial discovery withoutstopauthority. +- Repair652: lostoldcurrent association and later retirement, strict warmidentity/terminal proof, separate metadata/remoteabsence. +- Repair653: actual launcherfs import and actual managedproxylaunch caller control. +- Repair654: exactpending organization-busy branch and controls; no inventedRED. +- Repair655: serialized read-only shared validation, capturedR0locked publication and genuinely new-unpublished ownership cleanup, bound consumer and queue controls. +- Repair656: recognizedexactmatchingtmp/durable revoking intent, strict readers, allkey401/fresh checkedviews, singlefinalunlink before cacheclear and composite removeproof; broaderunknown/onlytmp/differing remains separatelybacklogged. + +Each task staysOPEN until its actual finding originator confirms the applicable fix with a citeable realcomment. Reviewers reportFIXCONFIRMED/PARTIAL/OPEN, actual source/evidence and scopedlimits. Sourceproof is not a fresh run; historical scopedGREEN is not broadened. + +No agent/source/helper/assertion/deadline changes, no tests/gates, no review-actor impersonation, token borrowing, queue/credential bypass or old receipt relabeling. Canonical protectedqueue commits use designatedqueue-commit procedure only. Unknown/failed posting is retained with actualtransport outcome and never countedposted. + +#662 scope was posted before arrival ofMos1909 (comment1338, exactbody/author13GETverified); further implementation is not started. #660 provisioning PR405 isREVISE/notready, no gate there. Those follow these reviews. #657/#658 stayOPENBACKLOG. diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/dewey-real-postlanding-verdict.md b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/dewey-real-postlanding-verdict.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..916e00fce --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/dewey-real-postlanding-verdict.md @@ -0,0 +1,31 @@ +# Row 331: Dewey post-landing source/evidence review + +Author: Dewey +Completed UTC: 2026-10-26T17:51:50Z +Full candidate: 52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1 +Product: 362893d043ff96fdd35f18e326cce683db031471 +Authority: Mos1909; file delivery/tracking boundary Mos1915 +Delivery: FILE ONLY. No verdict comment posted, no queue approval recorded by Dewey. A durable request comment and proper posting route remain prerequisites to recording. No copied, borrowed or minted seat keys. + +Dewey — actual POST-LANDING review of row 331 under Mos1909. + +Review target: candidate `52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1`, product `362893d043ff96fdd35f18e326cce683db031471`, tree `a7f7fcd7fc2cc4ba06efad78627f5f04929a0740`. Checkout `0e1dd0a95` has the same packages/scripts product. Landing came FIRST under Mos1864. This review does not replace round-3 CHANGES or claim approval before landing. + +Verdict: APPROVE the scoped post-landing repairs. No new actionable finding in this review. Task 656 remains PARTIAL against its broader original wording, with the exact matching-tmp and single-final-completion repair confirmed below. This existing limit does not reopen the landing or request a gate. + +I independently read the original task646–648/652–656 descriptions captured in Sage's `postlanding-330-331/task*-before.json`, the row331 brief, landed implementations and regression fixtures. This is my own Dewey assessment, not a relay or a replacement for Boyd's or the original Claude reviewer's confirmation. + +| Task | Status | Source/evidence reason and qualification | +| --- | --- | --- | +| 653 | FIXCONFIRMED | `packages/cli/src/launcher.mjs:144` imports `writeFileSync`, used by the 0600 exclusive enable publication at519. `model-managed-launch.test.mjs` exercises actual `createLauncher`, successful owned local preflight, enable-before-spawn, real confined runner registration/binding, idle unarmed, first silent actual adapter turn through trusted runtime stall/normal exit, output cancellation/no reset, nonproxy, refused preflight and no-launch. Its existing whole-file log is 5/5, zero skips. This confirms the missing binding and managed caller path, with a fake harness/local proxy, not production provider behavior. | +| 654 | FIXCONFIRMED | `modelOrganization` retains the per-business pending check and finally release; `model-organization-pending.test.mjs` deliberately holds real management HTTP, asserts exact `organization-busy` before second-operation effects, preserves/completes the first call, covers independent businesses, error release and actor refusal. Existing whole file4/4, zero skips. Coverage-only finding; no invented pre-fix RED or changed refusal semantics. | +| 655 | FIXCONFIRMED | `instance-settings.mjs:354–391` shares `prepareHire` between read-only check and actual publication. `model-keys.mjs` checks before model effects and performs check/ownership sample/issue/recheck/publish/failed-new-generation cleanup inside ONE exclusive controller slot (`hire`,138–155). Queued acquisition cannot take that failed generation before cleanup; existing-record cleanup is not inferred from a pre-queue sample. Whole `model-hire-ownership.test.mjs`18/18, zero skips: actual bound consumer survives concurrent duplicate hire, preexisting retiring metadata is unchanged, queue/post-HTTP revision changes refuse, genuine unpublished generation cleans before queued acquisition, failed cleanup retains revoking admission fence, and explicit exit precedes ordinary fire. The old bound-consumer consequence was conditional and latent behind653 atfff; I do not rewrite that history as a measured old reproduction. No new stop authority. | +| 656 | PARTIAL | Narrow repair FIXCONFIRMED: `credentials.mjs:219–327` requires bounded no-follow regular single-link owner0600 files, private0700 directory identity, complete matching revoking metadata/cache, and opaque instance/epoch proof. ModelKeys checks authoritative run absence and remote removal/401 for every current/retiring key before local completion. Tmp removal is verified; final removal performs ONE unlink, then memory-only bookkeeping, with no fallible filesystem/callback after success. Generic remove skips only the exact finished model proof; unknown-file fence and nonmodel behavior remain. Existing tmp-recovery39/final-completion21/completion-remove21 logs total81/81, zero skips, including real fire/delete, reboot, live/uncertain identities, replacement/read/unlink failures and proof invalidation. Broader original partial-write/tmp-only recovery is not solved: missing final cannot mint proof, malformed/nonmatching tmp refuses, and same-UID final-syscall TOCTOU is explicitly outside the guarantee. Valid-final rewrite/issue retry can self-repair as in the original qualified finding; no manual-only claim. This does not certify full original task656 closure. 657/658 remain BACKLOG and their drafts were not installed. | +| 646 | FIXCONFIRMED | Broker imports parsing-only `validation.mjs`; common reexports the same error/helper identities. `RUNNER_FILES` includes validation and first-output, excludes common/PIN/proxy state and broad directory mounts. Purity guards and exact transitive closure remain; existing validation3/3, sandbox11/11 and actual confined-marker2/2 logs have zero skips. No additional data access is used to repair closure. | +| 647 | FIXCONFIRMED | `runtime.mjs:131–228` inventories persisted identities before reconciliation/timer work; Registry-empty rewrites cannot erase known runs, failed boot discovery stays refusing, outer and runner identities are checked separately, and stop requires an existing matching binding. ModelKeys retains before grace and on failed discovery/stop, rechecks before remote mutation and before metadata deletion. Existing restart12/12 and retirement-boundary2/2 logs cover no-launch, recovery gap, malformed/missing discovery, identity disagreement, stop refusal, exit and in-flight discovery failure. Owned sleep identities establish retention/refusal; they are not proof of every actual runner rotation shutdown. | +| 648 | FIXCONFIRMED | Independent monotonic outer/runner terminal bits record only strict absence or same-start zombie, survive stale Registry and later synthetic PID reuse, and do not interpret an initial identity mismatch as exit. Existing terminal-proof7/7 includes corrupt-key/ticks and live counterpart controls. Synthetic reuse follows observed/reaped owned exits; actual OS PID wraparound or reuse before exit observation is not claimed. Unobserved ambiguity remains fail-closed. | +| 652 | FIXCONFIRMED | Whole-view `validated` provenance is committed only after all same-instance identity/binding checks succeed (`runtime.mjs:187–214`). A previously validated exact identity whose key association disappears can acquire strict exit proof; a surviving unassociated run still refuses. Failed whole views, initial corrupt metadata, changed immutable identities and partial exits grant no permission. Existing key-loss-interaction13/13 and key-provenance7/7 cover ensure/rotate, stale/empty Registry, separate exits, no-run, proof controls and read/tick failures. No absent key is restored or invented as retiring, and no new stop permission is granted. | + +Evidence qualification: I independently byte/hash-checked all1,968 entries of `model-join-tested-product-map.json` against BOTH current files and committed product blobs: no discrepancies. I also verified bytes/SHA256 of all339 raw logs referenced by the R2-full, completion and final phase receipts, and inspected the relevant raw named-case outcomes. These are existing OWNER executions, not tests I ran. The321-file loop's aggregate federation file reports one skip; the separate native FEDR7 log supplies1/1. Whole package1349/100/490, PIN/config and mutant phases remain separate evidence; original R2 orchestrator rc1/counter defect is preserved, not rewritten into one clean orchestrator result. `model-join-final-result.json` states these distinctions. + +No source/helper/test/gate edits or test/Node experiments. No new task or landing/gate reopening. This real Dewey-authored FILE may be cited for exactly the confirmations above; it is NOT an actual issue comment and must not be represented as one; it does not impersonate another finding originator or close any task. Mos1909's originating-reviewer confirmation requirement still applies, and656 must retain the broader qualification. diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/filbert-real-postlanding-verdict.md b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/filbert-real-postlanding-verdict.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..28d44c172 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/filbert-real-postlanding-verdict.md @@ -0,0 +1,71 @@ +# Filbert: row 330 post-landing review + +AUTHOR: Filbert, thread 048f3c63-074d-4bd6-9c0e-32c80b151c38; current provider Codex, gpt-6.1-sol. +CANDIDATE: 52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1 +PRODUCT: 362893d043ff96fdd35f18e326cce683db031471 +CURRENT_REFACTOR_CHECKED: 0e1dd0a95ba6399a8f70e0412393cca2d28e07cd +TIME: 2026-10-26T17:56:44Z +VERDICT: APPROVE, scoped to the landed original row 330/P4 repairs and current-generation P2 metadata integration. +FORMAL_POSTING: NOT POSTED. No Gitea comment, queue review record, or task closure is claimed. + +This is my actual independent landing-review verdict under the delivered Mos1909/1915 assignment. Landing already occurred under Mos1864. The new finding below is separate task-ready evidence; it does not reopen that landing, prescribe a new gate, or convert historical PASS/CHANGES into current approvals. This is not an approval of the entirety of row 331 or its broader recovery claims. #657 and #658 remain BACKLOG. + +## Scope, identity and independent checks + +I read the replacement brief docs/plans/2026-10-24_proxy-page-brief.md, the model-proxy design and applicable rows rules, Poe's committed BUILD.md/REVIEW.md at d9a564e6d, the landed source/tests, and Sage's committed evidence. The original #1828 is the issue for this review. Earlier Gladstone scoped PASS on b47ee2c0e remains historical with its stated P2/gate limitations; this verdict is my own source assessment of 52ba14c5f. + +The candidate, product and cited current refactor have identical packages trees: 473fb6dcfd6da073bfe179002b8ca990b937daf0. The packages/scripts/contracts/roles comparisons between these commits contain no differences. P4's page/HTTP/browser logic matches Poe's d9a564e6d source; the page vocabulary was extracted into a pure module and the shared management client additionally gained P2 probeKey. I read these integration changes rather than carrying the earlier verdict forward by name. + +I independently read every mapped Git blob and checked its byte count, SHA256 and identity at all three commits: 1,968/1,968 match model-join-tested-product-map.json. The current working files match 1,966/1,968; the two differences are docs/plans/QUEUE.md and queue.json, containing post-landing coordination. I did not repair them. All 43 landing-evidence-manifest.json artifact byte counts and hashes match. Both documented Poe acceptance aliases are byte-identical to the executed Sage helpers. These are read-only identity checks, not fresh test executions. + +Queue next returned review row 330, with an existing view-unknown warning. Reading queue.json confirms claimant Poe, round 1 candidate 52ba14c5f, operation poe-330-postlanding-round1-20261026, revs 4137/4138, failed pre-send credential/account check, null comment and no review receipts. I made no queue mutation or credential request. + +## Source assessment + +All source citations below refer to the candidate; those bytes also match the checked current refactor. + +- Human-only bus boundary: packages/bus/src/broker.mjs:4817-4831 dispatches only PROXY_PAGE_VERBS and calls #human before configuration/page work. #human at :1135 requires a CLI human capability with outsideAgent true; agent/tester/granted-user capabilities cannot acquire this path. Runtime's absent-page callback returns not-configured. The special path does not clone/trail a key or callback URL. Asynchronous errors are reduced to locally allowlisted codes; #refused at :4795 records a code, not request content. proxy-page.test.mjs separately covers each verb/caller/refusal. +- Owner-only Console: packages/webui/src/serve.mjs:703-770 checks named Host/proxy proof and owner sign-in before the P4 branch. userRoute at :56 excludes /proxy, /proxy.js and /api/proxy/; granted users stop before owner transport use. Tester and loopback access refuse. packages/webui/src/proxy-http.mjs:18-50 fixes path/method/argument names, bounds JSON bodies, and requires --send, exactly one own Origin and exactly one same-origin sec-fetch-site for POST. console-bus.mjs:12-19 restricts the transport to eight proxy verbs. No P4 module opens a management connection in the Console. The HTTP tests exercise owner/granted/tester/no-send and origin/metadata refusals. The parsed architecture test guards client imports, while direct source inspection establishes the proxy-setting separation. +- Accounts and priorities: packages/bus/src/proxy-page.mjs:18-60 constructs exactly accountId/provider/displayName/status/priority. OAuth id uses upstream id; API-key id uses auth_index, with no fallback to hashing api-key. Arbitrary labels/emails/group names are not reflected. Provider/status are enumerated and display names are generated. Priority requires an integer -1000..1000 and exactly one matching account. OAuth writes use {name,priority}; API-key writes update provider config. Both re-read priority before reporting success (:139-158). The management client strips response-only auth_index before PUT. Account tests cover toxic fields, both identifier/priority paths, refused/no-op writes and value-free receipts. +- OAuth: proxy-page.mjs:62-124 binds pending state to human/business, expires it after the trusted 300-second default and retires terminal/cancelled state. Start accepts only Claude/Codex and validates the returned HTTPS provider host, state and bounded URL. Callback input is bounded/parsed and must carry one pending state before management submission. Callback acceptance always returns wait; only an upstream status ok completes sign-in. Terminal upstream error bodies are replaced with fixed reasons. The state tests check unknown, foreign, expired, finished and cancelled states and wait-versus-ok. The browser uses noopener/noreferrer and clears callback/link state locally. +- Upstream API keys and client transport: proxy-page.mjs:126-137 accepts z.ai only and 1..4096 printable nonspace ASCII bytes, serializes provider read/modify/write, forwards the value once, and returns only added:true. Browser proxy.js:93-101 clears the password input before awaiting the request and uses no storage. packages/model-proxy/src/client.mjs:10-47 fixes numeric 127.0.0.1 HTTP, refuses port8317/redirects, uses only Authorization for the management key, bounds response bytes/time, discards refused bodies, sanitizes network errors and never retries. Its :67-93 receipts exclude queries and bodies. Narrow fresh-provider GET404 normalization at :74 retains the actual404 receipt and does not turn other endpoints/statuses or malformed200 bodies into success. Dedicated negative tests preserve those refusals. +- Canary evidence and its limits: webui/tests/proxy-canary.test.mjs sends the made-up key over real HTTP through a real human capability/broker/page/client to a fake management listener. It asserts one fake receipt and scans HTTP output, captured stdout/stderr, Console logs, management receipts and fixture Store files. The separate OAuth case scans fixture bus records/receipts for URL/state/code. These are synthetic fixture checks, not proof over live proxy logs, provider behavior, all possible credential strings or production storage. +- P2 join: runtime.mjs:328-334 obtains Credentials.status metadata, filters by model service and the current business, and passes only keyId/agent/issuedAt/state into P4. proxy-page.mjs:161-172 hashes remote values and returns IDs, sentinel/foreign labels and matched metadata, with no value or write verb. proxy-model-join.test.mjs:5-16 exercises the real runtime projection with a seeded current model record and a value-free result. It deliberately does not claim real issuance/ownership proof. P2's broader lifecycle coverage is distinct from this integration check. See NEW-330-01 for an uncovered retiring-generation case. + +I found no change request against the landed original P4 fixes. The source supports the human/owner and non-reflection boundaries above; passing counts alone are not the basis of APPROVE. + +## Supplied execution evidence, not executions by Filbert + +Evidence root: agents/sage/work/fix-641-643-run4/. + +- model-join-r2-full-receipts.json contains 321 whole-file rows, all recorded rc0, plus dedicated FEDR7. model-join-r2-independent-audit.json reports actual FEDR7 native 1/1 and verifies raw hashes. Original R2 events still end with stopped/RED FEDR7 dedicated acceptance: its TAP-only counter had recorded the spec result as zero. I preserve that orchestrator rc1 distinction and do not relabel it a single green run. The inherited FED skip and dedicated native run are distinct evidence. +- completed-packages-independent-audit.json records complete bus1349/model-proxy100/webui490, zero fail/skip/cancel, on unchanged product. The recorded gate source sets MOSAIC_REQUIRE_EDITOR_BUILD=1. This does not imply every repository package or every shell suite was rerun in the model-join phase. +- model-join-final-result.json remainingPhases equals model-join-final-receipts.json rows exactly. These record PIN8.0.42 offline acceptance rc0 and config55/55, plus all four exact P2 mutant failures with restored whole-file controls30/30. The P2 named failures concern confirming GET, foreign-key preservation, rejecting401 and revoking reconcile. Counter/helper repairs and their independent review are a separate tools phase; no product change is inferred. +- The four P4 mutants have named behavioral failures, restored source and positive whole-file controls: unfiltered account field 2 failures/control10; skipped callback state 2/control17; granted-user route 1/control11; API-key log leak 1/control2. This is stronger evidence than an unexplained nonzero exit. Earlier priority-measurement false kills remain historical, not counted here. +- PIN acceptance is offline with fabricated credentials and a private namespace. Its source exercises initial empty accounts, both provider starts, made-up callbacks never completing, cancel, first z.ai key, both priority read-backs and IDs-only keys. It proves pinned endpoint compatibility in that fixture, not a successful real-provider login or live cutover. The documented Poe alias was not separately run. + +I ran no test, mutant, acceptance helper, Node experiment or gate. I did not inspect another seat's raw scratch log directories or live credential/config/proxy/store. My execution assessment is of the committed receipts, audit statements, test assertions and runners, not an independent remeasurement of their scratch raw logs. Scope does not include deployment, production first-start, global cleanup/process census, broader recovery or arbitrary same-UID TOCTOU guarantees. + +Evidence identities independently matched: +- model-join-tested-product-map.json: 6b3cbbac40a50121f1a234ed4690d4ea559b2b7ca1e80a3caabb9e04632cd4e2 +- landing-evidence-manifest.json: 6a68fa7fe0d586b54aaf16b9f8951efd06c70ff19923d70664cfd178e09a4438 +- model-join-final-result.json: 4400a81d879790a7d4eb6add8bf07e368fd1fbc6dff6989c6629ecf9bdeb4827 +- model-join-final-receipts.json: 5aeda9288f418bc5990eec7495b84b8034023b140015cf46ea773baf29f4f378 + +## NEW-330-01: retiring client keys lose Console metadata + +Disposition: NEW task-ready evidence only, medium priority, owner recommendation Poe with P2 coordination. Not a new landing gate or reopening; no issue was filed and no patch/test was authored. This finding is independent of #657/#658, which remain backlog. + +Suggested title: Preserve retiring-generation ownership metadata in the Console client-key list. + +Trigger: a managed model key rotates while a run still uses its old generation. ModelKeys.#issue (packages/bus/src/model-keys.mjs:124-127) retains the old key remotely and in record.retiring with its keyId and issuedAt. sweep at :212-218 deliberately keeps it while a run is live within grace. The existing model-keys.test.mjs:127 rotation test asserts that old-key retention. + +Defect: Credentials.status at credentials.mjs:662-664 exposes the retiring key's safe keyId/issuedAt/retireAt, but runtime.mjs:332-333 maps only the current generation and discards retiring. ProxyPage.request at proxy-page.mjs:168-171 finds metadata by keyId in that flattened current-only list. Consequently an old key still legitimately used by a live run appears as stack-managed with agent:null, issuedAt:null and state:null. The owning agent and issue time are already known; the page simply loses them. This is an observability gap, not evidence of a credential leak or bypass of revocation. I established the path statically; I did not run a reproduction. + +Existing coverage limit: proxy-model-join.test.mjs seeds one current record and tests only record.keyId. The fake projection test in proxy-page-accounts.test.mjs also provides only one current metadata row. Neither covers a retained generation. + +Bounded follow-up: project current and retiring safe metadata for this business into the page, with an explicit retirement state chosen within the existing read response contract; retain per-generation issue time, no credential values and no new page write. Future acceptance should keep a real runtime old generation through rotation, verify both rows identify the same agent with their own issue times, verify retirement status and no key values, then verify the old row disappears after normal retirement. No new execution or implementation is authorized by this suggested task text. + +## Delivery and records + +This file is the actual authored verdict. Wait for the working formal actor route before posting or recording it. No borrowed/copied/minted key, fake comment or queue receipt was used. Prior historical verdicts, original rc1, #655/#656 scoped limits and #657/#658 backlog remain intact. No source/helper/test changed, no commit or push, no closure or deployment. diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/gladstone-real-postlanding-verdict.md b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/gladstone-real-postlanding-verdict.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4f8e60816 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/gladstone-real-postlanding-verdict.md @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +# Row 330 / P4 actual post-landing first review + +AUTHOR: Gladstone (Codex gpt-6.1-sol), thread 433058fc-9cea-46e3-8554-6ddefb312762 +CANDIDATE: 52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1 +PRODUCT: 362893d043ff96fdd35f18e326cce683db031471 +TIME: 2026-10-26T17:53:18.755413+00:00 +VERDICT: APPROVE +SCOPE: landed row330/P4 original issues, security boundary and P2 metadata join; actual post-landing review under the delivered Mos1909/1915 instruction. +FORMAL POSTING: NOT POSTED. This authored file is the verdict, not a server comment or approval receipt. + +I found no unresolved change request in the inspected landed P4 scope. This is my own source-based verdict, not an adoption of another review or an inference from pass counts. Landing already occurred under Mos1864; this verdict does not reopen it or order another gate. + +## Source assessment + +Read committed blobs with git show, not another seat's live checkout. Compared the previously reviewed b47ee2c0ef6580175e8fdd617878c4644861350e with this candidate and inspected the landed boundary and P2 join directly. + +- packages/bus/src/broker.mjs:4823-4832 retains the early eight-verb branch, #human gate, owner business/human scope, and enumerated error-code sanitization. It bypasses generic request-content persistence for write-only values. #human and bindHuman require the trusted CLI owner transport; agent/tester/granted-user capabilities do not satisfy it. +- packages/webui/src/serve.mjs:735-770 authenticates the named owner before the proxy route; granted users stop at userRoute and lose the owner proxy caller. Tester and unnamed/loopback requests refuse. packages/webui/src/proxy-http.mjs:25-48 requires --send, exactly one matching Origin and same-origin Fetch Metadata on POST, bounded JSON with exact fields, and fixed route/verb dispatch. Logs omit query/body/error text. Console wiring retains only the human-transport allowlist. +- packages/bus/src/proxy-page.mjs:34-64 copies exactly accountId/provider/displayName/status/priority into public accounts. IDs hash OAuth id or API-key auth_index, never a key fallback. Generated display names and enumerated provider/status values prevent arbitrary credential labels from being reflected. Priority validates integer range and unique account match, then verifies read-back; unconfirmed writes refuse. +- proxy-page.mjs:66-127 checks pending state syntax, human/business ownership and expiry; callback URLs are bounded and parsed, with one state. A submitted callback returns wait, never login success. Only upstream status ok completes sign-in. Finished/cancelled states are deleted. OAuth authorization URLs require the provider's HTTPS hostname and matching state. +- proxy-page.mjs:129-142 validates the z.ai-only key, passes it in provider-config writes and returns only added:true. Serialized provider read-modify-write avoids competing local page writes. packages/webui/src/public/proxy.js clears key/callback inputs before awaiting, uses textContent rather than HTML insertion, uses noopener/noreferrer, and has no browser storage or automatic write retry. +- packages/model-proxy/src/client.mjs:18-94 uses fixed numeric loopback, management Authorization header, no redirects/retries, bounded response reads and body-free receipts. Non-success response bodies are destroyed. The absent-provider exception remains ONLY GET /v8/management/config/api-keys/claude with HTTP404, returning [] while retaining the actual404 receipt. Other endpoints/methods/statuses refuse, and malformed200 null/object cannot pass the page's array checks. PUT strips response-only auth_index metadata. P2's added probeKey uses the client key, not the management key, on /v1/models and emits ids-only receipts. +- The vocabulary extraction into packages/bus/src/proxy-page-vocabulary.mjs is data-only. It preserves the verb/refusal lists while avoiding pulling the page/client dependency into parsing-only consumers. The production Console architecture test still checks for transitive management-client imports. + +## P2 join assessment + +The earlier review explicitly left this join provisional. It is now backed by actual runtime/store code and a dedicated join control: + +- packages/bus/src/runtime.mjs:310-336 constructs Credentials with model agents, creates ModelKeys with the same management client/configDir, and supplies ProxyPage keyRecords from Credentials.status(). It filters service=model and the exact business/ prefix, then projects keyId, role suffix as agent, issuedAt and state. The instance tag is sha256(organization.dir) first12, matching the configDir-derived sentinel namespace. +- packages/bus/src/credentials.mjs:650-680 returns model keyId/issuedAt/state and metadata-only retiring entries; it does not return the model key value. P4's key view hashes the management list values in memory, joins by keyId and emits only id, management label and selected metadata. No key write is added to the page. +- packages/bus/tests/proxy-model-join.test.mjs asserts the real runtime view equals the seeded P2 record's id/agent/issuedAt/valid state and excludes the value. Its own comment correctly limits this to read/join evidence, not issuance or ownership proof. I do not extend that test's claim to all lifecycle behavior. Existing account, state, HTTP, architecture, browser and canary tests exercise the actual P4 implementation and its refusal/projection paths. + +## Evidence identity and limits + +Independently verified every one of the 1968 rows in committed agents/sage/work/fix-641-643-run4/model-join-tested-product-map.json against candidate git blobs: byte length, SHA256 and git object ID all match. No mismatches. Candidate, product and cited current refactor0e1dd0a95 have identical packages tree 473fb6dcfd6da073bfe179002b8ca990b937daf0. This proves input identity, not execution by me. + +Read committed model-join-final-result.json. It records distinct phases: actual321 whole files plus dedicated FEDR7; native whole-package bus1349/1349, model-proxy100/100 and webui490/490 with zero skip/cancel; PIN8.0.42 acceptance and config55/55; four P4 killed mutants with restored positive controls; and four P2 killed mutants with restored controls. The committed model-join-completion-gate.mjs sets MOSAIC_REQUIRE_EDITOR_BUILD=1. Mutant failure names correspond to unfiltered account output, skipped callback state check, granted-user route access and key logging, so those are relevant security controls rather than unrelated green counts. + +These are supplied committed receipts. I did not execute tests, acceptance, mutants, a proxy, gates or live-provider calls, and did not independently re-read/hash the raw scratch logs named by the receipts. I do not claim one successful global orchestrator run: original R2 rc1 from the TAP-only/spec-counter defect remains a separate preserved result, as do earlier failures/corrections. The unrelated full-gate4-result.json names an earlier candidate and is not substituted for the integrated product's distinct-phase evidence. + +## Historical and operational boundaries + +My gladstone-0028 scoped PASS on b47ee2c0e remains historical, with its original then-unmet P2/gate/review limits. Prior PASS/CHANGES records from any reviewer remain historical; this file does not rewrite or fabricate them. The present approval addresses landed P4 and its actual P2 join using the identified source/evidence. It does not retroactively claim that a prior review happened before landing or certify a new Claude/protocol review. + +#657 and #658 stay BACKLOG, as directed and as recorded in the committed run4 PLAN.md. No new actionable finding was identified in this review, so no new task is proposed. No landing reopening, gate request, protocol, subagent or review loop is initiated. No source/helper/test changes, credential access, borrowed/copied/minted keys, live-instance access, formal comment, approval API call, fabricated receipt or queue update occurred. Only this requested verdict artifact was created, without committing or pushing it. + +T3 send delivery is unavailable in this session: catalog has no t3_thread_send, a direct call returned TypeError (not a function), and both T3_ACP_MCP_NODE and T3_ACP_MCP_ENTRYPOINT are unset. No delivery to Sage is claimed. Formal posting remains deferred until a working authorized route exists; no queue record may be made from this file alone. diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/journal-prefix-preservation.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/journal-prefix-preservation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2cea026d4 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/journal-prefix-preservation.json @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +[ + { + "path": "BUILD-LOG.md", + "canonicalPrefixBytes": 796514, + "ownAppendBytes": 519, + "baseBytes": 794515, + "canonicalEntirePrefixRetained": true + }, + { + "path": "docs/SESSIONS.md", + "canonicalPrefixBytes": 634923, + "ownAppendBytes": 519, + "baseBytes": 634048, + "canonicalEntirePrefixRetained": true + } +] diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/new-330-01-task-receipt.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/new-330-01-task-receipt.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f2a6d6b58 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/new-330-01-task-receipt.json @@ -0,0 +1,12 @@ +{ + "operation": "sage-4865-new-330-01", + "state": "created", + "at": "2026-10-26T17:58:16.616773+00:00", + "title": "Preserve retiring-generation metadata in Console client-key list (row330 follow-up)", + "description": "

NEW-330-01 raised by actual Filbert post-landing review, UTC2026-10-26T17:56:44Z, candidate52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1/product362893d043ff96fdd35f18e326cce683db031471. File agents/filbert/work/queue-330/postlanding-mos1909/REVIEW.md SHA2560f93bc883f1db2d2e136323040eaff2ad79aa184fa5ab140c94a0ae906f70ffe. Real verdict APPROVE for original repairs; this finding is a separate medium-priority backlog follow-up underMos1909/1864, not a landing reopen or gate request. Owner recommendation Poe with P2 coordination; no assignment/role authority changed by filing.

Trigger: a managed model key rotates while a run still uses its old generation. ModelKeys retains the old key remotely and in record.retiring with keyId and issuedAt; the existing rotation test asserts retention and sweep keeps it while the live run is within grace.

Static source defect: Credentials.status at credentials.mjs662-664 exposes safe retiring keyId/issuedAt/retireAt, but runtime.mjs332-333 projects only the current generation and discards retiring. ProxyPage.request proxy-page.mjs168-171 looks up the flattened list by keyId. The legitimate old client key consequently has agent:null, issuedAt:null and state:null despite known ownership metadata. This is a display/observability gap, not a demonstrated credential leak or revocation bypass. No runtime reproduction was run.

Existing coverage: proxy-model-join.test.mjs and proxy-page-accounts.test.mjs each supply only current-generation metadata. Their GREEN receipts do not cover retained generations.

Acceptance: project current and retiring safe metadata for the same business within the existing read contract. Preserve per-generation issue time and explicit retirement status, no key values or new page write. A real runtime regression retains an old generation through rotation and verifies both rows show the same owning agent with separate issue times/status; immutable key history and response/log/store guards show no credential values. Verify the old row disappears after normal retirement and current metadata/owner-only boundaries remain correct. Preserve original assertions/deadlines; choose an existing deterministic clock/readiness signal when needed.

No source edit, patch, test, gate, deployment or new #657/#658 recovery/provenance work is authorized by this filing. Existing landing/gate evidence stays immutable. Stable operation sage-4865-new-330-01; filed by Sage own bot13.

", + "priority": 2, + "status": 201, + "id": 665, + "readbackExactTitleDescriptionPriorityCreator": true, + "taskStillOpen": true +} diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/own-posting-route-inspection.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/own-posting-route-inspection.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ed9cfbac3 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/own-posting-route-inspection.json @@ -0,0 +1,239 @@ +{ + "at": "2026-10-26T17:54:02.960112+00:00", + "namesOnlyNoCredentialValues": true, + "historicalQueueEvidence": [ + { + "rev": 3331, + "op": "gander-276-inreview-r1", + "verb": "move", + "args": { + "id": 276, + "to": "in-review", + "reason": null, + "candidate": "/home/jwoltje/.t3/worktrees/mosaic-stack/gander-row196/agents/gander/work/queue-276/MANIFEST.sha256", + "evidence": null, + "issue": null + }, + "by": "gander", + "at": "2026-10-22T21:55:43.447Z", + "semantics": 2, + "result": { + "row": 276, + "from": "in-progress", + "to": "in-review", + "round": 1, + "issue": 1781, + "candidate": { + "kind": "manifest", + "digest": "8f30c19a530789df8b22a77bed24250a5ccd94f9eb0a38534f512d3dd0e82189", + "text": "9d40dfe1bc91f60cd9999b3224dcea5b44f46f79019678ec98c6987f815a5099 docs/plans/DEFERRED.md\neac5c83f43056bdeb5781101307e17d4bc01f03e97e02f4f5e930436d7e43535 packages/cli/tests/case-sudo-fixture.mjs\n1e8af0656707d93dedade923bf60556022dc7121c43761876a5d7e02731c14aa packages/cli/tests/case1-accept.test.mjs\n89b45bb84e8365f32f08fd055c7db8a0259533f23fe7ab03f484acb25bee92c2 scripts/case1-accept.sh\nf615d09cd0998bd3a109faff9a16a78ac3f414686300fadc282a7773ec08491a scripts/case2-unit.sh\n" + }, + "receipt": "ok gander-276-inreview-r1 rev 3331 row 276 in-progress\u2192in-review round 1 on #1781; request gander-276-inreview-r1 requesting" + }, + "viewSha": "13977e2865b7201cdfeafef53c48f14bcd4a61dde28e2eaae4c459c987f138a2" + }, + { + "rev": 3332, + "op": "gander-276-inreview-r1.outcome", + "verb": "review-outcome", + "args": { + "id": 276, + "attempt": "gander-276-inreview-r1", + "outcome": "failed", + "status": null, + "comment": null, + "detail": "pre-send: the credential or account check failed" + }, + "by": "gander", + "at": "2026-10-22T21:56:29.087Z", + "semantics": 2, + "result": { + "row": 276, + "round": 1, + "attempt": "gander-276-inreview-r1", + "state": "failed", + "receipt": "ok gander-276-inreview-r1.outcome rev 3332 row 276 round 1 request gander-276-inreview-r1 failed" + }, + "viewSha": "ef85263fd91f9934da8b0304f368ff4081ab5682403db28d6db1956283f2e0e9" + }, + { + "rev": 3333, + "op": "sage-276-req-r1", + "verb": "review-request", + "args": { + "id": 276 + }, + "by": "sage", + "at": "2026-10-22T21:57:35.933Z", + "semantics": 2, + "result": { + "row": 276, + "round": 1, + "attempt": "sage-276-req-r1", + "state": "requesting", + "receipt": "ok sage-276-req-r1 rev 3333 row 276 round 1 request sage-276-req-r1 requesting" + }, + "viewSha": "9716d0b1864cfb176a62e458981e66a385ff7a5001a1b74ec9a1ebb6b943c607" + }, + { + "rev": 3334, + "op": "sage-276-req-r1.outcome", + "verb": "review-outcome", + "args": { + "id": 276, + "attempt": "sage-276-req-r1", + "outcome": "posted", + "status": 201, + "comment": 30828, + "detail": "created" + }, + "by": "sage", + "at": "2026-10-22T21:58:23.379Z", + "semantics": 2, + "result": { + "row": 276, + "round": 1, + "attempt": "sage-276-req-r1", + "state": "posted", + "receipt": "ok sage-276-req-r1.outcome rev 3334 row 276 round 1 request sage-276-req-r1 posted comment 30828" + }, + "viewSha": "fffb8a544bdf03bca8556d159281ae6da1a8b31a10b8f316526935a40b7b2c4b" + }, + { + "rev": 3711, + "op": "gladstone-320-ir2", + "verb": "move", + "args": { + "id": 320, + "to": "in-review", + "reason": null, + "candidate": "faf55618ee6a66297a7784206da8897b1dc04af9", + "evidence": null, + "issue": 1816 + }, + "by": "gladstone", + "at": "2026-10-23T21:32:17.313Z", + "semantics": 2, + "result": { + "row": 320, + "from": "in-progress", + "to": "in-review", + "round": 2, + "issue": 1816, + "candidate": { + "kind": "commit", + "digest": "faf55618ee6a66297a7784206da8897b1dc04af9", + "text": null + }, + "receipt": "ok gladstone-320-ir2 rev 3711 row 320 in-progress\u2192in-review round 2 on #1816; request gladstone-320-ir2 requesting" + }, + "viewSha": "c42abe2169fd47f52d8e754fa88014d943a80b8e80e6a0c1bcb2bc5b7109d99a" + }, + { + "rev": 3712, + "op": "gladstone-320-ir2.outcome", + "verb": "review-outcome", + "args": { + "id": 320, + "attempt": "gladstone-320-ir2", + "outcome": "failed", + "status": null, + "comment": null, + "detail": "pre-send: the credential or account check failed" + }, + "by": "gladstone", + "at": "2026-10-23T21:33:07.150Z", + "semantics": 2, + "result": { + "row": 320, + "round": 2, + "attempt": "gladstone-320-ir2", + "state": "failed", + "receipt": "ok gladstone-320-ir2.outcome rev 3712 row 320 round 2 request gladstone-320-ir2 failed" + }, + "viewSha": "eab6b8207a222a1708607a4e567b1baf7feb4dc0c985dcd3a506291b3423fe21" + }, + { + "rev": 3713, + "op": "sage-3764", + "verb": "review-request", + "args": { + "id": 320 + }, + "by": "sage", + "at": "2026-10-23T21:34:18.146Z", + "semantics": 2, + "result": { + "row": 320, + "round": 2, + "attempt": "sage-3764", + "state": "requesting", + "receipt": "ok sage-3764 rev 3713 row 320 round 2 request sage-3764 requesting" + }, + "viewSha": "b9409baea30496c7b4856fbba52d09d0470e55f131a7d6446185b44b5f618b38" + }, + { + "rev": 3714, + "op": "sage-3764.outcome", + "verb": "review-outcome", + "args": { + "id": 320, + "attempt": "sage-3764", + "outcome": "posted", + "status": 201, + "comment": 31402, + "detail": "created" + }, + "by": "sage", + "at": "2026-10-23T21:35:07.079Z", + "semantics": 2, + "result": { + "row": 320, + "round": 2, + "attempt": "sage-3764", + "state": "posted", + "receipt": "ok sage-3764.outcome rev 3714 row 320 round 2 request sage-3764 posted comment 31402" + }, + "viewSha": "2602bcfce50e8ee5ef1bb72a57674c86c220dc5d4cb0081cd57bd710d26a17f6" + } + ], + "historicalConclusion": "Sage acting-actor review-request operations used helper scripts/gitea-api.sh and posted as queue loginFor(sage)=jarvis. Queue records transport outcome, not the literal credential filepath/env, so the earlier literal slot cannot be proven from these records.", + "currentOwnSlot": { + "name": "agents/jarvis/secrets/gitea-mosaicstack-jarvis.token", + "existsAtCanonical": false, + "env": "MOSAIC_GITEA_CREDENTIAL_FILE", + "configured": false + }, + "legacyDefault": { + "name": "~/secrets/mosaic.gitea.json", + "exists": true, + "mode": "0600 regular non-symlink", + "helper": "scripts/gitea-api.sh", + "GETuserLogin": "jason.woltje", + "postUsed": false, + "reason": "This is a human account, not ownJarvis. No posting or copy/borrow/mint." + }, + "queueRule": { + "requestForOtherOwner": "Sage is privileged under ownerOrPriv and may use review request on another owner current round without impersonating claimant.", + "requiredPostingIdentity": "jarvis ownfile plus GETuser exactjarvis; shareddefault rejected bycredCheck", + "currentlyUsable": false + }, + "result": "rows330/331 stay tracking-onlyOPEN until lawfulposting route/#436; cite realreviewfiles, no approvalsfabricated", + "sourcePins": [ + { + "path": "packages/queue/src/review.mjs", + "bytes": 8162, + "sha256": "8dc65a1f5a034e3ff4579b3f741ab2a99920dcec85c6059c9c84d958aa6f1b26" + }, + { + "path": "packages/queue/src/queue.mjs", + "bytes": 64708, + "sha256": "36b94e43e7b358328d52dcf9f6911761b4b1c608a9f73f51f675fe6a94b54664" + }, + { + "path": "scripts/gitea-api.sh", + "bytes": 4383, + "sha256": "2e555b369ac5016fe80658568e6ff3f455d63a5a2743d2da05d189987cd5a42d" + } + ] +} diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/prepared-manifest.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/prepared-manifest.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5e58aaf5e --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/prepared-manifest.json @@ -0,0 +1,142 @@ +{ + "at": "2026-10-26T18:02:39.116366+00:00", + "authority": "Mos1909/1915/1917", + "landedCandidate": "52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1", + "product": "362893d043ff96fdd35f18e326cce683db031471", + "allFourVerdictsRealFilesOnly": true, + "formalApprovalOrTaskClosure": false, + "newFollowupTask": 665, + "sourceUnchanged": true, + "artifacts": [ + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task647-before.json", + "sha256": "36397966479fabb5e905baf361aa046e58abda05142242229d12f2aaa91a77cd", + "bytes": 2506 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/gladstone-real-postlanding-verdict.md", + "sha256": "3e88018f2a60bf6f394cf1a11a020c1b38a2e4cc4fb9a20d80fd84f313d49e8e", + "bytes": 8346 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/queue-post-request-observation.json", + "sha256": "27afef2a8fd0e6221f0122c72a1be6779b7968f92ecaa81d45f7f832b35f4336", + "bytes": 18519 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task648-before.json", + "sha256": "01e31cc617d30626a1a2a27812f43166e3dba04c91652851ea1506a4e1d29a35", + "bytes": 1774 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task655-before.json", + "sha256": "e05a0cb27a222f7744808a18b9588f3fba1dcdcdfc1ad6cfcfcfff672d11bc60", + "bytes": 1933 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/verified-review-files.json", + "sha256": "fd2846661026862969e5119a9b366ec442048abf5449475d78662b9bb591e50b", + "bytes": 2764 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task654-before.json", + "sha256": "a5750c65823faf93299213105163b3c605e6fea4d529b6e9ec9649a500d104d6", + "bytes": 1837 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task656-before.json", + "sha256": "391c1843b75448ec8af8c1896bf370678962dedb5253b1803564bcd0ba249711", + "bytes": 1766 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/queue-after-file-citations.json", + "sha256": "da99021b60a5cba10941f580454aaf2882cfd88260a4e24555ece05322b48126", + "bytes": 20194 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/review-completion-summary.json", + "sha256": "dba05178f52d5861a149121a2b27ffb568b75f1b6d4f48f8f992d40d2cd221cc", + "bytes": 653 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/boyd-real-postlanding-verdict.md", + "sha256": "3d070b329f2b9f03e4e7aefaad965cb01e64b1dfe7b44465d068e285bbc2e7b8", + "bytes": 10136 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/new-330-01-task-receipt.json", + "sha256": "25e2a6b9c3e0e93ddc8eef595e5ca9f6dbb27f4188b6434ece90e06fe596acce", + "bytes": 2832 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/own-posting-route-inspection.json", + "sha256": "344979cb9f144846d72019b5577f3dc3ba0cb9181e7c4e8f1bd59328945f26bc", + "bytes": 8217 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/filbert-real-postlanding-verdict.md", + "sha256": "0f93bc883f1db2d2e136323040eaff2ad79aa184fa5ab140c94a0ae906f70ffe", + "bytes": 13692 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/queue-before-new-rounds.json", + "sha256": "f25b63868cdcdcd6860c7e36a32671179e2817a8991f68ba976c70053163a816", + "bytes": 18246 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/dewey-real-postlanding-verdict.md", + "sha256": "ab7edcb484a32093e9cb541032def275665f1572aa97bb118d2742f1f29fa97c", + "bytes": 8444 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/boyd-0063-exact-verdict.md", + "sha256": "c1fa6fdac3cc69dc653448022ac6130cab7f7672b58f5980120799f7fc5cee58", + "bytes": 8275 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/coordination.md", + "sha256": "06b88853c5216532455acf1c6676865a6d4b10bd94e51bd0fff325297d391728", + "bytes": 2791 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task646-before.json", + "sha256": "8112ee2a288c78e79d20a5e970be9862f4a2710d1005af6a392cd6fbfcc0eb5e", + "bytes": 2293 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/boyd-metadata-real-postlanding-verdict.json", + "sha256": "500cec7289fab322a7fc2aacf0c4e740a485f53098e812eaf49107faae75cec6", + "bytes": 1055 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/journal-prefix-preservation.json", + "sha256": "b2d0f8cdfd80de284800ad4654c7d90b918141250f1705f7cf63029c8aa6301a", + "bytes": 341 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task652-before.json", + "sha256": "19224245906760cd2b6853878a563c1ff86189697d790958a7aa4bc333151457", + "bytes": 2598 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/queue-verdict-file-note-receipts.json", + "sha256": "780a614350756b1b1e8c1fe95d7a3d3b2248c3908614d85e3c8f4acebba84459", + "bytes": 3206 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/conditional-closure-plan-mos1917.json", + "sha256": "ba99841fb078452539fe6e98d49bdd5dab562400c8585bcd06e03c23a23d4232", + "bytes": 957 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task653-before.json", + "sha256": "47996fe1c328d64cdb13a09162f035fc6063cad8b205ae724944321c1b2a896d", + "bytes": 1946 + }, + { + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/repair-task-scope-index.json", + "sha256": "b03b9af5dacd49d08989c657cc224443abdbb9327eca2a08befc2b6b949f17ff", + "bytes": 2927 + } + ] +} diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/queue-after-file-citations.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/queue-after-file-citations.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b1450ef79 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/queue-after-file-citations.json @@ -0,0 +1,314 @@ +{ + "revision": 4143, + "rows": [ + { + "id": 330, + "piece": "Model proxy P4: Console proxy page (OAuth sign-in, API keys, priority, key list, usage) via bus verbs (Q250, mos-1606/1608)", + "owner": "poe", + "issues": [ + 1828 + ], + "closes": [ + 1828 + ], + "state": "in-review", + "previousState": null, + "required": false, + "requiredSince": null, + "gate": "Gladstone first review; Filbert landing review; starts now, lands after P1 rebased on it; webui with MOSAIC_REQUIRE_EDITOR_BUILD=1. Sage gate: all package suites but queue and every scripts/test-*.sh green; brief Gate.", + "gateOwner": "sage", + "brief": { + "path": "docs/plans/2026-10-24_proxy-page-brief.md", + "anchor": "Brief: P4 the Console proxy page", + "blob": "4c005dc4936cba343f648dd386c9348070f115ef" + }, + "after": [], + "reviewers": [ + "filbert", + "gladstone" + ], + "review": { + "rounds": [ + { + "n": 1, + "op": "poe-330-postlanding-round1-20261026", + "by": "poe", + "at": "2026-10-26T17:46:56.768Z", + "issue": 1828, + "candidate": { + "kind": "commit", + "digest": "52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1", + "text": null + }, + "request": "comment", + "attempts": [ + { + "op": "poe-330-postlanding-round1-20261026", + "by": "poe", + "at": "2026-10-26T17:46:56.768Z", + "state": "failed", + "comment": null, + "transport": { + "outcome": "failed", + "status": null, + "comment": null, + "detail": "pre-send: the credential or account check failed" + }, + "resolutions": [] + } + ], + "duplicateRisk": false, + "receipts": [] + } + ] + }, + "claim": { + "seat": "poe", + "op": "poe-330-start" + }, + "note": "Mos1915 tracking-only OPEN: code landed52ba14c5f/product362893d04 first under1864. REAL postlanding APPROVE files: agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/filbert-real-postlanding-verdict.md and agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/gladstone-real-postlanding-verdict.md (authors/candidate/time/hash in verified-review-files.json). RequestR1failedpre-send/no comment; no queue approvals. Wait lawfulposting/#436, blocks nothing. NEW-330-01 is separate backlog task665, no landing reopen/gate.", + "blockedReason": null, + "createdAt": "2026-10-24T19:09:06.624Z", + "updatedAt": "2026-10-26T17:59:29.719Z", + "updatedBy": "sage" + }, + { + "id": 331, + "piece": "Model proxy P2: per-agent model keys, reconcile and launch preflight (237, mos-1600)", + "owner": "magica", + "issues": [ + 1829 + ], + "closes": [ + 1829 + ], + "state": "in-review", + "previousState": null, + "required": false, + "requiredSince": null, + "gate": "Boyd first review; Dewey landing review; three named mutants killed. Sage gate: all package suites but queue and every scripts/test-*.sh green; brief Gate.", + "gateOwner": "sage", + "brief": { + "path": "docs/plans/2026-10-24_model-proxy-rows.md", + "anchor": "Brief: P2 per-agent model keys, reconcile and the launch preflight", + "blob": "fd4325c05a7f9ba834d4bacba54cd312c93a971d" + }, + "after": [ + { + "id": 329, + "when": "done" + } + ], + "reviewers": [ + "boyd", + "dewey" + ], + "review": { + "rounds": [ + { + "n": 1, + "op": "magica-331-in-review-r5-candidate", + "by": "magica", + "at": "2026-10-25T08:22:52.743Z", + "issue": 1829, + "candidate": { + "kind": "commit", + "digest": "d62c69c8677df1d9e536b4deba16d7d4bb95c062", + "text": null + }, + "request": "comment", + "attempts": [ + { + "op": "magica-331-in-review-r5-candidate", + "by": "magica", + "at": "2026-10-25T08:22:52.743Z", + "state": "failed", + "comment": null, + "transport": { + "outcome": "failed", + "status": null, + "comment": null, + "detail": "pre-send: the credential or account check failed" + }, + "resolutions": [] + }, + { + "op": "sage-4481-row331-review", + "by": "sage", + "at": "2026-10-25T08:28:18.966Z", + "state": "posted", + "comment": 31700, + "transport": { + "outcome": "posted", + "status": 201, + "comment": 31700, + "detail": "created" + }, + "resolutions": [] + } + ], + "duplicateRisk": false, + "receipts": [ + { + "reviewer": "boyd", + "op": "boyd-331-verdict-0001", + "at": "2026-10-25T08:34:19.080Z", + "verdict": "changes", + "comment": 31701, + "candidate": "d62c69c8677df1d9e536b4deba16d7d4bb95c062" + } + ] + }, + { + "n": 2, + "op": "magica-331-round2-review-0060", + "by": "magica", + "at": "2026-10-25T09:36:56.297Z", + "issue": 1829, + "candidate": { + "kind": "manifest", + "digest": "fb0a7b68a70ebea1db745dfa3a89c0f93b06cbebeab9e2c9d1839369d276d5b6", + "text": "667b60c9935528aee1c489aaaf284222bab6af1b579e1f8f2fdec4dcb7d7a0f6 docs/plans/DEFERRED.md\neafd7e4b7a0d32b7522fa17e1424db088efedc69777b2ed914e98d07a9ffb6a5 packages/bus/src/broker.mjs\n1c27b306be4b1d9a3b163b940cf4d9ca0badd62812ed7c78670865a846cad0bd packages/bus/src/credentials.mjs\nbf96f9413537d75991464df1b6893c999c01599976eb48eb2032e33e9aade92a packages/bus/src/model-keys.mjs\n3d429ef05c2f869c8782273563fe13b0f02701832349f268634d3ba53a316285 packages/bus/src/process.mjs\n2894ea78e85ca4e11b2acf5dc130bea4cec75eeb1e30eea3bc068d336b58f7a6 packages/bus/src/runtime.mjs\n9a5f913845e2a987b4fe2fcc191b0d207696c1271455609aafc6c804906559bf packages/bus/tests/model-credential-store.test.mjs\n6986c8e290749b9f8f861c8c8d1b39f610131142482842e4834e3c6d48772040 packages/bus/tests/model-keys.test.mjs\nadcc349357f4ac89956a6bc503af5730b03bfff1ffff20fb07bcdb4d247cbd72 packages/bus/tests/model-proxy.test.mjs\ndaf5997cdb367388c1b79ff9392c33ce203d16bec2dc5b351dcb18497fdeb656 packages/bus/tests/model-restart.test.mjs\n5d2ed538b6db01530b4365675cf664ebee523ffb8ce853d58b635a7373917231 packages/bus/tests/model-retirement-boundary.test.mjs\ncb4f72afc070d86fc10c9fb410b03969341f3d7015da6ebaaec5ea1f780899ae packages/bus/tests/model-stop.test.mjs\nf13554e08d7390455075f085dbe2cb2f9e39e678a6513e32cb41b4ba1817e276 packages/bus/tests/project-runtime.test.mjs\n1e663b175e18e39ff68c9ac3a65ff71fc777a6c37ebca035fce6a2783d0aaac3 packages/cli/src/cli.mjs\n0272cc7c8e2ccbca9d92e4d3a34293cedc8a9bb1ec45fed88917050bd9bdede7 packages/cli/src/launcher.mjs\n9a043f122e1d49103bab64716d0eb80cfc09da3c91f7e2eb014b0d8ff0b02f3d packages/cli/src/model-proxy.mjs\n3df9770e8aae51357986a16473c96d2a3879bcd436153fa25c70f71b0ab181d7 packages/cli/src/model-stall.mjs\nc4b14bb65b2ea10603f8dfa446ac7a2d31fea6e2f7382892beaed5d3372dd237 packages/cli/tests/model-proxy-guards.test.mjs\n655c9ec5d37e8fa0a8ba3340ec053c886072519b6d322f298654d0ba152d287f packages/cli/tests/model-stall.test.mjs\n1ef13e5bd2ea9b166b505c46821f1649444b8fab9882531975858ce20a79f341 packages/harness/src/first-output.mjs\n9c0a0482c877dd5eae1e2691f20d30e37a289d68cb7d4998b0418c44055ae6d1 packages/harness/src/runner.mjs\n9cf8bbac00be602675e913699cb57d625bb1cab7a2734aa39396b6b9fe308351 packages/harness/tests/first-output.test.mjs\n982d06ff27cb69a8e099802cb062e7915e6e26a8a35d698950f21f9209c6e067 packages/model-proxy/README.md\n47120f55d91f110668d48c7fc7b7c2e1de513082bea6197ebc5073bcfea7f611 packages/model-proxy/src/client.mjs\na6fb88352018b8f21593a0bb9311f87162c80d8b1e05e62b4d43b1e69af21b23 packages/model-proxy/src/common.mjs\n1eac4b5741b360a077bb1c871c008b64f7c7119afc64be4d6e4a0dcdb3a313bb packages/model-proxy/src/settings.mjs\ne66453cf6662677cf28cbad1ae8f7509917d333e5b80404ab02c53f5cf75e9e1 packages/model-proxy/src/validation.mjs\n77327681d6eb51f25d7aeffcc532b7e8269c1dc59139cb03adb4a3a1409f63e9 packages/model-proxy/tests/client-probe.test.mjs\n858a0d254de44acc2d8e9d57e823ab2b4c6820059d1d29d2d73270a313a557ee packages/model-proxy/tests/p2-settings.test.mjs\ne0a79c3cc9b0e1a0d542f28539ce1e6c9f7239efab2ddbcbc0ee4651e85014cd packages/model-proxy/tests/validation.test.mjs\na203f7bb2735e4abeb0758c7719022545696b35f00d7943144b73aa892091807 packages/seat/src/sandbox.mjs\n0def1344345fe5fd719b8548ddc115d1ba581577294179a3996cb6f39dd5088a packages/seat/tests/sandbox.test.mjs\n55acb1965a630c079a39db740609074790310e47dc9e84f8decf5f278f102738 scripts/mosaic-config.mjs\n" + }, + "request": "comment", + "attempts": [ + { + "op": "magica-331-round2-review-0060", + "by": "magica", + "at": "2026-10-25T09:36:56.297Z", + "state": "failed", + "comment": null, + "transport": { + "outcome": "failed", + "status": null, + "comment": null, + "detail": "pre-send: the credential or account check failed" + }, + "resolutions": [] + }, + { + "op": "sage-4504-row331-round2-review", + "by": "sage", + "at": "2026-10-25T09:41:03.992Z", + "state": "posted", + "comment": 31702, + "transport": { + "outcome": "posted", + "status": 201, + "comment": 31702, + "detail": "created" + }, + "resolutions": [] + } + ], + "duplicateRisk": false, + "receipts": [ + { + "reviewer": "boyd", + "op": "boyd-331-verdict-0002", + "at": "2026-10-25T10:04:47.426Z", + "verdict": "changes", + "comment": 31705, + "candidate": "fb0a7b68a70ebea1db745dfa3a89c0f93b06cbebeab9e2c9d1839369d276d5b6" + } + ] + }, + { + "n": 3, + "op": "magica-331-round3-review-0129", + "by": "magica", + "at": "2026-10-25T17:06:36.866Z", + "issue": 1829, + "candidate": { + "kind": "manifest", + "digest": "bb2583e91bdb4080b5c25595d9df06ef2a5360ba866e9ac0866175aa9c7221ef", + "text": "95e2c9568498cbe628d62f1ef981dfb6819fc9acad0337086b67adc8717208fd docs/plans/2026-10-24_model-proxy-rows.md\n3038d65cd3e42c858445d92ac25675f7c5ae66babef1ef79799bd17ae59f0b17 docs/plans/2026-10-24_stack-model-proxy.md\n667b60c9935528aee1c489aaaf284222bab6af1b579e1f8f2fdec4dcb7d7a0f6 docs/plans/DEFERRED.md\n7ae9c3cef21024bebf32bd0c8af861a64d39b0137e8ba5899612004dd898b33c packages/bus/src/broker.mjs\n1c27b306be4b1d9a3b163b940cf4d9ca0badd62812ed7c78670865a846cad0bd packages/bus/src/credentials.mjs\n815b92c8e0b7b6eca8495ea745c0ec7cfdc91296a44d9b0a62b94ed9b5bc9e1d packages/bus/src/model-keys.mjs\ned13afdce6359df31d35a79496ebb4afdefef82030a8326a76b2a25b37e98d9d packages/bus/src/process.mjs\nc34497a1b1b009f7de156dcc7867e25f1b3afc4a876eed01f319d335a229a6a3 packages/bus/src/runtime.mjs\n9a5f913845e2a987b4fe2fcc191b0d207696c1271455609aafc6c804906559bf packages/bus/tests/model-credential-store.test.mjs\nce5f042304949d1aed85db003038059bbc3dae6dd7e915a1322db31c81eef8c9 packages/bus/tests/model-historical-cleanup.test.mjs\na5ad060fc9636aab1e142dedfff430f8955fbd6d0a67c9ebdf2062ac72cbdaf2 packages/bus/tests/model-historical-ipc.test.mjs\na9573572cba4ca747cebec232bfa39c744ab7df13fbe1876a19139d2ace0ebf7 packages/bus/tests/model-key-loss-interaction.test.mjs\nc1b24468e8220db6d881945fd5730f6c673dca84c14f179e9a74338c2b0ed9af packages/bus/tests/model-key-provenance.test.mjs\n6986c8e290749b9f8f861c8c8d1b39f610131142482842e4834e3c6d48772040 packages/bus/tests/model-keys.test.mjs\n3be2add875bec6c187d93528afede338a4e178566c61c30a1dfe74fa7ec0cfd6 packages/bus/tests/model-lifecycle-fixtures.mjs\nc5e5c1239bee252dca7ab0089105f0f3719824dcbae3013d82b4a5ba74aa1e6f packages/bus/tests/model-orphan-admission.test.mjs\nd2070945a6603cff4b7dfe98cc9026c9fc28419b2605a4ff904da48406b317ae packages/bus/tests/model-orphan-hire.test.mjs\nadcc349357f4ac89956a6bc503af5730b03bfff1ffff20fb07bcdb4d247cbd72 packages/bus/tests/model-proxy.test.mjs\ndaf5997cdb367388c1b79ff9392c33ce203d16bec2dc5b351dcb18497fdeb656 packages/bus/tests/model-restart.test.mjs\n5d2ed538b6db01530b4365675cf664ebee523ffb8ce853d58b635a7373917231 packages/bus/tests/model-retirement-boundary.test.mjs\n47be63b35472c12421f17700bc096557a89b88a2cd954ecb7e1ca1826f259af2 packages/bus/tests/model-review-fixtures.mjs\ncb4f72afc070d86fc10c9fb410b03969341f3d7015da6ebaaec5ea1f780899ae packages/bus/tests/model-stop.test.mjs\nfe0e3359db0d4cc0700df475fc10e3aa5ea0ec66088e2a222e11a34196193421 packages/bus/tests/model-sweep-isolation.test.mjs\n0e9c73f66e6c6413f7c5c7b79703302c38c5034273c08e6f0dbcdde0a643cf23 packages/bus/tests/model-terminal-proof.test.mjs\nf13554e08d7390455075f085dbe2cb2f9e39e678a6513e32cb41b4ba1817e276 packages/bus/tests/project-runtime.test.mjs\n1e663b175e18e39ff68c9ac3a65ff71fc777a6c37ebca035fce6a2783d0aaac3 packages/cli/src/cli.mjs\nd25274407d3ac3803e85a9dea93c34738dd05b8cd1fbbcc7325c5f682b9eed91 packages/cli/src/launcher.mjs\n9a043f122e1d49103bab64716d0eb80cfc09da3c91f7e2eb014b0d8ff0b02f3d packages/cli/src/model-proxy.mjs\n0bdc91dcaa096bd3dc9d08a1dea59893a21f6505c843e698ad9c8daa4b74364b packages/cli/src/model-stall.mjs\na937f5048fd151582c3ab59f0ce50a54183ff7df9b8c37d44f43505daf9e02e5 packages/cli/tests/fixtures/model-clock-probe.mjs\nc4b14bb65b2ea10603f8dfa446ac7a2d31fea6e2f7382892beaed5d3372dd237 packages/cli/tests/model-proxy-guards.test.mjs\n655c9ec5d37e8fa0a8ba3340ec053c886072519b6d322f298654d0ba152d287f packages/cli/tests/model-stall.test.mjs\n1ad28416c4e55e9feebadafd8f2f2785968620b2445dba41362c470bbef4b214 packages/cli/tests/model-turn-clock.test.mjs\n7a9507a382c4e7a3216c3d3af6df8c35ccb17e5454d6b3701ffcd6e2113e9bbc packages/cli/tests/model-turn-reader.test.mjs\n00af9fdbed4ba727f7a7cec3fa1890154eae01034464a4e85e32005853573a4f packages/cli/tests/session-clear.test.mjs\nc2fa4420fef203370e68656b4b2b3abbe407d2267d0f20bf9f0d4b27cbdec7ef packages/cli/tests/thread-revoke.test.mjs\n6263d358bc6222948242a102d3196727b3cc14a1cc5d02a4fb06f9dc1291d764 packages/harness/src/first-output.mjs\nd4bfea03e7a4f9cb7a5a8515afd32d3b567d95e9aa4234518648a1ed152bc484 packages/harness/src/runner.mjs\n9cf8bbac00be602675e913699cb57d625bb1cab7a2734aa39396b6b9fe308351 packages/harness/tests/first-output.test.mjs\nd2aacf299f157d66ebca15ff8c2e1bde9845b1ac1d789f62fab64e3aa4e89459 packages/harness/tests/first-turn.test.mjs\n6a11bba06be1265ec7ab0229464334f6258a9fc2852615cce9b3acd7cca0437c packages/harness/tests/model-turn-publication.test.mjs\n982d06ff27cb69a8e099802cb062e7915e6e26a8a35d698950f21f9209c6e067 packages/model-proxy/README.md\n47120f55d91f110668d48c7fc7b7c2e1de513082bea6197ebc5073bcfea7f611 packages/model-proxy/src/client.mjs\na6fb88352018b8f21593a0bb9311f87162c80d8b1e05e62b4d43b1e69af21b23 packages/model-proxy/src/common.mjs\n1eac4b5741b360a077bb1c871c008b64f7c7119afc64be4d6e4a0dcdb3a313bb packages/model-proxy/src/settings.mjs\ne66453cf6662677cf28cbad1ae8f7509917d333e5b80404ab02c53f5cf75e9e1 packages/model-proxy/src/validation.mjs\n77327681d6eb51f25d7aeffcc532b7e8269c1dc59139cb03adb4a3a1409f63e9 packages/model-proxy/tests/client-probe.test.mjs\n858a0d254de44acc2d8e9d57e823ab2b4c6820059d1d29d2d73270a313a557ee packages/model-proxy/tests/p2-settings.test.mjs\ne0a79c3cc9b0e1a0d542f28539ce1e6c9f7239efab2ddbcbc0ee4651e85014cd packages/model-proxy/tests/validation.test.mjs\na203f7bb2735e4abeb0758c7719022545696b35f00d7943144b73aa892091807 packages/seat/src/sandbox.mjs\n3fb2e3841f7368bcdd851aad1b4a6293175e0258bb6aa2cd1cdc2fd03c42049f packages/seat/tests/model-markers-confined.test.mjs\n0def1344345fe5fd719b8548ddc115d1ba581577294179a3996cb6f39dd5088a packages/seat/tests/sandbox.test.mjs\n55acb1965a630c079a39db740609074790310e47dc9e84f8decf5f278f102738 scripts/mosaic-config.mjs\n" + }, + "request": "comment", + "attempts": [ + { + "op": "magica-331-round3-review-0129", + "by": "magica", + "at": "2026-10-25T17:06:36.866Z", + "state": "failed", + "comment": null, + "transport": { + "outcome": "failed", + "status": null, + "comment": null, + "detail": "pre-send: the credential or account check failed" + }, + "resolutions": [] + }, + { + "op": "sage-4678-row331-round3-review", + "by": "sage", + "at": "2026-10-25T17:13:29.637Z", + "state": "posted", + "comment": 31706, + "transport": { + "outcome": "posted", + "status": 201, + "comment": 31706, + "detail": "created" + }, + "resolutions": [] + } + ], + "duplicateRisk": false, + "receipts": [ + { + "reviewer": "boyd", + "op": "boyd-331-verdict-0003", + "at": "2026-10-25T17:46:24.006Z", + "verdict": "changes", + "comment": 31707, + "candidate": "bb2583e91bdb4080b5c25595d9df06ef2a5360ba866e9ac0866175aa9c7221ef" + } + ] + }, + { + "n": 4, + "op": "magica-331-postlanding-round4-review-0175", + "by": "magica", + "at": "2026-10-26T17:50:09.895Z", + "issue": 1829, + "candidate": { + "kind": "commit", + "digest": "52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1", + "text": null + }, + "request": "comment", + "attempts": [ + { + "op": "magica-331-postlanding-round4-review-0175", + "by": "magica", + "at": "2026-10-26T17:50:09.895Z", + "state": "failed", + "comment": null, + "transport": { + "outcome": "failed", + "status": null, + "comment": null, + "detail": "pre-send: the credential or account check failed" + }, + "resolutions": [] + } + ], + "duplicateRisk": false, + "receipts": [] + } + ] + }, + "claim": { + "seat": "magica", + "op": "magica-331-start" + }, + "note": "P2 input from magica-0020 (acceptance-probe-4): 8.0.42 revocation lags ~105ms after v8 PUT (first call 200, then 401); reconcile/revoke must poll to 401, not assume instant. Per-key model objects give 422; no per-key model restriction. Mos1915 tracking-only OPEN/#436: landed52ba; realBoyd/Dewey APPROVE files, no comments/queueapprovals. Index+hashes: agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/verified-review-files.json.656narrowfixed/broaderPARTIAL;657/658backlog.", + "blockedReason": null, + "createdAt": "2026-10-24T19:11:25.454Z", + "updatedAt": "2026-10-26T18:01:25.576Z", + "updatedBy": "sage" + } + ] +} diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/queue-before-new-rounds.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/queue-before-new-rounds.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0338e9489 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/queue-before-new-rounds.json @@ -0,0 +1,278 @@ +{ + "revision": 4137, + "rows": [ + { + "id": 330, + "piece": "Model proxy P4: Console proxy page (OAuth sign-in, API keys, priority, key list, usage) via bus verbs (Q250, mos-1606/1608)", + "owner": "poe", + "issues": [ + 1828 + ], + "closes": [ + 1828 + ], + "state": "in-review", + "previousState": null, + "required": false, + "requiredSince": null, + "gate": "Gladstone first review; Filbert landing review; starts now, lands after P1 rebased on it; webui with MOSAIC_REQUIRE_EDITOR_BUILD=1. Sage gate: all package suites but queue and every scripts/test-*.sh green; brief Gate.", + "gateOwner": "sage", + "brief": { + "path": "docs/plans/2026-10-24_proxy-page-brief.md", + "anchor": "Brief: P4 the Console proxy page", + "blob": "4c005dc4936cba343f648dd386c9348070f115ef" + }, + "after": [], + "reviewers": [ + "filbert", + "gladstone" + ], + "review": { + "rounds": [ + { + "n": 1, + "op": "poe-330-postlanding-round1-20261026", + "by": "poe", + "at": "2026-10-26T17:46:56.768Z", + "issue": 1828, + "candidate": { + "kind": "commit", + "digest": "52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1", + "text": null + }, + "request": "comment", + "attempts": [ + { + "op": "poe-330-postlanding-round1-20261026", + "by": "poe", + "at": "2026-10-26T17:46:56.768Z", + "state": "requesting", + "comment": null, + "transport": null, + "resolutions": [] + } + ], + "duplicateRisk": false, + "receipts": [] + } + ] + }, + "claim": { + "seat": "poe", + "op": "poe-330-start" + }, + "note": null, + "blockedReason": null, + "createdAt": "2026-10-24T19:09:06.624Z", + "updatedAt": "2026-10-26T17:46:56.768Z", + "updatedBy": "poe" + }, + { + "id": 331, + "piece": "Model proxy P2: per-agent model keys, reconcile and launch preflight (237, mos-1600)", + "owner": "magica", + "issues": [ + 1829 + ], + "closes": [ + 1829 + ], + "state": "in-review", + "previousState": null, + "required": false, + "requiredSince": null, + "gate": "Boyd first review; Dewey landing review; three named mutants killed. Sage gate: all package suites but queue and every scripts/test-*.sh green; brief Gate.", + "gateOwner": "sage", + "brief": { + "path": "docs/plans/2026-10-24_model-proxy-rows.md", + "anchor": "Brief: P2 per-agent model keys, reconcile and the launch preflight", + "blob": "fd4325c05a7f9ba834d4bacba54cd312c93a971d" + }, + "after": [ + { + "id": 329, + "when": "done" + } + ], + "reviewers": [ + "boyd", + "dewey" + ], + "review": { + "rounds": [ + { + "n": 1, + "op": "magica-331-in-review-r5-candidate", + "by": "magica", + "at": "2026-10-25T08:22:52.743Z", + "issue": 1829, + "candidate": { + "kind": "commit", + "digest": "d62c69c8677df1d9e536b4deba16d7d4bb95c062", + "text": null + }, + "request": "comment", + "attempts": [ + { + "op": "magica-331-in-review-r5-candidate", + "by": "magica", + "at": "2026-10-25T08:22:52.743Z", + "state": "failed", + "comment": null, + "transport": { + "outcome": "failed", + "status": null, + "comment": null, + "detail": "pre-send: the credential or account check failed" + }, + "resolutions": [] + }, + { + "op": "sage-4481-row331-review", + "by": "sage", + "at": "2026-10-25T08:28:18.966Z", + "state": "posted", + "comment": 31700, + "transport": { + "outcome": "posted", + "status": 201, + "comment": 31700, + "detail": "created" + }, + "resolutions": [] + } + ], + "duplicateRisk": false, + "receipts": [ + { + "reviewer": "boyd", + "op": "boyd-331-verdict-0001", + "at": "2026-10-25T08:34:19.080Z", + "verdict": "changes", + "comment": 31701, + "candidate": "d62c69c8677df1d9e536b4deba16d7d4bb95c062" + } + ] + }, + { + "n": 2, + "op": "magica-331-round2-review-0060", + "by": "magica", + "at": "2026-10-25T09:36:56.297Z", + "issue": 1829, + "candidate": { + "kind": "manifest", + "digest": "fb0a7b68a70ebea1db745dfa3a89c0f93b06cbebeab9e2c9d1839369d276d5b6", + "text": "667b60c9935528aee1c489aaaf284222bab6af1b579e1f8f2fdec4dcb7d7a0f6 docs/plans/DEFERRED.md\neafd7e4b7a0d32b7522fa17e1424db088efedc69777b2ed914e98d07a9ffb6a5 packages/bus/src/broker.mjs\n1c27b306be4b1d9a3b163b940cf4d9ca0badd62812ed7c78670865a846cad0bd packages/bus/src/credentials.mjs\nbf96f9413537d75991464df1b6893c999c01599976eb48eb2032e33e9aade92a packages/bus/src/model-keys.mjs\n3d429ef05c2f869c8782273563fe13b0f02701832349f268634d3ba53a316285 packages/bus/src/process.mjs\n2894ea78e85ca4e11b2acf5dc130bea4cec75eeb1e30eea3bc068d336b58f7a6 packages/bus/src/runtime.mjs\n9a5f913845e2a987b4fe2fcc191b0d207696c1271455609aafc6c804906559bf packages/bus/tests/model-credential-store.test.mjs\n6986c8e290749b9f8f861c8c8d1b39f610131142482842e4834e3c6d48772040 packages/bus/tests/model-keys.test.mjs\nadcc349357f4ac89956a6bc503af5730b03bfff1ffff20fb07bcdb4d247cbd72 packages/bus/tests/model-proxy.test.mjs\ndaf5997cdb367388c1b79ff9392c33ce203d16bec2dc5b351dcb18497fdeb656 packages/bus/tests/model-restart.test.mjs\n5d2ed538b6db01530b4365675cf664ebee523ffb8ce853d58b635a7373917231 packages/bus/tests/model-retirement-boundary.test.mjs\ncb4f72afc070d86fc10c9fb410b03969341f3d7015da6ebaaec5ea1f780899ae packages/bus/tests/model-stop.test.mjs\nf13554e08d7390455075f085dbe2cb2f9e39e678a6513e32cb41b4ba1817e276 packages/bus/tests/project-runtime.test.mjs\n1e663b175e18e39ff68c9ac3a65ff71fc777a6c37ebca035fce6a2783d0aaac3 packages/cli/src/cli.mjs\n0272cc7c8e2ccbca9d92e4d3a34293cedc8a9bb1ec45fed88917050bd9bdede7 packages/cli/src/launcher.mjs\n9a043f122e1d49103bab64716d0eb80cfc09da3c91f7e2eb014b0d8ff0b02f3d packages/cli/src/model-proxy.mjs\n3df9770e8aae51357986a16473c96d2a3879bcd436153fa25c70f71b0ab181d7 packages/cli/src/model-stall.mjs\nc4b14bb65b2ea10603f8dfa446ac7a2d31fea6e2f7382892beaed5d3372dd237 packages/cli/tests/model-proxy-guards.test.mjs\n655c9ec5d37e8fa0a8ba3340ec053c886072519b6d322f298654d0ba152d287f packages/cli/tests/model-stall.test.mjs\n1ef13e5bd2ea9b166b505c46821f1649444b8fab9882531975858ce20a79f341 packages/harness/src/first-output.mjs\n9c0a0482c877dd5eae1e2691f20d30e37a289d68cb7d4998b0418c44055ae6d1 packages/harness/src/runner.mjs\n9cf8bbac00be602675e913699cb57d625bb1cab7a2734aa39396b6b9fe308351 packages/harness/tests/first-output.test.mjs\n982d06ff27cb69a8e099802cb062e7915e6e26a8a35d698950f21f9209c6e067 packages/model-proxy/README.md\n47120f55d91f110668d48c7fc7b7c2e1de513082bea6197ebc5073bcfea7f611 packages/model-proxy/src/client.mjs\na6fb88352018b8f21593a0bb9311f87162c80d8b1e05e62b4d43b1e69af21b23 packages/model-proxy/src/common.mjs\n1eac4b5741b360a077bb1c871c008b64f7c7119afc64be4d6e4a0dcdb3a313bb packages/model-proxy/src/settings.mjs\ne66453cf6662677cf28cbad1ae8f7509917d333e5b80404ab02c53f5cf75e9e1 packages/model-proxy/src/validation.mjs\n77327681d6eb51f25d7aeffcc532b7e8269c1dc59139cb03adb4a3a1409f63e9 packages/model-proxy/tests/client-probe.test.mjs\n858a0d254de44acc2d8e9d57e823ab2b4c6820059d1d29d2d73270a313a557ee packages/model-proxy/tests/p2-settings.test.mjs\ne0a79c3cc9b0e1a0d542f28539ce1e6c9f7239efab2ddbcbc0ee4651e85014cd packages/model-proxy/tests/validation.test.mjs\na203f7bb2735e4abeb0758c7719022545696b35f00d7943144b73aa892091807 packages/seat/src/sandbox.mjs\n0def1344345fe5fd719b8548ddc115d1ba581577294179a3996cb6f39dd5088a packages/seat/tests/sandbox.test.mjs\n55acb1965a630c079a39db740609074790310e47dc9e84f8decf5f278f102738 scripts/mosaic-config.mjs\n" + }, + "request": "comment", + "attempts": [ + { + "op": "magica-331-round2-review-0060", + "by": "magica", + "at": "2026-10-25T09:36:56.297Z", + "state": "failed", + "comment": null, + "transport": { + "outcome": "failed", + "status": null, + "comment": null, + "detail": "pre-send: the credential or account check failed" + }, + "resolutions": [] + }, + { + "op": "sage-4504-row331-round2-review", + "by": "sage", + "at": "2026-10-25T09:41:03.992Z", + "state": "posted", + "comment": 31702, + "transport": { + "outcome": "posted", + "status": 201, + "comment": 31702, + "detail": "created" + }, + "resolutions": [] + } + ], + "duplicateRisk": false, + "receipts": [ + { + "reviewer": "boyd", + "op": "boyd-331-verdict-0002", + "at": "2026-10-25T10:04:47.426Z", + "verdict": "changes", + "comment": 31705, + "candidate": "fb0a7b68a70ebea1db745dfa3a89c0f93b06cbebeab9e2c9d1839369d276d5b6" + } + ] + }, + { + "n": 3, + "op": "magica-331-round3-review-0129", + "by": "magica", + "at": "2026-10-25T17:06:36.866Z", + "issue": 1829, + "candidate": { + "kind": "manifest", + "digest": "bb2583e91bdb4080b5c25595d9df06ef2a5360ba866e9ac0866175aa9c7221ef", + "text": "95e2c9568498cbe628d62f1ef981dfb6819fc9acad0337086b67adc8717208fd docs/plans/2026-10-24_model-proxy-rows.md\n3038d65cd3e42c858445d92ac25675f7c5ae66babef1ef79799bd17ae59f0b17 docs/plans/2026-10-24_stack-model-proxy.md\n667b60c9935528aee1c489aaaf284222bab6af1b579e1f8f2fdec4dcb7d7a0f6 docs/plans/DEFERRED.md\n7ae9c3cef21024bebf32bd0c8af861a64d39b0137e8ba5899612004dd898b33c packages/bus/src/broker.mjs\n1c27b306be4b1d9a3b163b940cf4d9ca0badd62812ed7c78670865a846cad0bd packages/bus/src/credentials.mjs\n815b92c8e0b7b6eca8495ea745c0ec7cfdc91296a44d9b0a62b94ed9b5bc9e1d packages/bus/src/model-keys.mjs\ned13afdce6359df31d35a79496ebb4afdefef82030a8326a76b2a25b37e98d9d packages/bus/src/process.mjs\nc34497a1b1b009f7de156dcc7867e25f1b3afc4a876eed01f319d335a229a6a3 packages/bus/src/runtime.mjs\n9a5f913845e2a987b4fe2fcc191b0d207696c1271455609aafc6c804906559bf packages/bus/tests/model-credential-store.test.mjs\nce5f042304949d1aed85db003038059bbc3dae6dd7e915a1322db31c81eef8c9 packages/bus/tests/model-historical-cleanup.test.mjs\na5ad060fc9636aab1e142dedfff430f8955fbd6d0a67c9ebdf2062ac72cbdaf2 packages/bus/tests/model-historical-ipc.test.mjs\na9573572cba4ca747cebec232bfa39c744ab7df13fbe1876a19139d2ace0ebf7 packages/bus/tests/model-key-loss-interaction.test.mjs\nc1b24468e8220db6d881945fd5730f6c673dca84c14f179e9a74338c2b0ed9af packages/bus/tests/model-key-provenance.test.mjs\n6986c8e290749b9f8f861c8c8d1b39f610131142482842e4834e3c6d48772040 packages/bus/tests/model-keys.test.mjs\n3be2add875bec6c187d93528afede338a4e178566c61c30a1dfe74fa7ec0cfd6 packages/bus/tests/model-lifecycle-fixtures.mjs\nc5e5c1239bee252dca7ab0089105f0f3719824dcbae3013d82b4a5ba74aa1e6f packages/bus/tests/model-orphan-admission.test.mjs\nd2070945a6603cff4b7dfe98cc9026c9fc28419b2605a4ff904da48406b317ae packages/bus/tests/model-orphan-hire.test.mjs\nadcc349357f4ac89956a6bc503af5730b03bfff1ffff20fb07bcdb4d247cbd72 packages/bus/tests/model-proxy.test.mjs\ndaf5997cdb367388c1b79ff9392c33ce203d16bec2dc5b351dcb18497fdeb656 packages/bus/tests/model-restart.test.mjs\n5d2ed538b6db01530b4365675cf664ebee523ffb8ce853d58b635a7373917231 packages/bus/tests/model-retirement-boundary.test.mjs\n47be63b35472c12421f17700bc096557a89b88a2cd954ecb7e1ca1826f259af2 packages/bus/tests/model-review-fixtures.mjs\ncb4f72afc070d86fc10c9fb410b03969341f3d7015da6ebaaec5ea1f780899ae packages/bus/tests/model-stop.test.mjs\nfe0e3359db0d4cc0700df475fc10e3aa5ea0ec66088e2a222e11a34196193421 packages/bus/tests/model-sweep-isolation.test.mjs\n0e9c73f66e6c6413f7c5c7b79703302c38c5034273c08e6f0dbcdde0a643cf23 packages/bus/tests/model-terminal-proof.test.mjs\nf13554e08d7390455075f085dbe2cb2f9e39e678a6513e32cb41b4ba1817e276 packages/bus/tests/project-runtime.test.mjs\n1e663b175e18e39ff68c9ac3a65ff71fc777a6c37ebca035fce6a2783d0aaac3 packages/cli/src/cli.mjs\nd25274407d3ac3803e85a9dea93c34738dd05b8cd1fbbcc7325c5f682b9eed91 packages/cli/src/launcher.mjs\n9a043f122e1d49103bab64716d0eb80cfc09da3c91f7e2eb014b0d8ff0b02f3d packages/cli/src/model-proxy.mjs\n0bdc91dcaa096bd3dc9d08a1dea59893a21f6505c843e698ad9c8daa4b74364b packages/cli/src/model-stall.mjs\na937f5048fd151582c3ab59f0ce50a54183ff7df9b8c37d44f43505daf9e02e5 packages/cli/tests/fixtures/model-clock-probe.mjs\nc4b14bb65b2ea10603f8dfa446ac7a2d31fea6e2f7382892beaed5d3372dd237 packages/cli/tests/model-proxy-guards.test.mjs\n655c9ec5d37e8fa0a8ba3340ec053c886072519b6d322f298654d0ba152d287f packages/cli/tests/model-stall.test.mjs\n1ad28416c4e55e9feebadafd8f2f2785968620b2445dba41362c470bbef4b214 packages/cli/tests/model-turn-clock.test.mjs\n7a9507a382c4e7a3216c3d3af6df8c35ccb17e5454d6b3701ffcd6e2113e9bbc packages/cli/tests/model-turn-reader.test.mjs\n00af9fdbed4ba727f7a7cec3fa1890154eae01034464a4e85e32005853573a4f packages/cli/tests/session-clear.test.mjs\nc2fa4420fef203370e68656b4b2b3abbe407d2267d0f20bf9f0d4b27cbdec7ef packages/cli/tests/thread-revoke.test.mjs\n6263d358bc6222948242a102d3196727b3cc14a1cc5d02a4fb06f9dc1291d764 packages/harness/src/first-output.mjs\nd4bfea03e7a4f9cb7a5a8515afd32d3b567d95e9aa4234518648a1ed152bc484 packages/harness/src/runner.mjs\n9cf8bbac00be602675e913699cb57d625bb1cab7a2734aa39396b6b9fe308351 packages/harness/tests/first-output.test.mjs\nd2aacf299f157d66ebca15ff8c2e1bde9845b1ac1d789f62fab64e3aa4e89459 packages/harness/tests/first-turn.test.mjs\n6a11bba06be1265ec7ab0229464334f6258a9fc2852615cce9b3acd7cca0437c packages/harness/tests/model-turn-publication.test.mjs\n982d06ff27cb69a8e099802cb062e7915e6e26a8a35d698950f21f9209c6e067 packages/model-proxy/README.md\n47120f55d91f110668d48c7fc7b7c2e1de513082bea6197ebc5073bcfea7f611 packages/model-proxy/src/client.mjs\na6fb88352018b8f21593a0bb9311f87162c80d8b1e05e62b4d43b1e69af21b23 packages/model-proxy/src/common.mjs\n1eac4b5741b360a077bb1c871c008b64f7c7119afc64be4d6e4a0dcdb3a313bb packages/model-proxy/src/settings.mjs\ne66453cf6662677cf28cbad1ae8f7509917d333e5b80404ab02c53f5cf75e9e1 packages/model-proxy/src/validation.mjs\n77327681d6eb51f25d7aeffcc532b7e8269c1dc59139cb03adb4a3a1409f63e9 packages/model-proxy/tests/client-probe.test.mjs\n858a0d254de44acc2d8e9d57e823ab2b4c6820059d1d29d2d73270a313a557ee packages/model-proxy/tests/p2-settings.test.mjs\ne0a79c3cc9b0e1a0d542f28539ce1e6c9f7239efab2ddbcbc0ee4651e85014cd packages/model-proxy/tests/validation.test.mjs\na203f7bb2735e4abeb0758c7719022545696b35f00d7943144b73aa892091807 packages/seat/src/sandbox.mjs\n3fb2e3841f7368bcdd851aad1b4a6293175e0258bb6aa2cd1cdc2fd03c42049f packages/seat/tests/model-markers-confined.test.mjs\n0def1344345fe5fd719b8548ddc115d1ba581577294179a3996cb6f39dd5088a packages/seat/tests/sandbox.test.mjs\n55acb1965a630c079a39db740609074790310e47dc9e84f8decf5f278f102738 scripts/mosaic-config.mjs\n" + }, + "request": "comment", + "attempts": [ + { + "op": "magica-331-round3-review-0129", + "by": "magica", + "at": "2026-10-25T17:06:36.866Z", + "state": "failed", + "comment": null, + "transport": { + "outcome": "failed", + "status": null, + "comment": null, + "detail": "pre-send: the credential or account check failed" + }, + "resolutions": [] + }, + { + "op": "sage-4678-row331-round3-review", + "by": "sage", + "at": "2026-10-25T17:13:29.637Z", + "state": "posted", + "comment": 31706, + "transport": { + "outcome": "posted", + "status": 201, + "comment": 31706, + "detail": "created" + }, + "resolutions": [] + } + ], + "duplicateRisk": false, + "receipts": [ + { + "reviewer": "boyd", + "op": "boyd-331-verdict-0003", + "at": "2026-10-25T17:46:24.006Z", + "verdict": "changes", + "comment": 31707, + "candidate": "bb2583e91bdb4080b5c25595d9df06ef2a5360ba866e9ac0866175aa9c7221ef" + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "claim": { + "seat": "magica", + "op": "magica-331-start" + }, + "note": "P2 input from magica-0020 (acceptance-probe-4): 8.0.42 revocation lags ~105ms after v8 PUT (first call 200, then 401); reconcile/revoke must poll to 401, not assume instant. Per-key model objects give 422; no per-key model restriction.", + "blockedReason": null, + "createdAt": "2026-10-24T19:11:25.454Z", + "updatedAt": "2026-10-25T17:46:24.006Z", + "updatedBy": "boyd" + } + ] +} diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/queue-post-request-observation.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/queue-post-request-observation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6a043bf64 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/queue-post-request-observation.json @@ -0,0 +1,284 @@ +{ + "revision": 4138, + "rows": [ + { + "id": 330, + "piece": "Model proxy P4: Console proxy page (OAuth sign-in, API keys, priority, key list, usage) via bus verbs (Q250, mos-1606/1608)", + "owner": "poe", + "issues": [ + 1828 + ], + "closes": [ + 1828 + ], + "state": "in-review", + "previousState": null, + "required": false, + "requiredSince": null, + "gate": "Gladstone first review; Filbert landing review; starts now, lands after P1 rebased on it; webui with MOSAIC_REQUIRE_EDITOR_BUILD=1. Sage gate: all package suites but queue and every scripts/test-*.sh green; brief Gate.", + "gateOwner": "sage", + "brief": { + "path": "docs/plans/2026-10-24_proxy-page-brief.md", + "anchor": "Brief: P4 the Console proxy page", + "blob": "4c005dc4936cba343f648dd386c9348070f115ef" + }, + "after": [], + "reviewers": [ + "filbert", + "gladstone" + ], + "review": { + "rounds": [ + { + "n": 1, + "op": "poe-330-postlanding-round1-20261026", + "by": "poe", + "at": "2026-10-26T17:46:56.768Z", + "issue": 1828, + "candidate": { + "kind": "commit", + "digest": "52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1", + "text": null + }, + "request": "comment", + "attempts": [ + { + "op": "poe-330-postlanding-round1-20261026", + "by": "poe", + "at": "2026-10-26T17:46:56.768Z", + "state": "failed", + "comment": null, + "transport": { + "outcome": "failed", + "status": null, + "comment": null, + "detail": "pre-send: the credential or account check failed" + }, + "resolutions": [] + } + ], + "duplicateRisk": false, + "receipts": [] + } + ] + }, + "claim": { + "seat": "poe", + "op": "poe-330-start" + }, + "note": null, + "blockedReason": null, + "createdAt": "2026-10-24T19:09:06.624Z", + "updatedAt": "2026-10-26T17:47:59.835Z", + "updatedBy": "poe" + }, + { + "id": 331, + "piece": "Model proxy P2: per-agent model keys, reconcile and launch preflight (237, mos-1600)", + "owner": "magica", + "issues": [ + 1829 + ], + "closes": [ + 1829 + ], + "state": "in-review", + "previousState": null, + "required": false, + "requiredSince": null, + "gate": "Boyd first review; Dewey landing review; three named mutants killed. Sage gate: all package suites but queue and every scripts/test-*.sh green; brief Gate.", + "gateOwner": "sage", + "brief": { + "path": "docs/plans/2026-10-24_model-proxy-rows.md", + "anchor": "Brief: P2 per-agent model keys, reconcile and the launch preflight", + "blob": "fd4325c05a7f9ba834d4bacba54cd312c93a971d" + }, + "after": [ + { + "id": 329, + "when": "done" + } + ], + "reviewers": [ + "boyd", + "dewey" + ], + "review": { + "rounds": [ + { + "n": 1, + "op": "magica-331-in-review-r5-candidate", + "by": "magica", + "at": "2026-10-25T08:22:52.743Z", + "issue": 1829, + "candidate": { + "kind": "commit", + "digest": "d62c69c8677df1d9e536b4deba16d7d4bb95c062", + "text": null + }, + "request": "comment", + "attempts": [ + { + "op": "magica-331-in-review-r5-candidate", + "by": "magica", + "at": "2026-10-25T08:22:52.743Z", + "state": "failed", + "comment": null, + "transport": { + "outcome": "failed", + "status": null, + "comment": null, + "detail": "pre-send: the credential or account check failed" + }, + "resolutions": [] + }, + { + "op": "sage-4481-row331-review", + "by": "sage", + "at": "2026-10-25T08:28:18.966Z", + "state": "posted", + "comment": 31700, + "transport": { + "outcome": "posted", + "status": 201, + "comment": 31700, + "detail": "created" + }, + "resolutions": [] + } + ], + "duplicateRisk": false, + "receipts": [ + { + "reviewer": "boyd", + "op": "boyd-331-verdict-0001", + "at": "2026-10-25T08:34:19.080Z", + "verdict": "changes", + "comment": 31701, + "candidate": "d62c69c8677df1d9e536b4deba16d7d4bb95c062" + } + ] + }, + { + "n": 2, + "op": "magica-331-round2-review-0060", + "by": "magica", + "at": "2026-10-25T09:36:56.297Z", + "issue": 1829, + "candidate": { + "kind": "manifest", + "digest": "fb0a7b68a70ebea1db745dfa3a89c0f93b06cbebeab9e2c9d1839369d276d5b6", + "text": "667b60c9935528aee1c489aaaf284222bab6af1b579e1f8f2fdec4dcb7d7a0f6 docs/plans/DEFERRED.md\neafd7e4b7a0d32b7522fa17e1424db088efedc69777b2ed914e98d07a9ffb6a5 packages/bus/src/broker.mjs\n1c27b306be4b1d9a3b163b940cf4d9ca0badd62812ed7c78670865a846cad0bd packages/bus/src/credentials.mjs\nbf96f9413537d75991464df1b6893c999c01599976eb48eb2032e33e9aade92a packages/bus/src/model-keys.mjs\n3d429ef05c2f869c8782273563fe13b0f02701832349f268634d3ba53a316285 packages/bus/src/process.mjs\n2894ea78e85ca4e11b2acf5dc130bea4cec75eeb1e30eea3bc068d336b58f7a6 packages/bus/src/runtime.mjs\n9a5f913845e2a987b4fe2fcc191b0d207696c1271455609aafc6c804906559bf packages/bus/tests/model-credential-store.test.mjs\n6986c8e290749b9f8f861c8c8d1b39f610131142482842e4834e3c6d48772040 packages/bus/tests/model-keys.test.mjs\nadcc349357f4ac89956a6bc503af5730b03bfff1ffff20fb07bcdb4d247cbd72 packages/bus/tests/model-proxy.test.mjs\ndaf5997cdb367388c1b79ff9392c33ce203d16bec2dc5b351dcb18497fdeb656 packages/bus/tests/model-restart.test.mjs\n5d2ed538b6db01530b4365675cf664ebee523ffb8ce853d58b635a7373917231 packages/bus/tests/model-retirement-boundary.test.mjs\ncb4f72afc070d86fc10c9fb410b03969341f3d7015da6ebaaec5ea1f780899ae packages/bus/tests/model-stop.test.mjs\nf13554e08d7390455075f085dbe2cb2f9e39e678a6513e32cb41b4ba1817e276 packages/bus/tests/project-runtime.test.mjs\n1e663b175e18e39ff68c9ac3a65ff71fc777a6c37ebca035fce6a2783d0aaac3 packages/cli/src/cli.mjs\n0272cc7c8e2ccbca9d92e4d3a34293cedc8a9bb1ec45fed88917050bd9bdede7 packages/cli/src/launcher.mjs\n9a043f122e1d49103bab64716d0eb80cfc09da3c91f7e2eb014b0d8ff0b02f3d packages/cli/src/model-proxy.mjs\n3df9770e8aae51357986a16473c96d2a3879bcd436153fa25c70f71b0ab181d7 packages/cli/src/model-stall.mjs\nc4b14bb65b2ea10603f8dfa446ac7a2d31fea6e2f7382892beaed5d3372dd237 packages/cli/tests/model-proxy-guards.test.mjs\n655c9ec5d37e8fa0a8ba3340ec053c886072519b6d322f298654d0ba152d287f packages/cli/tests/model-stall.test.mjs\n1ef13e5bd2ea9b166b505c46821f1649444b8fab9882531975858ce20a79f341 packages/harness/src/first-output.mjs\n9c0a0482c877dd5eae1e2691f20d30e37a289d68cb7d4998b0418c44055ae6d1 packages/harness/src/runner.mjs\n9cf8bbac00be602675e913699cb57d625bb1cab7a2734aa39396b6b9fe308351 packages/harness/tests/first-output.test.mjs\n982d06ff27cb69a8e099802cb062e7915e6e26a8a35d698950f21f9209c6e067 packages/model-proxy/README.md\n47120f55d91f110668d48c7fc7b7c2e1de513082bea6197ebc5073bcfea7f611 packages/model-proxy/src/client.mjs\na6fb88352018b8f21593a0bb9311f87162c80d8b1e05e62b4d43b1e69af21b23 packages/model-proxy/src/common.mjs\n1eac4b5741b360a077bb1c871c008b64f7c7119afc64be4d6e4a0dcdb3a313bb packages/model-proxy/src/settings.mjs\ne66453cf6662677cf28cbad1ae8f7509917d333e5b80404ab02c53f5cf75e9e1 packages/model-proxy/src/validation.mjs\n77327681d6eb51f25d7aeffcc532b7e8269c1dc59139cb03adb4a3a1409f63e9 packages/model-proxy/tests/client-probe.test.mjs\n858a0d254de44acc2d8e9d57e823ab2b4c6820059d1d29d2d73270a313a557ee packages/model-proxy/tests/p2-settings.test.mjs\ne0a79c3cc9b0e1a0d542f28539ce1e6c9f7239efab2ddbcbc0ee4651e85014cd packages/model-proxy/tests/validation.test.mjs\na203f7bb2735e4abeb0758c7719022545696b35f00d7943144b73aa892091807 packages/seat/src/sandbox.mjs\n0def1344345fe5fd719b8548ddc115d1ba581577294179a3996cb6f39dd5088a packages/seat/tests/sandbox.test.mjs\n55acb1965a630c079a39db740609074790310e47dc9e84f8decf5f278f102738 scripts/mosaic-config.mjs\n" + }, + "request": "comment", + "attempts": [ + { + "op": "magica-331-round2-review-0060", + "by": "magica", + "at": "2026-10-25T09:36:56.297Z", + "state": "failed", + "comment": null, + "transport": { + "outcome": "failed", + "status": null, + "comment": null, + "detail": "pre-send: the credential or account check failed" + }, + "resolutions": [] + }, + { + "op": "sage-4504-row331-round2-review", + "by": "sage", + "at": "2026-10-25T09:41:03.992Z", + "state": "posted", + "comment": 31702, + "transport": { + "outcome": "posted", + "status": 201, + "comment": 31702, + "detail": "created" + }, + "resolutions": [] + } + ], + "duplicateRisk": false, + "receipts": [ + { + "reviewer": "boyd", + "op": "boyd-331-verdict-0002", + "at": "2026-10-25T10:04:47.426Z", + "verdict": "changes", + "comment": 31705, + "candidate": "fb0a7b68a70ebea1db745dfa3a89c0f93b06cbebeab9e2c9d1839369d276d5b6" + } + ] + }, + { + "n": 3, + "op": "magica-331-round3-review-0129", + "by": "magica", + "at": "2026-10-25T17:06:36.866Z", + "issue": 1829, + "candidate": { + "kind": "manifest", + "digest": "bb2583e91bdb4080b5c25595d9df06ef2a5360ba866e9ac0866175aa9c7221ef", + "text": "95e2c9568498cbe628d62f1ef981dfb6819fc9acad0337086b67adc8717208fd docs/plans/2026-10-24_model-proxy-rows.md\n3038d65cd3e42c858445d92ac25675f7c5ae66babef1ef79799bd17ae59f0b17 docs/plans/2026-10-24_stack-model-proxy.md\n667b60c9935528aee1c489aaaf284222bab6af1b579e1f8f2fdec4dcb7d7a0f6 docs/plans/DEFERRED.md\n7ae9c3cef21024bebf32bd0c8af861a64d39b0137e8ba5899612004dd898b33c packages/bus/src/broker.mjs\n1c27b306be4b1d9a3b163b940cf4d9ca0badd62812ed7c78670865a846cad0bd packages/bus/src/credentials.mjs\n815b92c8e0b7b6eca8495ea745c0ec7cfdc91296a44d9b0a62b94ed9b5bc9e1d packages/bus/src/model-keys.mjs\ned13afdce6359df31d35a79496ebb4afdefef82030a8326a76b2a25b37e98d9d packages/bus/src/process.mjs\nc34497a1b1b009f7de156dcc7867e25f1b3afc4a876eed01f319d335a229a6a3 packages/bus/src/runtime.mjs\n9a5f913845e2a987b4fe2fcc191b0d207696c1271455609aafc6c804906559bf packages/bus/tests/model-credential-store.test.mjs\nce5f042304949d1aed85db003038059bbc3dae6dd7e915a1322db31c81eef8c9 packages/bus/tests/model-historical-cleanup.test.mjs\na5ad060fc9636aab1e142dedfff430f8955fbd6d0a67c9ebdf2062ac72cbdaf2 packages/bus/tests/model-historical-ipc.test.mjs\na9573572cba4ca747cebec232bfa39c744ab7df13fbe1876a19139d2ace0ebf7 packages/bus/tests/model-key-loss-interaction.test.mjs\nc1b24468e8220db6d881945fd5730f6c673dca84c14f179e9a74338c2b0ed9af packages/bus/tests/model-key-provenance.test.mjs\n6986c8e290749b9f8f861c8c8d1b39f610131142482842e4834e3c6d48772040 packages/bus/tests/model-keys.test.mjs\n3be2add875bec6c187d93528afede338a4e178566c61c30a1dfe74fa7ec0cfd6 packages/bus/tests/model-lifecycle-fixtures.mjs\nc5e5c1239bee252dca7ab0089105f0f3719824dcbae3013d82b4a5ba74aa1e6f packages/bus/tests/model-orphan-admission.test.mjs\nd2070945a6603cff4b7dfe98cc9026c9fc28419b2605a4ff904da48406b317ae packages/bus/tests/model-orphan-hire.test.mjs\nadcc349357f4ac89956a6bc503af5730b03bfff1ffff20fb07bcdb4d247cbd72 packages/bus/tests/model-proxy.test.mjs\ndaf5997cdb367388c1b79ff9392c33ce203d16bec2dc5b351dcb18497fdeb656 packages/bus/tests/model-restart.test.mjs\n5d2ed538b6db01530b4365675cf664ebee523ffb8ce853d58b635a7373917231 packages/bus/tests/model-retirement-boundary.test.mjs\n47be63b35472c12421f17700bc096557a89b88a2cd954ecb7e1ca1826f259af2 packages/bus/tests/model-review-fixtures.mjs\ncb4f72afc070d86fc10c9fb410b03969341f3d7015da6ebaaec5ea1f780899ae packages/bus/tests/model-stop.test.mjs\nfe0e3359db0d4cc0700df475fc10e3aa5ea0ec66088e2a222e11a34196193421 packages/bus/tests/model-sweep-isolation.test.mjs\n0e9c73f66e6c6413f7c5c7b79703302c38c5034273c08e6f0dbcdde0a643cf23 packages/bus/tests/model-terminal-proof.test.mjs\nf13554e08d7390455075f085dbe2cb2f9e39e678a6513e32cb41b4ba1817e276 packages/bus/tests/project-runtime.test.mjs\n1e663b175e18e39ff68c9ac3a65ff71fc777a6c37ebca035fce6a2783d0aaac3 packages/cli/src/cli.mjs\nd25274407d3ac3803e85a9dea93c34738dd05b8cd1fbbcc7325c5f682b9eed91 packages/cli/src/launcher.mjs\n9a043f122e1d49103bab64716d0eb80cfc09da3c91f7e2eb014b0d8ff0b02f3d packages/cli/src/model-proxy.mjs\n0bdc91dcaa096bd3dc9d08a1dea59893a21f6505c843e698ad9c8daa4b74364b packages/cli/src/model-stall.mjs\na937f5048fd151582c3ab59f0ce50a54183ff7df9b8c37d44f43505daf9e02e5 packages/cli/tests/fixtures/model-clock-probe.mjs\nc4b14bb65b2ea10603f8dfa446ac7a2d31fea6e2f7382892beaed5d3372dd237 packages/cli/tests/model-proxy-guards.test.mjs\n655c9ec5d37e8fa0a8ba3340ec053c886072519b6d322f298654d0ba152d287f packages/cli/tests/model-stall.test.mjs\n1ad28416c4e55e9feebadafd8f2f2785968620b2445dba41362c470bbef4b214 packages/cli/tests/model-turn-clock.test.mjs\n7a9507a382c4e7a3216c3d3af6df8c35ccb17e5454d6b3701ffcd6e2113e9bbc packages/cli/tests/model-turn-reader.test.mjs\n00af9fdbed4ba727f7a7cec3fa1890154eae01034464a4e85e32005853573a4f packages/cli/tests/session-clear.test.mjs\nc2fa4420fef203370e68656b4b2b3abbe407d2267d0f20bf9f0d4b27cbdec7ef packages/cli/tests/thread-revoke.test.mjs\n6263d358bc6222948242a102d3196727b3cc14a1cc5d02a4fb06f9dc1291d764 packages/harness/src/first-output.mjs\nd4bfea03e7a4f9cb7a5a8515afd32d3b567d95e9aa4234518648a1ed152bc484 packages/harness/src/runner.mjs\n9cf8bbac00be602675e913699cb57d625bb1cab7a2734aa39396b6b9fe308351 packages/harness/tests/first-output.test.mjs\nd2aacf299f157d66ebca15ff8c2e1bde9845b1ac1d789f62fab64e3aa4e89459 packages/harness/tests/first-turn.test.mjs\n6a11bba06be1265ec7ab0229464334f6258a9fc2852615cce9b3acd7cca0437c packages/harness/tests/model-turn-publication.test.mjs\n982d06ff27cb69a8e099802cb062e7915e6e26a8a35d698950f21f9209c6e067 packages/model-proxy/README.md\n47120f55d91f110668d48c7fc7b7c2e1de513082bea6197ebc5073bcfea7f611 packages/model-proxy/src/client.mjs\na6fb88352018b8f21593a0bb9311f87162c80d8b1e05e62b4d43b1e69af21b23 packages/model-proxy/src/common.mjs\n1eac4b5741b360a077bb1c871c008b64f7c7119afc64be4d6e4a0dcdb3a313bb packages/model-proxy/src/settings.mjs\ne66453cf6662677cf28cbad1ae8f7509917d333e5b80404ab02c53f5cf75e9e1 packages/model-proxy/src/validation.mjs\n77327681d6eb51f25d7aeffcc532b7e8269c1dc59139cb03adb4a3a1409f63e9 packages/model-proxy/tests/client-probe.test.mjs\n858a0d254de44acc2d8e9d57e823ab2b4c6820059d1d29d2d73270a313a557ee packages/model-proxy/tests/p2-settings.test.mjs\ne0a79c3cc9b0e1a0d542f28539ce1e6c9f7239efab2ddbcbc0ee4651e85014cd packages/model-proxy/tests/validation.test.mjs\na203f7bb2735e4abeb0758c7719022545696b35f00d7943144b73aa892091807 packages/seat/src/sandbox.mjs\n3fb2e3841f7368bcdd851aad1b4a6293175e0258bb6aa2cd1cdc2fd03c42049f packages/seat/tests/model-markers-confined.test.mjs\n0def1344345fe5fd719b8548ddc115d1ba581577294179a3996cb6f39dd5088a packages/seat/tests/sandbox.test.mjs\n55acb1965a630c079a39db740609074790310e47dc9e84f8decf5f278f102738 scripts/mosaic-config.mjs\n" + }, + "request": "comment", + "attempts": [ + { + "op": "magica-331-round3-review-0129", + "by": "magica", + "at": "2026-10-25T17:06:36.866Z", + "state": "failed", + "comment": null, + "transport": { + "outcome": "failed", + "status": null, + "comment": null, + "detail": "pre-send: the credential or account check failed" + }, + "resolutions": [] + }, + { + "op": "sage-4678-row331-round3-review", + "by": "sage", + "at": "2026-10-25T17:13:29.637Z", + "state": "posted", + "comment": 31706, + "transport": { + "outcome": "posted", + "status": 201, + "comment": 31706, + "detail": "created" + }, + "resolutions": [] + } + ], + "duplicateRisk": false, + "receipts": [ + { + "reviewer": "boyd", + "op": "boyd-331-verdict-0003", + "at": "2026-10-25T17:46:24.006Z", + "verdict": "changes", + "comment": 31707, + "candidate": "bb2583e91bdb4080b5c25595d9df06ef2a5360ba866e9ac0866175aa9c7221ef" + } + ] + } + ] + }, + "claim": { + "seat": "magica", + "op": "magica-331-start" + }, + "note": "P2 input from magica-0020 (acceptance-probe-4): 8.0.42 revocation lags ~105ms after v8 PUT (first call 200, then 401); reconcile/revoke must poll to 401, not assume instant. Per-key model objects give 422; no per-key model restriction.", + "blockedReason": null, + "createdAt": "2026-10-24T19:11:25.454Z", + "updatedAt": "2026-10-25T17:46:24.006Z", + "updatedBy": "boyd" + } + ], + "claim": "Actual observation only; no request/verdict comment invented" +} diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/queue-verdict-file-note-receipts.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/queue-verdict-file-note-receipts.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9c5f5a6d7 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/queue-verdict-file-note-receipts.json @@ -0,0 +1,36 @@ +[ + { + "row": 330, + "op": "sage-4866-row330-real-review-files", + "rc": 0, + "stdout": "ok sage-4866-row330-real-review-files rev 4142 row 330 note\n", + "stderr": "", + "note": "Mos1915 tracking-only OPEN: code landed52ba14c5f/product362893d04 first under1864. REAL postlanding APPROVE files: agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/filbert-real-postlanding-verdict.md and agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/gladstone-real-postlanding-verdict.md (authors/candidate/time/hash in verified-review-files.json). RequestR1failedpre-send/no comment; no queue approvals. Wait lawfulposting/#436, blocks nothing. NEW-330-01 is separate backlog task665, no landing reopen/gate." + }, + { + "row": 331, + "op": "sage-4866-row331-real-review-files", + "rc": 2, + "stdout": "", + "stderr": "queue: note is longer than 500 characters\n", + "note": "P2 input from magica-0020 (acceptance-probe-4): 8.0.42 revocation lags ~105ms after v8 PUT (first call 200, then 401); reconcile/revoke must poll to 401, not assume instant. Per-key model objects give 422; no per-key model restriction.\nMos1915/1917 tracking-only OPEN: code landed52ba14c5f/product362893d04 first under1864. REAL postlanding APPROVE files: agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/boyd-real-postlanding-verdict.md and agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/dewey-real-postlanding-verdict.md (authors/candidate/time/hash in verified-review-files.json). R4requestfailedpre-send/no comment; R3CHANGES31707 preserved/no approvals. Repairs646-648/652-655confirmedscoped;656narrowconfirmed/broaderPARTIAL; no taskclosesuntilrealcomment. Wait lawfulposting/#436, no block/gate;657/658backlog." + }, + { + "row": 331, + "op": "sage-4867-row331-file-index-note", + "rc": 2, + "stdout": "", + "stderr": "queue: note must be one line with no control characters\n", + "note": "P2 input from magica-0020 (acceptance-probe-4): 8.0.42 revocation lags ~105ms after v8 PUT (first call 200, then 401); reconcile/revoke must poll to 401, not assume instant. Per-key model objects give 422; no per-key model restriction.\nMos1915 tracking-only OPEN/#436: landed52ba; realBoyd/Dewey APPROVE files, no comments/queueapprovals. Index+hashes: agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/verified-review-files.json.656narrowfixed/broaderPARTIAL;657/658backlog.", + "priorRefusal": "over500char rejected with no mutation; bounded indexcitation replaces attempted new text, original note preserved" + }, + { + "row": 331, + "op": "sage-4868-row331-singleline-file-note", + "rc": 0, + "stdout": "ok sage-4868-row331-singleline-file-note rev 4143 row 331 note\n", + "stderr": "", + "note": "P2 input from magica-0020 (acceptance-probe-4): 8.0.42 revocation lags ~105ms after v8 PUT (first call 200, then 401); reconcile/revoke must poll to 401, not assume instant. Per-key model objects give 422; no per-key model restriction. Mos1915 tracking-only OPEN/#436: landed52ba; realBoyd/Dewey APPROVE files, no comments/queueapprovals. Index+hashes: agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/verified-review-files.json.656narrowfixed/broaderPARTIAL;657/658backlog.", + "format": "one-line <=500 chars; original235-char note exactprefix preserved" + } +] diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/repair-task-scope-index.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/repair-task-scope-index.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0039f5161 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/repair-task-scope-index.json @@ -0,0 +1,71 @@ +{ + "source": "actualVikunjaAPI/currenttaskdescriptions, no reviewer confirmation or taskclosure inferred", + "landed": "52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1", + "product": "362893d043ff96fdd35f18e326cce683db031471", + "tasks": [ + { + "task": 646, + "title": "Repair row 331 sandbox import closure without adding data access (owner Sage)", + "done": false, + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task646-before.json", + "sha256": "8112ee2a288c78e79d20a5e970be9862f4a2710d1005af6a392cd6fbfcc0eb5e", + "bytes": 2293 + }, + { + "task": 647, + "title": "Repair full P2 B1: preserve retiring model keys for persisted sessions after restart (owner Sage)", + "done": false, + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task647-before.json", + "sha256": "36397966479fabb5e905baf361aa046e58abda05142242229d12f2aaa91a77cd", + "bytes": 2506 + }, + { + "task": 648, + "title": "Full P2 M1: adjudicate cached process exit and PID reuse without weakening discovery (owner Sage)", + "done": false, + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task648-before.json", + "sha256": "01e31cc617d30626a1a2a27812f43166e3dba04c91652851ea1506a4e1d29a35", + "bytes": 1774 + }, + { + "task": 652, + "title": "Investigate M1/L3b lost key association and later retirement availability (owner Sage)", + "done": false, + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task652-before.json", + "sha256": "19224245906760cd2b6853878a563c1ff86189697d790958a7aa4bc333151457", + "bytes": 2598 + }, + { + "task": 653, + "title": "Repair P2 round 3 B1: launcher fs binding and actual proxy-launch regression (owner Sage)", + "done": false, + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task653-before.json", + "sha256": "47996fe1c328d64cdb13a09162f035fc6063cad8b205ae724944321c1b2a896d", + "bytes": 1946 + }, + { + "task": 654, + "title": "Cover P2 round 3 L1: pending organization-busy refusal branch (owner Sage)", + "done": false, + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task654-before.json", + "sha256": "a5750c65823faf93299213105163b3c605e6fea4d529b6e9ec9649a500d104d6", + "bytes": 1837 + }, + { + "task": 655, + "title": "Resolve P2 round 3 L2: failed-hire cleanup and concurrent credential ownership (owner Sage)", + "done": false, + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task655-before.json", + "sha256": "e05a0cb27a222f7744808a18b9588f3fba1dcdcdfc1ad6cfcfcfff672d11bc60", + "bytes": 1933 + }, + { + "task": 656, + "title": "Resolve P2 round 3 L3: recognized model temporary-state recovery (owner Sage)", + "done": false, + "path": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task656-before.json", + "sha256": "391c1843b75448ec8af8c1896bf370678962dedb5253b1803564bcd0ba249711", + "bytes": 1766 + } + ] +} diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/review-completion-summary.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/review-completion-summary.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..569b927c5 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/review-completion-summary.json @@ -0,0 +1,21 @@ +{ + "at": "2026-10-26T18:00:06.762182+00:00", + "candidate": "52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1", + "product": "362893d043ff96fdd35f18e326cce683db031471", + "all1968ProductInputsStillMatch": true, + "authors": [ + "Boyd", + "Dewey", + "Filbert", + "Gladstone" + ], + "verdicts": "all four APPROVE scoped; Dewey656PARTIALoriginalbroadwording", + "actualPostedComments": 0, + "actualQueueApprovals": 0, + "newFindingTask": 665, + "newSourceOrTestOrGate": false, + "rows": "tracking-onlyOPEN underMos1915; no closurefromfiles", + "task662ScopeComment": 1338, + "runner660": "PR405REVISE/no readytarget/no newgate", + "backlog657658": true +} diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task646-before.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task646-before.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ddaa5550f --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task646-before.json @@ -0,0 +1,40 @@ +{ + "$schema": "https://tasks.woltje.com/api/v2/schemas/TaskReadOneBody.json", + "id": 646, + "title": "Repair row 331 sandbox import closure without adding data access (owner Sage)", + "description": "

2026-10-25T07:49:13Z: sage-4468/Magica trace and Mos read-only source checks at0965fe1ea confirm runner -> client -> Broker -> common imports fs/path/http/crypto and reads PIN at module load; RUNNER_FILES omits common/PIN and first-output.mjs. Magica r4 stopped at file69 with no landing.

Scope approved by mos-1698: pure validation.mjs holds ProxyError/refuse/validManagementKey/proxyTiming, importing only validateHeaderValue from node:http; common imports/reexports same bindings, Broker imports validation. Preserve semantics/error identity. Add precisely validation.mjs and harness/first-output.mjs as read-only runner files, no common/PIN/config/state/secrets/directory mounts or unnecessary image/copy expansion. Preserve exact import/no-lazy guard and closure equality, add purity/I-O guard and actual confined-startup tests.

Acceptance: new content manifest, focused regression/confinement evidence, fresh independent Q246 Claude guard/security review before landing, plus existing row331/global landing gates. No assertion/deadline/threshold relaxation. Coordinator Sage relays scope to Magica and returns findings. Task tracks this corrective boundary work, not all row331 or row288 completion.

", + "project_id": 19, + "done": false, + "done_at": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "due_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "reminders": null, + "repeat_after": 0, + "repeat_mode": 0, + "priority": 4, + "start_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "end_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "assignees": null, + "labels": null, + "hex_color": "", + "percent_done": 0, + "identifier": "MOSAICSTA-448", + "index": 448, + "related_tasks": {}, + "attachments": null, + "cover_image_attachment_id": 0, + "is_favorite": false, + "created": "2026-10-25T07:49:13Z", + "updated": "2026-10-25T08:24:40Z", + "bucket_id": 0, + "position": 0, + "reactions": null, + "created_by": { + "id": 11, + "name": "mosaic-stack mos", + "username": "bot-mosaic-stack-mos", + "bot_owner_id": 5, + "created": "2026-10-12T17:42:25Z", + "updated": "2026-10-12T17:42:25Z" + }, + "max_permission": 0 +} diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task647-before.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task647-before.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3ebd7f0ae --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task647-before.json @@ -0,0 +1,40 @@ +{ + "$schema": "https://tasks.woltje.com/api/v2/schemas/TaskReadOneBody.json", + "id": 647, + "title": "Repair full P2 B1: preserve retiring model keys for persisted sessions after restart (owner Sage)", + "description": "

2026-10-25T08:33:20Z: sage-4484 reports Boyd first full-P2 Codex verdict CHANGES, high B1. Mos source check at4948ece0e confirms runtime.mjs:164 creates an empty modelRuns map; :209 supplies only that map to ModelKeys; bindLaunch populates it later. model-keys.mjs:163-172 removes a retiring key when the view returns no matching run, without retaining future grace. Existing persisted sessions are not represented at that point; --no-launch and normal recovery are reported affected.

Owner Sage with Magica. Existing bounded preparation sage-4483 remains: propose runtime/restart regressions and the smallest authoritative identity-checked persisted-session view. Record intended pre-fix RED only under a future test CLEAR; no premature rerun/source patch. Fail closed and retain on unknown/failed discovery or stop. Preserve --no-launch, existing grace semantics, identity checks and stop authority.

Any guard/deadline/public-schema/refusal/authority boundary change needs a concrete owner ruling first. Then focused verification and fresh independent full-P2/credential/security reviews on the repaired candidate, plus existing full/global/FED R7/row288/landing gates. Prior builder evidence remains scoped to its code; the narrow closure approval under #646 is not reversed. Canonical review request is owned by Sage operation sage-4481-row331-review; do not duplicate it or borrow credentials.

", + "project_id": 19, + "done": false, + "done_at": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "due_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "reminders": null, + "repeat_after": 0, + "repeat_mode": 0, + "priority": 4, + "start_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "end_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "assignees": null, + "labels": null, + "hex_color": "", + "percent_done": 0, + "identifier": "MOSAICSTA-449", + "index": 449, + "related_tasks": {}, + "attachments": null, + "cover_image_attachment_id": 0, + "is_favorite": false, + "created": "2026-10-25T08:33:20Z", + "updated": "2026-10-25T17:46:39Z", + "bucket_id": 0, + "position": 0, + "reactions": null, + "created_by": { + "id": 11, + "name": "mosaic-stack mos", + "username": "bot-mosaic-stack-mos", + "bot_owner_id": 5, + "created": "2026-10-12T17:42:25Z", + "updated": "2026-10-12T17:42:25Z" + }, + "max_permission": 0 +} diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task648-before.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task648-before.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..14196ae9b --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task648-before.json @@ -0,0 +1,40 @@ +{ + "$schema": "https://tasks.woltje.com/api/v2/schemas/TaskReadOneBody.json", + "id": 648, + "title": "Full P2 M1: adjudicate cached process exit and PID reuse without weakening discovery (owner Sage)", + "description": "2026-10-25T09:59:41Z: Fresh full Claude Q246 review REQUEST_CHANGES at81cbdea37 identifies M1, cached known entry survives old process exit and later PID reuse, making retirement refuse. Boyd contrary APPROVE is preserved; Sage4508 read-only adjudication/Magica4509 static proposals continue. Reproduce and distinguish a previously verified identity whose exit can be confirmed from an initial corrupt/mismatched snapshot. Do not turn arbitrary first-discovery mismatch into exit; preserve #647 fail-closed discovery/identity/stop rules. Return minimal proposal before changes, test-first bounded CLEAR and fresh full reviews/gates before landing. Links: #647/full-round2-verdict.json.", + "project_id": 19, + "done": false, + "done_at": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "due_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "reminders": null, + "repeat_after": 0, + "repeat_mode": 0, + "priority": 4, + "start_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "end_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "assignees": null, + "labels": null, + "hex_color": "", + "percent_done": 0, + "identifier": "MOSAICSTA-450", + "index": 450, + "related_tasks": {}, + "attachments": null, + "cover_image_attachment_id": 0, + "is_favorite": false, + "created": "2026-10-25T09:59:41Z", + "updated": "2026-10-25T10:45:38Z", + "bucket_id": 0, + "position": 0, + "reactions": null, + "created_by": { + "id": 11, + "name": "mosaic-stack mos", + "username": "bot-mosaic-stack-mos", + "bot_owner_id": 5, + "created": "2026-10-12T17:42:25Z", + "updated": "2026-10-12T17:42:25Z" + }, + "max_permission": 0 +} diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task652-before.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task652-before.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..74b1fd6bb --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task652-before.json @@ -0,0 +1,40 @@ +{ + "$schema": "https://tasks.woltje.com/api/v2/schemas/TaskReadOneBody.json", + "id": 652, + "title": "Investigate M1/L3b lost key association and later retirement availability (owner Sage)", + "description": "2026-10-25T11:16:59Z sage4554 source-only interaction, not an executed regression or confirmed acceptance blocker. Source5868 M1 known inventory validates current/retiring key association before acquiring incomplete terminal proof. Accepted unapplied L3b43c14 drops a confirmed-absent old current rather than inventing retirement. A previously known live run with that old key may then fail association checks even after process exit, holding later retirement. Preserve strict initial unknown/corrupt-key and process identity guards. Prepare ONLY a bounded static regression proposal for known live old-current run -> confirmed remote absence -> ensure/rotate fresh generation -> independent outer/runner exit -> later retirement, including stale Registry and no-run/initial-corrupt controls. Explicitly distinguish process-exit observation, terminal proof, key metadata and remote absence. Return proposed assertion map, immutable product/proposal pins and exact future run scope before execution or any additional product fix. Do not re-add absent key to retirement, restore it remotely, infer exit from mismatch, erase known inventory or add stop authority. Current corrected #651 controller/runtime intended RED path may continue under existing CLEARs. Scope liveness claims until this is resolved or explicitly accepted by final reviewers. Done only after inspectable proposal and explicit measured/deferred disposition are recorded with full-review handoff. #648/#651/#647 linked, full/global/landing gates remain.", + "project_id": 19, + "done": false, + "done_at": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "due_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "reminders": null, + "repeat_after": 0, + "repeat_mode": 0, + "priority": 3, + "start_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "end_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "assignees": null, + "labels": null, + "hex_color": "", + "percent_done": 0, + "identifier": "MOSAICSTA-454", + "index": 454, + "related_tasks": {}, + "attachments": null, + "cover_image_attachment_id": 0, + "is_favorite": false, + "created": "2026-10-25T11:16:59Z", + "updated": "2026-10-25T14:28:15Z", + "bucket_id": 0, + "position": 0, + "reactions": null, + "created_by": { + "id": 11, + "name": "mosaic-stack mos", + "username": "bot-mosaic-stack-mos", + "bot_owner_id": 5, + "created": "2026-10-12T17:42:25Z", + "updated": "2026-10-12T17:42:25Z" + }, + "max_permission": 0 +} diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task653-before.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task653-before.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..03a96b335 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task653-before.json @@ -0,0 +1,40 @@ +{ + "$schema": "https://tasks.woltje.com/api/v2/schemas/TaskReadOneBody.json", + "id": 653, + "title": "Repair P2 round 3 B1: launcher fs binding and actual proxy-launch regression (owner Sage)", + "description": "Formal R3 both independent reviews CHANGES on sourcefff/candidatebb. Launcher uses writeFileSync519 without fs import144, caught as launch-failed520 before actual proxy spawn/bind/watch. Deterministic source trace, no runtime reproduction yet. Mos next scope is STATIC test-first packet after definitive canonical R3 CHANGES readback: exact unapplied binding-only import diff and whole-file actual createLauncher proxy-mode regression using only owned fake/local preflight, enable marker0600, real owned runner/trusted bind/watch path and refusal/nonproxy controls. Pin legal command/config/fixtures/content/dependencies and expected old failure. No product application/test execution until separate inspected ruling. Final acceptance needs verified intended RED, focused/full evidence and fresh independent fullP2/Q246 reviews. Parent647, prior647-652 remain open.", + "project_id": 19, + "done": false, + "done_at": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "due_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "reminders": null, + "repeat_after": 0, + "repeat_mode": 0, + "priority": 4, + "start_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "end_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "assignees": null, + "labels": null, + "hex_color": "", + "percent_done": 0, + "identifier": "MOSAICSTA-455", + "index": 455, + "related_tasks": {}, + "attachments": null, + "cover_image_attachment_id": 0, + "is_favorite": false, + "created": "2026-10-25T17:45:04Z", + "updated": "2026-10-25T18:44:43Z", + "bucket_id": 0, + "position": 0, + "reactions": null, + "created_by": { + "id": 11, + "name": "mosaic-stack mos", + "username": "bot-mosaic-stack-mos", + "bot_owner_id": 5, + "created": "2026-10-12T17:42:25Z", + "updated": "2026-10-12T17:42:25Z" + }, + "max_permission": 0 +} diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task654-before.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task654-before.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..82e1826e9 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task654-before.json @@ -0,0 +1,40 @@ +{ + "$schema": "https://tasks.woltje.com/api/v2/schemas/TaskReadOneBody.json", + "id": 654, + "title": "Cover P2 round 3 L1: pending organization-busy refusal branch (owner Sage)", + "description": "R3 low finding agreed by Boyd and Claude: newly introduced per-business pending-wrapper gate model-keys245 reuses organization-busy but has no code-specific branch test. Currently reachable lifecycle concurrency, distinct from older writer lock. STATIC whole-file test packet only after canonical R3 CHANGES settles: deliberately pending first authorized operation, second same-business operation refuses exact organization-busy before effects, first operation preserved/completes, independent-business and pending-release controls where applicable. Existing product expected correct; do not invent intended RED or change semantics/assertions/deadlines. No execution or code application without separate inspection/CLEAR. Parent647; preserve sourcefff/bb and review31707.", + "project_id": 19, + "done": false, + "done_at": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "due_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "reminders": null, + "repeat_after": 0, + "repeat_mode": 0, + "priority": 2, + "start_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "end_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "assignees": null, + "labels": null, + "hex_color": "", + "percent_done": 0, + "identifier": "MOSAICSTA-456", + "index": 456, + "related_tasks": {}, + "attachments": null, + "cover_image_attachment_id": 0, + "is_favorite": false, + "created": "2026-10-25T17:45:04Z", + "updated": "2026-10-25T18:33:36Z", + "bucket_id": 0, + "position": 0, + "reactions": null, + "created_by": { + "id": 11, + "name": "mosaic-stack mos", + "username": "bot-mosaic-stack-mos", + "bot_owner_id": 5, + "created": "2026-10-12T17:42:25Z", + "updated": "2026-10-12T17:42:25Z" + }, + "max_permission": 0 +} diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task655-before.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task655-before.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0dbe77ca1 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task655-before.json @@ -0,0 +1,40 @@ +{ + "$schema": "https://tasks.woltje.com/api/v2/schemas/TaskReadOneBody.json", + "id": 655, + "title": "Resolve P2 round 3 L2: failed-hire cleanup and concurrent credential ownership (owner Sage)", + "description": "R3 source-adjudicated ownership race: hasRecord sampled before serialized ensure is not generation ownership. Legal duplicate hire may queue behind first preflight, reuse its credential, then instance-exists invokes failed-hire cleanup against another operation generation. Current issuance/revocation effects reachable; bound-consumer impact latent behind B1 and conditional ordering, unmeasured. STATIC legal actor/business/definition/membership/revision interleaving table, exact unapplied bounded proposal and regression/control plan. Preserve writer optionC, legitimate failed-unpublished-orphan cleanup, controller file assertions and stop-before-revocation/admission boundaries. No new stop authority, blanket cleanup or public/schema policy approved. Separate concrete disposition and execution/fix ruling required. Parent647, related651/652.", + "project_id": 19, + "done": false, + "done_at": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "due_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "reminders": null, + "repeat_after": 0, + "repeat_mode": 0, + "priority": 2, + "start_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "end_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "assignees": null, + "labels": null, + "hex_color": "", + "percent_done": 0, + "identifier": "MOSAICSTA-457", + "index": 457, + "related_tasks": {}, + "attachments": null, + "cover_image_attachment_id": 0, + "is_favorite": false, + "created": "2026-10-25T17:45:04Z", + "updated": "2026-10-26T17:35:39Z", + "bucket_id": 0, + "position": 0, + "reactions": null, + "created_by": { + "id": 11, + "name": "mosaic-stack mos", + "username": "bot-mosaic-stack-mos", + "bot_owner_id": 5, + "created": "2026-10-12T17:42:25Z", + "updated": "2026-10-12T17:42:25Z" + }, + "max_permission": 0 +} diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task656-before.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task656-before.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..41631e7b3 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/task656-before.json @@ -0,0 +1,40 @@ +{ + "$schema": "https://tasks.woltje.com/api/v2/schemas/TaskReadOneBody.json", + "id": 656, + "title": "Resolve P2 round 3 L3: recognized model temporary-state recovery (owner Sage)", + "description": "R3 qualified operability follow-up: model.tmp after partial write can block DELETE via Credentials.remove and FIRE via residual-file fence. Onlytmp and revoking-final+tmp need explicit accounting; valid-final rewrite or issue retry can self-repair. Manual-only claim rejected. STATIC crash/state/remote-intent/retry table, unknown-file and live/revoking-intent controls plus smallest unapplied recovery proposal or explicit justified disposition. No blind model/model.tmp allowlist, deletion, weakened unknown-file fence, filesystem schema or new cleanup authority. No test execution/application without concrete ruling. Parent647; preserve original Claude and Boyd/Sage qualifications separately.", + "project_id": 19, + "done": false, + "done_at": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "due_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "reminders": null, + "repeat_after": 0, + "repeat_mode": 0, + "priority": 2, + "start_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "end_date": "0001-01-01T00:00:00Z", + "assignees": null, + "labels": null, + "hex_color": "", + "percent_done": 0, + "identifier": "MOSAICSTA-458", + "index": 458, + "related_tasks": {}, + "attachments": null, + "cover_image_attachment_id": 0, + "is_favorite": false, + "created": "2026-10-25T17:45:04Z", + "updated": "2026-10-26T17:35:39Z", + "bucket_id": 0, + "position": 0, + "reactions": null, + "created_by": { + "id": 11, + "name": "mosaic-stack mos", + "username": "bot-mosaic-stack-mos", + "bot_owner_id": 5, + "created": "2026-10-12T17:42:25Z", + "updated": "2026-10-12T17:42:25Z" + }, + "max_permission": 0 +} diff --git a/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/verified-review-files.json b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/verified-review-files.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8e592a742 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/verified-review-files.json @@ -0,0 +1,52 @@ +[ + { + "author": "boyd", + "source": "/home/jwoltje/.t3/worktrees/mosaic-stack/boyd-row298/agents/boyd/work/queue-331/POSTLANDING-r4-REVIEW.md", + "copy": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/boyd-real-postlanding-verdict.md", + "sha256": "3d070b329f2b9f03e4e7aefaad965cb01e64b1dfe7b44465d068e285bbc2e7b8", + "bytes": 10136, + "candidate": "52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1", + "status": "FILE_ONLY, actual comment absent; no queue approval or taskclosure", + "authoredTime": "2026-10-26T17:51:52Z" + }, + { + "author": "boyd-metadata", + "source": "/home/jwoltje/.t3/worktrees/mosaic-stack/boyd-row298/agents/boyd/work/queue-331/POSTLANDING-r4-REVIEW.metadata.json", + "copy": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/boyd-metadata-real-postlanding-verdict.json", + "sha256": "500cec7289fab322a7fc2aacf0c4e740a485f53098e812eaf49107faae75cec6", + "bytes": 1055, + "candidate": "52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1", + "status": "FILE_ONLY, actual comment absent; no queue approval or taskclosure", + "authoredTime": "2026-10-26T17:51:52Z" + }, + { + "author": "dewey", + "source": "/mnt/storage/src/mosaic-stack/agents/dewey/work/queue-331/postlanding-mos1909/REVIEW.md", + "copy": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/dewey-real-postlanding-verdict.md", + "sha256": "ab7edcb484a32093e9cb541032def275665f1572aa97bb118d2742f1f29fa97c", + "bytes": 8444, + "candidate": "52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1", + "status": "FILE_ONLY; APPROVE scopedrepairs;656PARTIALoriginalbroadwording; no comment/approval/taskclosure", + "authoredTime": "2026-10-26T17:51:50Z" + }, + { + "author": "Gladstone", + "source": "/home/jwoltje/.t3/worktrees/mosaic-stack/gladstone-hostcheck-item5/agents/gladstone/work/queue-330/postlanding-review-20261026.md", + "copy": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/gladstone-real-postlanding-verdict.md", + "bytes": 8346, + "sha256": "3e88018f2a60bf6f394cf1a11a020c1b38a2e4cc4fb9a20d80fd84f313d49e8e", + "candidate": "52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1", + "status": "FILE_ONLY; APPROVE; no actual postedcomment or queuerecord; no newfinding", + "authoredTime": "2026-10-26T17:53:18.755413+00:00" + }, + { + "author": "Filbert", + "source": "/mnt/storage/src/mosaic-stack/agents/filbert/work/queue-330/postlanding-mos1909/REVIEW.md", + "copy": "agents/sage/work/postlanding-330-331/filbert-real-postlanding-verdict.md", + "bytes": 13692, + "sha256": "0f93bc883f1db2d2e136323040eaff2ad79aa184fa5ab140c94a0ae906f70ffe", + "candidate": "52ba14c5f1273d955956c42c48f5c9ed47fc94a1", + "status": "FILE_ONLY; APPROVE scoped originalrepairs; NEW-330-01 separatetask; no postedcomment or queuerecord", + "authoredTime": "2026-10-26T17:56:44Z" + } +] diff --git a/agents/sage/work/task662-scope/scope-post-receipt.json b/agents/sage/work/task662-scope/scope-post-receipt.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fe0ef1431 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/task662-scope/scope-post-receipt.json @@ -0,0 +1,25 @@ +{ + "task": 662, + "commentId": 1338, + "scopeSha256": "ffc9509c47f8217a56b3165f9ab3a8a7f99bfc084066aa490b5ee2835d5400ad", + "exactWholeBodyAuthorReadback": { + "id": 1338, + "comment": "# #662 scope: factory finding triage, mandate budget and flaky-test policy\n\nOwner: Sage. Authority: mos-1884; #659 S2\u2013S4; DECISIONS Q261/Q263 (Q24 yes), with Q222 human-only settings. Starts after rows330/331: landed origin/refactor through0e1dd0a95. This scopes product work in Mosaic Stack; it does not reopen #657/#658 or alter their backlog status.\n\n## Outcome\n\nThe next factory enforces bounded mandates, evidence-based finding triage and tracked flaky-test remediation in source. Console/CLI humans control the policy; agents can read their effective mandate and submit evidence, but cannot change guard settings, enlarge their own budget or make a failed gate pass.\n\n## Settings and defaults\n\nProposed engineering namespace: `factoryPolicy` in the instance's one system config, with Console/CLI editing behind existing human authentication and writer conventions; the new policy editor is part of this task. Final wire names belong to implementation; there is no agent-writable policy copy in a task description or prompt. Effective values and the policy revision used for each decision are visible and recorded. Missing optional settings use documented defaults; explicit malformed/unknown policy refuses policy-dependent mutation and never silently widens authority.\n\n| Control | Initial default | Effect |\n|---|---|---|\n| Finding blocking rule | `regression-or-red-gate` | Candidate-caused defects and red required gates block; preexisting defects receive a linked task and do not block this landing. |\n| Severity vocabulary | P0 urgent / P1 high / P2 normal / P3 low | Every finding carries severity separately from causality and blocking disposition. Severity does not turn an older defect into a regression or excuse a red gate. |\n| Review-round budget | 2 per mandate | Initial review and one subsequent review. This is Sage's proposed default, consistent with the existing two-round lead rule, not a new Jason-selected number. |\n| Allowed seat outcome reports | done / red-with-cause / hard-rule-wait / scope-change | The coordinator receives outcomes rather than routine per-step approval requests. Evidence remains available without status-message fan-out. |\n| Timing-failure action | deterministic source fix plus tracked quarantine | Preserve the failing test/assertions and raw failure; fix the timing dependency with the existing clock/readiness mechanisms. |\n| Quarantine mode | tracked, temporary, no gate exemption | Record the flake under the human-owned policy and link its source-fix task. It cannot remove a required gate, count a skip as PASS or waive a red required gate. |\n\nOnly an authenticated human may change effective settings, grant an override or extend the round allowance. An agent/PM may request a scope change under its existing task authority, not grant itself a budget reset. An environment variable may still select the legitimate system config under the existing contract; it cannot inject policy values. Role names, prompts, tester sessions and task JSON are not policy authority.\n\n## S2: finding triage\n\nRecord finding identity, severity, candidate/baseline references, reproduction or source evidence, causality (`candidate-caused`, `preexisting`, `unknown`), affected test and disposition. Derive the blocking decision from the current human policy and real gate state. A preexisting finding must retain its follow-up task/evidence; it does not trigger an open-ended design dependency. Unknown causality stays visibly unresolved until comparison establishes it; absence of evidence is not a passing test. Review receipts and the queue's existing actor/approval rules remain real, not fabricated or bypassed.\n\n## S3: bounded mandates\n\nEach new managed seat task has a nonempty goal, explicit acceptance criteria, scope/limits and an effective round budget tied to a mandate identity/revision. Validate this before dispatch. Count a round once when the actual review request is admitted; duplicate delivery/retry does not consume twice, and restart/relaunch does not reset the ledger. Exhaustion stops another review round and produces the bounded hard-rule-wait/scope-change outcome; it never marks work accepted or spawns replacement tasks to evade the budget. A human extension records who changed it and the old/new limits. Specify and test existing-task compatibility before enforcement; do not rewrite historical tasks or reinterpret existing prose as authenticated approval.\n\n## S4: flaky-test policy\n\nA timing failure reproducible under controlled load records exact test, commit/tree, raw failure, environment/load evidence and owner/source-fix task. An injected-clock/readiness regression demonstrates the source repair while retaining every original assertion. The quarantine record names the original test, reason, effective human-owned policy revision, explicit expiry/release condition and required reinstatement evidence. Recording a flake needs no per-step approval, and a quarantine record never independently authorizes exclusion from the required gate. No retries-until-green, larger deadline, assertion deletion, renamed-away failure or unreported skip substitutes for repair. Use owned deterministic fixtures instead of making acceptance depend on obtaining a slow host.\n\n## Acceptance criteria\n\n1. Human Console and CLI can read/update/reset the settings with defaults, validation, concurrency protection and an audit record; agent, PM and tester attempts through each actual exposed route refuse without a policy write.\n2. A real managed task carries its goal/criteria/effective budget into dispatch and the review coordinator. Missing/invalid mandate data refuses before work starts; legacy task behavior is explicitly covered rather than silently migrated.\n3. A controlled candidate regression blocks; the same independently demonstrated baseline defect produces a linked backlog task and permits the otherwise-green candidate. A real red required gate blocks regardless of finding label/severity. Unknown causality cannot be auto-classified as old or GREEN.\n4. With the default budget, two actual rounds are accounted for and a third refuses. Duplicate requests, crash/restart and changed task descriptions cannot replenish it; only a recorded human extension permits another round.\n5. Actual seat/coordinator routing accepts the four outcome types and preserves the goal/criteria across continuation. Exhaustion returns one actionable cause, not a new approval loop.\n6. Reproduce a timing race using an owned deterministic test signal; demonstrate RED before the source repair and GREEN after it with all original assertions. A wall-clock delay increase cannot satisfy this control.\n7. Quarantine creation/expiry/reinstatement and failure history are tested. Quarantined, skipped, unavailable, cancelled, timed-out and unrecognized outputs remain distinguishable from PASS, including gate-tool consumers. No automatic quarantine conceals a required failure.\n8. Atomic policy/ledger writes, stale revision, duplicate delivery, partial write and restart tests retain history and refuse uncertainty. No secrets enter decision receipts.\n9. Existing role/writer/queue/hook rules, normal task operations, system config compatibility and local test conventions remain covered. This task grants no new push/deploy/host/node authority.\n10. One bounded independent review of the implementation, targeted integration checks and the applicable full gate on the accepted dedicated runner precede landing. Report actual phase outcomes and frozen commit/tree; no count-only or composite acceptance.\n\n## Delivery boundary\n\nImplement as one bounded feature with independently testable policy/authorization, finding disposition and mandate/quarantine consumers. Expected source owners: system config loader and human settings surface; tasks/seat dispatch and durable review accounting; review/gate disposition consumers. Exact file/schema changes and tests are settled in the implementation plan against the then-current base, not copied into agent work artifacts as a substitute for enforcement. Documentation includes defaults, human overrides, compatibility and recovery behavior.\n\nS1/#660 infrastructure and S6/#661 node access remain Ops-owned. S5/#663 record archival is separate. No redesign of provider/model routing, deployment, source role authority or #657/#658 recovery protocols is part of #662. No new agent/review factory is launched by this scoping note.\n\n## #660 dependency\n\nAs inspected, #660 comment1335 reports source prepared, independent review/PR merge pending and no VM/CPU write applied. Sage has supplied the actual gate commands/runtime needs in comments1329/1334. Do not claim the tool targets a dedicated runner yet. When Ops supplies the ready verified endpoint/identity, approved profile, runtime checks and merged provisioning/runbook evidence, configure the gate target, refuse local fallback and complete one full frozen gate there; confirm actual target/receipts on #660. No local substitute run or host/Proxmox change is authorized by this scope.\n\nStable operation: sage-4849-task662-scope-mos1884.\n", + "author": { + "id": 13, + "name": "mosaic-stack sage", + "username": "bot-mosaic-stack-sage", + "bot_owner_id": 5, + "created": "2026-10-12T17:47:34Z", + "updated": "2026-10-12T17:47:34Z" + }, + "reactions": null, + "created": "2026-10-26T17:41:35Z", + "updated": "2026-10-26T17:41:35Z" + }, + "sourceBaseline": "0e1dd0a95ba6399a8f70e0412393cca2d28e07cd", + "implementationStarted": false, + "runner660Ready": false, + "readinessEvidence": "660 c1335: no VM/CPU write; review/PR merge outstanding", + "at": "2026-10-26T17:41:36.123672+00:00" +} diff --git a/agents/sage/work/task662-scope/scope.md b/agents/sage/work/task662-scope/scope.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8a4fdf462 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/sage/work/task662-scope/scope.md @@ -0,0 +1,59 @@ +# #662 scope: factory finding triage, mandate budget and flaky-test policy + +Owner: Sage. Authority: mos-1884; #659 S2–S4; DECISIONS Q261/Q263 (Q24 yes), with Q222 human-only settings. Starts after rows330/331: landed origin/refactor through0e1dd0a95. This scopes product work in Mosaic Stack; it does not reopen #657/#658 or alter their backlog status. + +## Outcome + +The next factory enforces bounded mandates, evidence-based finding triage and tracked flaky-test remediation in source. Console/CLI humans control the policy; agents can read their effective mandate and submit evidence, but cannot change guard settings, enlarge their own budget or make a failed gate pass. + +## Settings and defaults + +Proposed engineering namespace: `factoryPolicy` in the instance's one system config, with Console/CLI editing behind existing human authentication and writer conventions; the new policy editor is part of this task. Final wire names belong to implementation; there is no agent-writable policy copy in a task description or prompt. Effective values and the policy revision used for each decision are visible and recorded. Missing optional settings use documented defaults; explicit malformed/unknown policy refuses policy-dependent mutation and never silently widens authority. + +| Control | Initial default | Effect | +|---|---|---| +| Finding blocking rule | `regression-or-red-gate` | Candidate-caused defects and red required gates block; preexisting defects receive a linked task and do not block this landing. | +| Severity vocabulary | P0 urgent / P1 high / P2 normal / P3 low | Every finding carries severity separately from causality and blocking disposition. Severity does not turn an older defect into a regression or excuse a red gate. | +| Review-round budget | 2 per mandate | Initial review and one subsequent review. This is Sage's proposed default, consistent with the existing two-round lead rule, not a new Jason-selected number. | +| Allowed seat outcome reports | done / red-with-cause / hard-rule-wait / scope-change | The coordinator receives outcomes rather than routine per-step approval requests. Evidence remains available without status-message fan-out. | +| Timing-failure action | deterministic source fix plus tracked quarantine | Preserve the failing test/assertions and raw failure; fix the timing dependency with the existing clock/readiness mechanisms. | +| Quarantine mode | tracked, temporary, no gate exemption | Record the flake under the human-owned policy and link its source-fix task. It cannot remove a required gate, count a skip as PASS or waive a red required gate. | + +Only an authenticated human may change effective settings, grant an override or extend the round allowance. An agent/PM may request a scope change under its existing task authority, not grant itself a budget reset. An environment variable may still select the legitimate system config under the existing contract; it cannot inject policy values. Role names, prompts, tester sessions and task JSON are not policy authority. + +## S2: finding triage + +Record finding identity, severity, candidate/baseline references, reproduction or source evidence, causality (`candidate-caused`, `preexisting`, `unknown`), affected test and disposition. Derive the blocking decision from the current human policy and real gate state. A preexisting finding must retain its follow-up task/evidence; it does not trigger an open-ended design dependency. Unknown causality stays visibly unresolved until comparison establishes it; absence of evidence is not a passing test. Review receipts and the queue's existing actor/approval rules remain real, not fabricated or bypassed. + +## S3: bounded mandates + +Each new managed seat task has a nonempty goal, explicit acceptance criteria, scope/limits and an effective round budget tied to a mandate identity/revision. Validate this before dispatch. Count a round once when the actual review request is admitted; duplicate delivery/retry does not consume twice, and restart/relaunch does not reset the ledger. Exhaustion stops another review round and produces the bounded hard-rule-wait/scope-change outcome; it never marks work accepted or spawns replacement tasks to evade the budget. A human extension records who changed it and the old/new limits. Specify and test existing-task compatibility before enforcement; do not rewrite historical tasks or reinterpret existing prose as authenticated approval. + +## S4: flaky-test policy + +A timing failure reproducible under controlled load records exact test, commit/tree, raw failure, environment/load evidence and owner/source-fix task. An injected-clock/readiness regression demonstrates the source repair while retaining every original assertion. The quarantine record names the original test, reason, effective human-owned policy revision, explicit expiry/release condition and required reinstatement evidence. Recording a flake needs no per-step approval, and a quarantine record never independently authorizes exclusion from the required gate. No retries-until-green, larger deadline, assertion deletion, renamed-away failure or unreported skip substitutes for repair. Use owned deterministic fixtures instead of making acceptance depend on obtaining a slow host. + +## Acceptance criteria + +1. Human Console and CLI can read/update/reset the settings with defaults, validation, concurrency protection and an audit record; agent, PM and tester attempts through each actual exposed route refuse without a policy write. +2. A real managed task carries its goal/criteria/effective budget into dispatch and the review coordinator. Missing/invalid mandate data refuses before work starts; legacy task behavior is explicitly covered rather than silently migrated. +3. A controlled candidate regression blocks; the same independently demonstrated baseline defect produces a linked backlog task and permits the otherwise-green candidate. A real red required gate blocks regardless of finding label/severity. Unknown causality cannot be auto-classified as old or GREEN. +4. With the default budget, two actual rounds are accounted for and a third refuses. Duplicate requests, crash/restart and changed task descriptions cannot replenish it; only a recorded human extension permits another round. +5. Actual seat/coordinator routing accepts the four outcome types and preserves the goal/criteria across continuation. Exhaustion returns one actionable cause, not a new approval loop. +6. Reproduce a timing race using an owned deterministic test signal; demonstrate RED before the source repair and GREEN after it with all original assertions. A wall-clock delay increase cannot satisfy this control. +7. Quarantine creation/expiry/reinstatement and failure history are tested. Quarantined, skipped, unavailable, cancelled, timed-out and unrecognized outputs remain distinguishable from PASS, including gate-tool consumers. No automatic quarantine conceals a required failure. +8. Atomic policy/ledger writes, stale revision, duplicate delivery, partial write and restart tests retain history and refuse uncertainty. No secrets enter decision receipts. +9. Existing role/writer/queue/hook rules, normal task operations, system config compatibility and local test conventions remain covered. This task grants no new push/deploy/host/node authority. +10. One bounded independent review of the implementation, targeted integration checks and the applicable full gate on the accepted dedicated runner precede landing. Report actual phase outcomes and frozen commit/tree; no count-only or composite acceptance. + +## Delivery boundary + +Implement as one bounded feature with independently testable policy/authorization, finding disposition and mandate/quarantine consumers. Expected source owners: system config loader and human settings surface; tasks/seat dispatch and durable review accounting; review/gate disposition consumers. Exact file/schema changes and tests are settled in the implementation plan against the then-current base, not copied into agent work artifacts as a substitute for enforcement. Documentation includes defaults, human overrides, compatibility and recovery behavior. + +S1/#660 infrastructure and S6/#661 node access remain Ops-owned. S5/#663 record archival is separate. No redesign of provider/model routing, deployment, source role authority or #657/#658 recovery protocols is part of #662. No new agent/review factory is launched by this scoping note. + +## #660 dependency + +As inspected, #660 comment1335 reports source prepared, independent review/PR merge pending and no VM/CPU write applied. Sage has supplied the actual gate commands/runtime needs in comments1329/1334. Do not claim the tool targets a dedicated runner yet. When Ops supplies the ready verified endpoint/identity, approved profile, runtime checks and merged provisioning/runbook evidence, configure the gate target, refuse local fallback and complete one full frozen gate there; confirm actual target/receipts on #660. No local substitute run or host/Proxmox change is authorized by this scope. + +Stable operation: sage-4849-task662-scope-mos1884. diff --git a/docs/SESSIONS.md b/docs/SESSIONS.md index 15ef4ef0e..70d32e024 100644 --- a/docs/SESSIONS.md +++ b/docs/SESSIONS.md @@ -1871,3 +1871,11 @@ are never rewritten or removed; corrections are new entries. 2026-10-26 | Sage | Mos1864/1881 reviewed330/331 join, frozen362893/treea7f7 |321whole files plus dedicatedFEDR7, three whole packages, PIN/config/eight named mutants+restored controls verified; counter review2findings fixed23/23, originalrc1 preserved; evidence/map49c162c99, landing next;657/658 backlog unchanged 2026-10-26 | Sage | Mos1864/1881 landing complete | source52ba14c5f pushedrefactor;321files+FEDR7,3wholepackages,PIN/config/eightmutants+restores verified, product362893/treea7f7unchanged; counter23fixtures/review fixed; queue331 missingformalapprovals preserved,330unclosed;655/656notesOPEN,657/658BACKLOG; unrelatedrootindex preserved + +2026-10-26T17:51:50Z | Dewey | row331 post-landing review Mos1909/Mos1915, issue1829, candidate52ba14c5f/product362893d04 | APPROVE scoped repairs;646-648/652-655 FIXCONFIRMED;656 PARTIAL (narrow matched tmp/single completion confirmed); independent1968input and339raw-log hash checks; FILE ONLY agents/dewey/work/queue-331/postlanding-mos1909/REVIEW.md; no post/queue approval/source edits/test or gate run;657/658 backlog + +2026-10-26T17:56:44Z | Filbert | row330 post-landing review Mos1909/1915, #1828, candidate52ba14c5f/product362893d04 | scoped APPROVE saved agents/filbert/work/queue-330/postlanding-mos1909/REVIEW.md sha256 0f93bc883f1db2d2e136323040eaff2ad79aa184fa5ab140c94a0ae906f70ffe; independent1968 committed-input/43 evidence-artifact hash checks; new retiring-key metadata follow-up NEW-330-01; no runs/source edits/formal post/queue record;657/658 BACKLOG + +2026-10-26 | Sage | mos1884/#662 scope after330/331landing | ReadQ222/Q261/Q263 and659/660/662; posted bounded human-only factory settings/triage/defaulttwo-roundmandate/trackedno-exemptionflake scope with10acceptance criteria, task662comment1338 exactwholebody/author13GETverified. No implementation/review/gate launched.660c1335notready(review/merge, noVM); gatefacts1329/1334 retained; target integration/fullrunner confirmation follows readiness, no localfallback. Landedproduct/evidence unchanged;657/658backlog. + +2026-10-26 | Sage | Mos1909/1915/1917 real postlanding reviews | Boyd/Dewey/Filbert/Gladstone real authored candidate52ba verdictfiles independently byte/hash-verified, allAPPROVE scoped; Dewey656broaderPARTIAL retained. Formal330R1/331R4 requests failedpre-send/no comments or approvals; no borrowed/copied/mintedkeys. LegacyhelperGETname jason.woltje is NOT ownJarvis, ownslotabsent; rows tracking-open/#436, files cited via normalqueue. NewFilbertNEW-330-01 filedtask665 exactreadback, notlandingreopen/gate. Repair646-648/652-656 remainOPEN untilactualcomments;1917 conditionalbacklog routing retained. #662scope1338posted;660PR405REVISE/notready. Product1968inputs unchanged; no source/helper/test/gate edits/runs; peerjournal prefixes preserved.