feat(organization): triage is system-only, no organization gains it (#1873, lane triage-fence)

One list, SYSTEM_ONLY in vocabulary.mjs, names triage; every path by which an
organization could gain one refuses with the one code template-system-only:
hire prepare at org, project and root level and a change onto it (hire.raise,
hire.start.console, decision.raise naming role.hire or role.change); the hire
and definitions template lists omit it; definition import; a definition copied
from it; organization roles, root agents and project agents; a pack record
pinning it; a starter pack defining it, so pack preview and apply refuse an
installed pack that names it; instances.set add and change for the human and
the tester, and the instances add list omits it. The broker passes the code
through and the webui tables map it. The template itself still loads and
validates. Red-first tests in organization and bus system-only.test.mjs; the
channel-proof hash of webui bus.mjs and the broker import pin are updated.
This commit was merged in pull request #1980.
This commit is contained in:
jason.woltje committed 2026-11-16 11:38:17 -06:00
1 parent 5c7194e05b
commit 4a9c7a931c
20 files changed
+447 -15

No files matched your search

+7 -2
View File
@@ -11,7 +11,7 @@ import { initializeControl, processingStatus } from '../../processing-control/sr
import { NAME as HARNESS_NAME } from '../../plugins/src/kinds.mjs';
import { loadRequirements } from '../../tasks/src/requirements.mjs';
import { MERGE, LandingRefusal, readLanding } from './landing.mjs';
import { pluginName, ID_PATTERN, THREAD_DEFINITIONS, END_PROTECTED, forkProblem, forkUrl, credentialKind, validArgv, commandAllowed, HOST_ID, CREATIVE_DEFINITIONS, giteaName, parseGiteaUrl, covers, grantScopeOf, grantInScope } from '../../organization/src/vocabulary.mjs';
import { pluginName, ID_PATTERN, THREAD_DEFINITIONS, END_PROTECTED, forkProblem, forkUrl, credentialKind, validArgv, commandAllowed, HOST_ID, CREATIVE_DEFINITIONS, giteaName, parseGiteaUrl, covers, grantScopeOf, grantInScope, SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL, systemOnly } from '../../organization/src/vocabulary.mjs';
// Kept closed while S1 lands; its vocabulary is the integration authority.
export const ACTIONS = Object.freeze([
@@ -6791,6 +6791,9 @@ export class Broker {
#pinRole(noHire, hire) {
const pin = hire?.pin;
if (!object(pin)) fail('invalid-request');
// #1873 triage-fence: a recorded pin never hires a system-only template, by reference or as the
// inline copy of one (the inline composition below drops from).
if (systemOnly(pin.template) || systemOnly(hire.entry?.from?.template)) fail(SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL);
if (!Object.hasOwn(pin, 'inline')) return structuredClone(pin);
if (!object(hire.entry) || typeof pin.sha256 !== 'string') fail('invalid-request');
// The broker's sandbox import closure is fixed, so the digest and the composition are local
@@ -7202,7 +7205,7 @@ export class Broker {
// name; a file check (BusinessError) is invalid-request, anything else outcome-unknown.
#packFail(e) {
const code = e?.code ?? '';
if (['credential-leak', 'pack-plan-stale', 'revision-conflict', 'invalid-request', 'human-required', 'not-configured'].includes(code)
if (['credential-leak', 'pack-plan-stale', 'revision-conflict', 'invalid-request', 'human-required', 'not-configured', SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL].includes(code)
|| /^(starter-pack|definition|organization)-[a-z-]+$/.test(code)) fail(code);
if (e?.name === 'BusinessError') fail('invalid-request');
throw new BusError('outcome-unknown');
@@ -7234,6 +7237,8 @@ export class Broker {
if ((verb === "instance.hire" || verb === "instance.fire") && e.code === "definition-not-hireable") fail(e.code);
// Row 194 (B7, webby-0094 N3): the limits writer's keep check, against the file, as well.
if (e.code === "instance-kept") fail(e.code);
// #1873 triage-fence: a system-only template refuses by its one code on every write.
if (e.code === SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL) fail(e.code);
// #1873 T1: the definition writer's refusals pass by code; a composition refusal stays invalid-request.
if (Object.hasOwn(DEFINITION_BUS_KEYS, verb) && /^definition-[a-z-]+$/.test(e.code ?? "")) fail(e.code);
// Row 194 (brief item 8): a fire's or a delete's revoke failed, and nothing was written.
+7
View File
@@ -199,6 +199,13 @@ group(
"R10: only the caller's own saved templates",
"List your saved templates and use one of those names. A saved template is visible only to the owner who saved it."
);
// #1873 triage-fence: a template on the system-only list (organization vocabulary.mjs SYSTEM_ONLY)
// joins no organization by any path.
group(
"template-system-only",
"R8/R10: a system-only role template joins no organization",
"This role template serves the system outside every organization. Pick another template or definition; no hire, change, pack, import or instance write gives an organization one."
);
group(
"starter-pack-template-changed",
"R8: a pack's hash pin must match the current template",
+8 -1
View File
@@ -40,6 +40,7 @@ import { instanceSettings } from '../../organization/src/instance-settings.mjs';
import { organizationWriter, OrganizationError, setReplyLimits } from '../../organization/src/organization.mjs';
import { definitionVerbs, DEFINITION_BUS_VERBS } from '../../organization/src/definition-verbs.mjs';
import { ORG_PREFIX, orgDefinitionName, compositionOf, readTemplate, entryFromTemplate, lineDiff, PRIMITIVES } from '../../organization/src/definitions.mjs';
import { SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL, systemOnly } from '../../organization/src/vocabulary.mjs';
import { installedStarterPacks, readSavedTemplate } from '../../plugins/src/starter-pack.mjs';
import { TemplateError, templateList, templatePreview, templateSave } from '../../organization/src/template-save.mjs';
import { checkComposition } from '../../organization/src/composition.mjs';
@@ -313,7 +314,10 @@ function packOps({ writer, rolesDir, dataRoot, system, registryFor, assertClean,
async function loadPack(name, actor) {
if (typeof name !== 'string' || name.length > 128) bad();
if (name.startsWith(SAVED_PREFIX)) return readSavedTemplate({ configDir, account: actor, name: name.slice(SAVED_PREFIX.length), rolesDir });
const found = (await installed()).find(p => p.id === name);
const { packs, refused } = await installedStarterPacks({ dataRoot, rolesDir });
const found = packs.find(p => p.id === name);
// #1873 triage-fence: an installed pack refused for naming a system-only template says so.
if (!found && refused.some(r => r.name === name && r.code === SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL)) throw new BusError(SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL);
if (!found) throw new BusError('starter-pack-not-found');
return found;
}
@@ -332,6 +336,9 @@ function packOps({ writer, rolesDir, dataRoot, system, registryFor, assertClean,
// The entry a pack definition writes: a template reference becomes the template's own entry, pinned
// by its hash (a moved hash refuses), and a full entry is copied as it is. Neither carries rev.
function entryOf(value) {
// #1873 triage-fence: preview and apply both refuse a pack naming a system-only template, as a
// reference or as the from of a full entry.
if (systemOnly(value?.template) || systemOnly(value?.from?.template)) throw new BusError(SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL);
if (Object.hasOwn(value, 'template') && Object.hasOwn(value, 'sha256') && Object.keys(value).length === 2) {
const template = readTemplate(rolesDir, value.template);
if (template.sha256 !== value.sha256) throw new BusError('starter-pack-template-changed');
+2 -1
View File
@@ -42,7 +42,8 @@ const baselines = {
// deadline; userCall shares transport(). Nonces, argv and limits are unchanged.
// #1873 A3: STATUS maps credential-unbound, copy-refused, project-refused and project-agent-elsewhere
// to 409; no proof or transport change.
"packages/webui/src/bus.mjs": "d8f3e0eb5299fdb192e98a1238ca693aae7c36af9a21de72d5f5d39610589377",
// #1873 triage-fence: STATUS maps template-system-only to 400; no proof or transport change.
"packages/webui/src/bus.mjs": "cd08e1beb49e9e881bb1b308f2ab3343a480b47dd9b17ccbd16e120d341d7511",
};
const repoFile = path => new URL("../../../" + path, import.meta.url);
+2 -1
View File
@@ -43,7 +43,8 @@ test('Broker keeps the sandbox client import closure: only the listed imports, n
// Row 236 (#1742, #436b) reads giteaName and parseGiteaUrl for the Gitea grant path.
// FED R3 r5 (row 274, #414) reads covers, a user's grant check, from it.
// Row 219 reads THREAD_DEFINITIONS from the same vocabulary for creative thread admission.
"import { pluginName, ID_PATTERN, THREAD_DEFINITIONS, END_PROTECTED, forkProblem, forkUrl, credentialKind, validArgv, commandAllowed, HOST_ID, CREATIVE_DEFINITIONS, giteaName, parseGiteaUrl, covers, grantScopeOf, grantInScope } from '../../organization/src/vocabulary.mjs';",
// #1873 triage-fence reads SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL and systemOnly from the same vocabulary.
"import { pluginName, ID_PATTERN, THREAD_DEFINITIONS, END_PROTECTED, forkProblem, forkUrl, credentialKind, validArgv, commandAllowed, HOST_ID, CREATIVE_DEFINITIONS, giteaName, parseGiteaUrl, covers, grantScopeOf, grantInScope, SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL, systemOnly } from '../../organization/src/vocabulary.mjs';",
]);
assert.doesNotMatch(source, /\bimport\s*\(/);
assert.doesNotMatch(readFileSync(new URL('../src/proxy-page-vocabulary.mjs', import.meta.url), 'utf8'), /\bimport\b/);
+165
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,165 @@
// #1873 lane triage-fence: through the broker, no organization gains the system-only Triage
// template. Pack preview and apply, the Console hire start, the chief's hire.raise and
// decision.raise, and instances.set add as the human and the tester each refuse with
// template-system-only; the Console's hire template list omits triage. The coding pack still
// previews as before. Fixtures live in a temp directory.
import test from 'node:test';
import assert from 'node:assert/strict';
import { chmodSync, lstatSync, mkdirSync, mkdtempSync, readdirSync, readFileSync, rmSync, writeFileSync } from 'node:fs';
import { tmpdir } from 'node:os';
import { join } from 'node:path';
import { Broker } from '../src/broker.mjs';
import { Store } from '../src/store.mjs';
import { pluginHash } from '../../plugins/src/pinned.mjs';
import { installPlugin } from '../../plugins/src/install.mjs';
import { starterPack as codingPack } from '../../plugins/starter-pack/coding/index.mjs';
import { templateHash } from '../../organization/src/definitions.mjs';
import { hireDecisions } from '../../organization/src/hire-decisions.mjs';
import { organizationWriter } from '../../organization/src/organization.mjs';
import { loadBusiness } from '../../organization/src/organization-config.mjs';
import { businessDoc, rolesCopy, systemFor, writeJson } from '../../organization/tests/helpers.mjs';
const CODE = 'template-system-only';
const SUBJECT = { provider: 'test', iss: 'https://issuer.test', sub: 'owner' };
const ROUTE = { harness: 'pi', model: 'claude-opus-5-5' };
// The broker started as the runtime starts it, with the organization writer and installed packs.
async function runtime(t) {
const { startBroker } = await import('../src/runtime.mjs');
const root = mkdtempSync(join(tmpdir(), 'sobus-'));
const rolesDir = rolesCopy(root);
const doc = businessDoc(root, 'demo');
doc.plugins = { harness: ['pi'] };
doc.roles.chief.vars = { ...ROUTE };
writeJson(join(root, 'businesses/demo.json'), doc);
const data = join(root, 'data');
mkdirSync(data, { mode: 0o700 });
const roles = { chief: { definition: 'chief-of-staff', authority: { withinRole: ['decision.resolve.technical', 'decision.resolve.delivery', 'organization.change'], crossRole: [] } } };
const businesses = { demo: { id: 'demo', human: 'jason', arbiters: { technical: 'chief', delivery: 'chief' }, roles, vars: { 'bus.tester': true } } };
const bus = await startBroker({ dataRoot: data, businesses, organization: { dir: root, rolesDir, system: systemFor(root) } });
const thaw = (p) => { const st = lstatSync(p); if (st.isSymbolicLink()) return; if (st.isDirectory()) { chmodSync(p, 0o700); for (const e of readdirSync(p)) thaw(join(p, e)); } };
t.after(async () => { await bus.close(); thaw(root); rmSync(root, { recursive: true, force: true }); });
const b = bus.broker;
const owner = b.bindConsole({ business: 'demo', human: 'jason', subject: SUBJECT });
const human = b.bindHuman({ business: 'demo', human: 'jason', via: 'cli', outsideAgent: true });
const tester = b.bindTester({ business: 'demo' });
const call = async (verb, args = {}, cap = owner) => b.request(cap, { verb, args });
const file = () => readFileSync(join(root, 'businesses/demo.json'), 'utf8');
let n = 0;
const install = (pack) => {
const src = join(root, `src-${n++}`);
mkdirSync(join(src, 'starter-pack'), { recursive: true });
writeFileSync(join(src, 'starter-pack', 'index.mjs'), `export const interfaceVersion = 1;\nexport function starterPack() { return ${JSON.stringify(pack)}; }\n`);
const manifest = { name: pack.id, version: '1.0.0', kinds: ['starter-pack'], interfaceVersions: { 'starter-pack': 1 }, sha256: '0'.repeat(64),
source: { path: 'fixture', version: '1.0.0' }, signature: null, tools: [], actions: [], services: [], roleTemplates: [] };
writeFileSync(join(src, 'plugin.json'), JSON.stringify(manifest));
manifest.sha256 = pluginHash(src);
writeFileSync(join(src, 'plugin.json'), JSON.stringify(manifest));
installPlugin({ dataRoot: data, source: src, expectedHash: manifest.sha256 });
};
return { b, root, rolesDir, owner, human, tester, call, file, install };
}
// The A4 broker with the real hire service, so the chief's raise and the Console start reach it.
function hires(t) {
const root = mkdtempSync(join(tmpdir(), 'sohire-')), rolesDir = rolesCopy(root);
writeJson(join(root, 'businesses/demo.json'), { ...businessDoc(root, 'demo'), plugins: { harness: ['pi'] } });
const storeRoot = join(root, 'data'); mkdirSync(storeRoot, { mode: 0o700 });
const writer = organizationWriter({ dir: root, rolesDir }), store = new Store(storeRoot);
const service = hireDecisions({ writer, rolesDir, dataRoot: storeRoot, configDir: root, assertClean: () => {} });
const loaded = () => { const doc = loadBusiness('demo', { dir: root, rolesDir }); return { ...doc, roles: Object.fromEntries(Object.entries(doc.roles).map(([k, e]) => [k, { ...doc.definitions[e.definition], ...e }])) }; };
const b = new Broker({ store, businesses: { demo: loaded() }, hires: service });
t.after(() => { store.close(); rmSync(root, { recursive: true, force: true }); });
const owner = b.bindConsole({ business: 'demo', human: 'jason', subject: SUBJECT });
const chief = b.bindLaunch({ business: 'demo', role: 'chief', run: 'chief-run', harness: 'pi' });
b.request(chief, { verb: 'role.claim' });
const call = (cap, verb, args = {}) => b.request(cap, { verb, args });
const triage = { template: 'triage', sha256: templateHash(rolesDir, 'triage') };
const hire = (extra = {}) => ({ op: 'hire', level: 'org', name: 'sorter', role: triage, route: ROUTE, reason: 'Sort the inbox', ...extra });
const decisions = () => store.get('SELECT count(*) n FROM decisions').n;
return { owner, chief, call, hire, decisions };
}
const refuses = async (promise) => assert.rejects(Promise.resolve().then(() => promise), (e) => e?.code === CODE);
test('pack preview refuses an installed pack that defines triage', async (t) => {
const h = await runtime(t);
const pack = { ...codingPack(), id: 'sorting', label: 'Sorting' };
pack.definitions = { ...pack.definitions, triage: { template: 'triage', sha256: templateHash(h.rolesDir, 'triage') } };
h.install(pack);
const before = h.file();
await refuses(h.call('pack.preview.console', { pack: 'sorting' }));
assert.equal(h.file(), before);
});
test('pack apply refuses an installed pack that defines triage', async (t) => {
const h = await runtime(t);
const pack = { ...codingPack(), id: 'sorting', label: 'Sorting' };
pack.definitions = { ...pack.definitions, triage: { template: 'triage', sha256: templateHash(h.rolesDir, 'triage') } };
h.install(pack);
const before = h.file();
await refuses(h.call('pack.apply.console', { pack: 'sorting', digest: 'a'.repeat(64) }));
assert.equal(h.file(), before);
});
test('instances.set add refuses triage for the human', async (t) => {
const h = await runtime(t);
const { revision } = await h.call('instances', {}, h.human);
const before = h.file();
await refuses(h.call('instances.set', { revision, instance: 'sorter', op: 'add', definition: 'triage' }, h.human));
assert.equal(h.file(), before);
});
test('instances.set add refuses triage for the tester', async (t) => {
const h = await runtime(t);
const { revision } = await h.call('instances', {}, h.human);
const before = h.file();
await refuses(h.call('instances.set', { revision, instance: 'sorter', op: 'add', definition: 'triage' }, h.tester));
assert.equal(h.file(), before);
});
test('the instances read offers no triage add', async (t) => {
const h = await runtime(t);
const view = await h.call('instances', {}, h.human);
assert.equal(Object.hasOwn(view.definitions, 'triage'), false);
});
test('the Console hire start refuses a triage template', async (t) => {
const f = hires(t);
await refuses(f.call(f.owner, 'hire.start.console', f.hire()));
assert.equal(f.decisions(), 0);
});
test('the chief hire.raise refuses a triage template at org, project and root level', async (t) => {
const f = hires(t);
await refuses(f.call(f.chief, 'hire.raise', f.hire()));
await refuses(f.call(f.chief, 'hire.raise', f.hire({ level: 'project', project: 'stack' })));
await refuses(f.call(f.chief, 'hire.raise', f.hire({ level: 'root' })));
assert.equal(f.decisions(), 0);
});
test('the chief decision.raise naming role.hire or role.change refuses a triage template', async (t) => {
const f = hires(t);
await refuses(f.call(f.chief, 'decision.raise', { action: 'role.hire', hire: f.hire() }));
await refuses(f.call(f.chief, 'decision.raise', { action: 'role.change', hire: f.hire({ op: 'change', name: 'coder' }) }));
assert.equal(f.decisions(), 0);
});
test('the Console hire template list omits triage and keeps the rest', async (t) => {
const f = hires(t);
const names = (await f.call(f.owner, 'hire.templates.console')).templates.map((x) => x.name);
assert.ok(!names.includes('triage'));
assert.ok(names.includes('coder') && names.includes('reviewer'));
});
// The guard: a shipped pack previews and applies as before, and an installed pack with no triage loads.
test('the shipped coding pack and an installed pack without triage preview as before', async (t) => {
const h = await runtime(t);
const preview = await h.call('pack.preview.console', { pack: 'coding' });
assert.match(preview.digest, /^[a-f0-9]{64}$/);
h.install({ ...codingPack(), id: 'plain', label: 'Plain' });
const plain = await h.call('pack.preview.console', { pack: 'plain' });
assert.match(plain.digest, /^[a-f0-9]{64}$/);
const out = await h.call('pack.apply.console', { pack: 'coding', digest: preview.digest });
assert.deepEqual(out.hires.map((x) => [x.name, x.state]), [['pm-1', 'hired'], ['coder-1', 'hired'], ['reviewer-1', 'hired']]);
});
@@ -9,6 +9,7 @@ import { join } from "node:path";
import { refuse } from "./errors.mjs";
import { checkDefinitions } from "./definitions.mjs";
import { loadRole } from "./role.mjs";
import { SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL, systemOnly } from "./vocabulary.mjs";
import { checkVars, mergeVars, REGISTRY } from "./vars.mjs";
import { deepFreeze, isPlainObject, readJsonFile, rejectUnknownKeys, requireDistinctList, requireId, requireObject } from "./util.mjs";
@@ -27,6 +28,8 @@ export function rootAgentsPath(configDir) {
function definitionOf(name, at, rolesDir, cache, definitions = {}) {
if (typeof name === "string" && name.startsWith("org:") && Object.hasOwn(definitions,name)) return definitions[name];
requireId(name, `${at}.definition`);
// #1873 triage-fence: no root or project agent, and so no copy of one, names a system-only template.
if (systemOnly(name)) refuse(`${SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL}: ${at}.definition names ${name}, a template no organization may hold`);
if (!cache.has(name)) {
// A role refusal names host paths; this message travels to the Console, so it names none.
try { cache.set(name, loadRole(rolesDir, name)); }
@@ -15,6 +15,7 @@ import { OrganizationError } from "./organization.mjs";
import {
diffDefinition, entryFromTemplate, instancesNaming, readTemplate, templateHashes, checkDefinitionName, ORG_PREFIX,
} from "./definitions.mjs";
import { SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL, systemOnly } from "./vocabulary.mjs";
// The verb names the policy table maps, following R1's hire.resolve.console.
export const DEFINITION_VERBS = Object.freeze({
@@ -64,6 +65,8 @@ export function definitionVerbs({ writer, rolesDir, assertClean }) {
// Copies a template into definitions with from set to its name and current hash.
function importTemplate(id, { revision, template, as = template }, caller) {
authorize(caller, "import");
// #1873 triage-fence: no organization imports a system-only template.
if (systemOnly(template)) fail(SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL);
checkDefinitionName(as, "definition name");
const source = readTemplate(rolesDir, template);
const result = writer.setDefinition(id, as, (current) => {
@@ -125,5 +128,5 @@ export function definitionVerbs({ writer, rolesDir, assertClean }) {
return { organization: id, revision, ...diffDefinition(document, name, rolesDir) };
}
return { import: importTemplate, edit, invent, remove, list, show, diff, templates: () => templateHashes(rolesDir) };
return { import: importTemplate, edit, invent, remove, list, show, diff, templates: () => templateHashes(rolesDir).filter(({ template }) => !systemOnly(template)) };
}
+3 -1
View File
@@ -23,7 +23,7 @@ import { createHash } from "node:crypto";
import { refuse } from "./errors.mjs";
import { buildRegistry, checkComposition } from "./composition.mjs";
import { validateRoleDocument } from "./role.mjs";
import { ID_PATTERN } from "./vocabulary.mjs";
import { ID_PATTERN, SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL, systemOnly } from "./vocabulary.mjs";
import { canonicalJson, deepFreeze } from "./util.mjs";
export const ORG_PREFIX = "org:";
@@ -88,6 +88,8 @@ export function checkDefinition(name, entry, { assertClean = NO_STORE, where = "
keysOnly(entry.from, FROM_KEYS, `${at}.from`);
if (typeof entry.from.template !== "string" || !ID_PATTERN.test(entry.from.template)) refuse(`${at}.from.template must be a template name matching ${ID_PATTERN}`);
if (typeof entry.from.sha256 !== "string" || !HEX64.test(entry.from.sha256)) refuse(`${at}.from.sha256 must be 64 lowercase hex characters`);
// #1873 triage-fence: no organization definition copies a system-only template.
if (systemOnly(entry.from.template)) refuse(`${SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL}: ${at}.from.template names ${entry.from.template}, a template no organization may hold`);
}
if (!plain(entry.role)) refuse(`${at}.role must be a JSON object`);
keysOnly(entry.role, ROLE_KEYS, `${at}.role`);
+5 -2
View File
@@ -8,7 +8,7 @@ import { compositionOf, entryFromTemplate, readTemplate, templateHashes } from '
import { readRootAgentsFile, changeRootAgent } from './agent-levels-write.mjs';
import { validateBusinessDocument } from './organization-config.mjs';
import { canonicalJson, isPlainObject, readJsonFile } from './util.mjs';
import { ID_PATTERN, NETWORKS } from './vocabulary.mjs';
import { ID_PATTERN, NETWORKS, SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL, systemOnly } from './vocabulary.mjs';
import { OrganizationError } from './organization.mjs';
import { resolveInstance } from './resolve.mjs';
import { checkRoutes } from './launch-settings.mjs';
@@ -204,6 +204,8 @@ export function hireDecisions({ writer, rolesDir, configDir, dataRoot, assertCle
if ('template' in input.role) { id(input.role.template); if (!/^[a-f0-9]{64}$/.test(input.role.sha256??'') || Object.keys(input.role).length!==2) fail('invalid-request'); }
if ('definition' in input.role) { id(input.role.definition); if (!Number.isSafeInteger(input.role.rev) || Object.keys(input.role).length!==2) fail('invalid-request'); }
if ('inline' in input.role && Object.keys(input.role).length!==1) fail('invalid-request');
// #1873 triage-fence: no hire or change at any level copies a system-only template.
if (systemOnly(input.role.template)) fail(SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL);
} else if (['role','route','credentials','personality'].some(k=>k in input)) fail('invalid-request');
const {document:doc,revision} = writer.read(business);
const loaded = validateBusinessDocument(doc,`${business}.json`,{rolesDir,dataRoot});
@@ -226,6 +228,7 @@ export function hireDecisions({ writer, rolesDir, configDir, dataRoot, assertCle
if ('template' in ref) { const template=readTemplate(rolesDir,ref.template); if(template.sha256!==ref.sha256) fail('decision-stale'); entry=entryFromTemplate(template); }
else if ('definition' in ref) { entry=doc.definitions?.[ref.definition]; if(!entry || entry.rev!==ref.rev) fail('definition-rev-conflict'); entry=structuredClone(entry); }
else entry={rev:1,role:{},instructions:''};
if (systemOnly(entry.from?.template)) fail(SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL);
let c='inline' in ref ? structuredClone(ref.inline) : compositionOf(entry);
if ('credentials' in input) c.credentials=structuredClone(input.credentials);
if ('personality' in input) c.personality=structuredClone(input.personality);
@@ -387,5 +390,5 @@ export function hireDecisions({ writer, rolesDir, configDir, dataRoot, assertCle
const result=writer.reverseHireDecision(business,p,{...caller,beforeWrite:guard,beforePublish:publicationGuard});
return {...result,...(r.op==='change' && stopped?.running?{relaunch:publicOf(p)}:{})};
}
return {prepare,reverse,templates:()=>({templates:templateHashes(rolesDir).map(({template,sha256})=>({name:template,sha256}))}),preview:async(business,decision,caller)=>{const p=await adjusted(business,decision,caller.adjust);if(Date.parse(p.expiresAt)<=(caller.now??Date.now)())fail('decision-expired');authorizeHire(publicOf(p),caller);return publicOf(p);},rootRefusal,rootActive:name=>rootRefusal(name)===null,check:async(...args)=>{await check(...args);},apply,read: decision => publicOf(read(decision))};
return {prepare,reverse,templates:()=>({templates:templateHashes(rolesDir).filter(({template})=>!systemOnly(template)).map(({template,sha256})=>({name:template,sha256}))}),preview:async(business,decision,caller)=>{const p=await adjusted(business,decision,caller.adjust);if(Date.parse(p.expiresAt)<=(caller.now??Date.now)())fail('decision-expired');authorizeHire(publicOf(p),caller);return publicOf(p);},rootRefusal,rootActive:name=>rootRefusal(name)===null,check:async(...args)=>{await check(...args);},apply,read: decision => publicOf(read(decision))};
}
@@ -14,7 +14,7 @@ import { resolveInstance } from "./resolve.mjs";
import { loadRole } from "./role.mjs";
import { refuse } from "./errors.mjs";
import { isPlainObject, canonicalJson } from "./util.mjs";
import { CREATIVE_DEFINITIONS, CREATIVE_SERVICE, END_PROTECTED, HOST_SERVICE, ID_PATTERN, checkGrantScope, grantScopeOf } from "./vocabulary.mjs";
import { CREATIVE_DEFINITIONS, CREATIVE_SERVICE, END_PROTECTED, HOST_SERVICE, ID_PATTERN, SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL, checkGrantScope, grantScopeOf, systemOnly } from "./vocabulary.mjs";
const SET_KEYS = ["revision", "instance", "op", "definition", "vars", "launch", "tracker"];
const VETO_KEYS = ["revision", "op", "name"];
@@ -93,6 +93,8 @@ const sameCredentialServices = (before, after) => credentialServices(before).joi
// Row 194 (brief item 7): the human's add passes credentials true and lifts it. The tester's add,
// change and hire keep it.
function definitionFor(rolesDir, name, { credentials = false } = {}) {
// #1873 triage-fence: no add or change of definition gives an instance a system-only template.
if (systemOnly(name)) throw new OrganizationError(SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL);
if (closed(name)) throw new OrganizationError("organization-definition-refused");
const definition = loadRole(rolesDir, name);
if (definition.roleVersion !== 2) throw new OrganizationError("invalid-request", `role definition ${name} is version 1`);
@@ -153,6 +155,8 @@ export function instanceSettings({ dir, rolesDir, system, levels = () => null, r
const out = {};
for (const file of readdirSync(rolesDir).filter(f => f.endsWith(".json")).sort()) {
const name = file.slice(0, -5);
// #1873 triage-fence: the add list never offers a system-only template.
if (systemOnly(name)) continue;
let definition;
try {
definition = loadRole(rolesDir, name);
@@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ import { checkVars } from "./vars.mjs";
import { parseCredentialRef } from "./credentials.mjs";
import { loadRole } from "./role.mjs";
import { checkDefinition, checkDefinitions, checkDefinitionName, orgDefinitionName, ORG_PREFIX } from "./definitions.mjs";
import { END_PROTECTED, parseRepoRemote } from "./vocabulary.mjs";
import { END_PROTECTED, parseRepoRemote, SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL, systemOnly } from "./vocabulary.mjs";
import { checkPlugins, checkUsageSettings, NAME as KIND_NAME } from "../../plugins/src/kinds.mjs";
import { checkMapping } from "../../library/src/mapping.mjs";
import { forkProblem, giteaName, parseGiteaUrl, HOST_SERVICE, CREATIVE_DEFINITIONS } from "./vocabulary.mjs";
@@ -113,6 +113,8 @@ function checkPin(pin, where) {
if (!shape) refuse(`${where} must be {template, sha256}, {definition, rev} or {inline}`);
if (shape[0] === "template") {
requireId(pin.template, `${where}.template`);
// #1873 triage-fence: no pack proposal pins a system-only template.
if (systemOnly(pin.template)) refuse(`${SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL}: ${where}.template names ${pin.template}, a template no organization may hold`);
if (typeof pin.sha256 !== "string" || !HEX64.test(pin.sha256)) refuse(`${where}.sha256 must be 64 lowercase hex characters`);
} else if (shape[0] === "definition") {
checkDefinitionName(pin.definition, `${where}.definition`);
@@ -285,8 +287,11 @@ function checkRoles(roles, file, rolesDir, business, hasLibrary, orgDefinitions)
rejectUnknownKeys(entry, ["definition", "holder", "vars", "tracker", "credentials", "identity", "publish", "hosts", "hireDecision"], at);
// #1873 T1: "org:<name>" names one of this file's definitions; anything else is a template.
const orgName = orgDefinitionName(entry.definition);
if (orgName === null) requireId(entry.definition, `${at}.definition`);
else if (!Object.hasOwn(orgDefinitions, ORG_PREFIX + checkDefinitionName(orgName, `${at}.definition after org:`))) {
if (orgName === null) {
requireId(entry.definition, `${at}.definition`);
// #1873 triage-fence: no instance names a system-only template.
if (systemOnly(entry.definition)) refuse(`${SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL}: ${at}.definition names ${entry.definition}, a template no organization may hold`);
} else if (!Object.hasOwn(orgDefinitions, ORG_PREFIX + checkDefinitionName(orgName, `${at}.definition after org:`))) {
refuse(`definition-missing: ${at}.definition names ${ORG_PREFIX}${orgName}, which definitions doesn't declare`);
}
const definition = Object.hasOwn(definitions, entry.definition) ? definitions[entry.definition]
+9
View File
@@ -209,6 +209,15 @@ export const THREAD_DEFINITIONS = Object.freeze([THREAD_DEFINITION, ...CREATIVE_
// organization write may give an instance one of them, except the human's instances.set for a
// creative definition (row 213).
export const END_PROTECTED = THREAD_DEFINITIONS;
// #1873 lane triage-fence: the shipped templates no organization may hold. Jason approved the
// Triage template on 2026-11-16; its use outside an organization waits for his ruling. Every path
// by which an organization could gain a role reads this list and refuses with SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL:
// a hire or change at org, project or root level, a pack preview or apply, instances.set, the
// organization file's own validation, and every template list a page offers. The template itself
// still loads and validates as a template.
export const SYSTEM_ONLY = Object.freeze(["triage"]);
export const SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL = "template-system-only";
export const systemOnly = name => typeof name === "string" && SYSTEM_ONLY.includes(name);
// Row 199 (#1697, design D9c): the Gitea URL parse. It lives here because the broker reads it and
// this file imports nothing. Gitea's name rule for users and repositories: letters, digits, "_", "."
@@ -0,0 +1,209 @@
// #1873 lane triage-fence: the Triage template is system-only. Jason approved the template on
// 2026-11-16; no organization may hold it until he rules on its use outside one. Every place an
// organization could gain it refuses with one code, template-system-only, and the template itself
// still loads and validates as a template. Fixtures live in a temp directory.
import test from "node:test";
import assert from "node:assert/strict";
import { mkdirSync, mkdtempSync, rmSync } from "node:fs";
import { join } from "node:path";
import { tmpdir } from "node:os";
// A namespace import, so a run against the commit before the fence fails test by test, not at load.
import * as vocabulary from "../src/vocabulary.mjs";
import { checkDefinition, entryFromTemplate, readTemplate, templateHash, templateHashes } from "../src/definitions.mjs";
import { loadRole } from "../src/role.mjs";
import { validateBusinessDocument } from "../src/organization-config.mjs";
import { checkProjectAgents, checkRootAgents } from "../src/agent-levels.mjs";
import { hireDecisions } from "../src/hire-decisions.mjs";
import { instanceSettings } from "../src/instance-settings.mjs";
import { definitionVerbs } from "../src/definition-verbs.mjs";
import { organizationWriter } from "../src/organization.mjs";
import { ROLE_RIGHTS } from "../src/org-rights.mjs";
import { checkPack, installedStarterPacks } from "../../plugins/src/starter-pack.mjs";
import { businessDoc, rolesCopy, systemFor, tmp, writeJson } from "./helpers.mjs";
const CODE = "template-system-only";
const coded = (e) => e?.code === CODE;
const prefixed = (e) => e?.name === "BusinessError" && e.message.startsWith(`${CODE}: `);
const OWNER = { actor: "jason", agent: false, rights: ["org.hire"], owner: true, instanceOwner: true, subject: { provider: "test", iss: "https://test", sub: "owner" } };
const DEF_OWNER = { actor: "jason", rights: [...ROLE_RIGHTS.owner], agent: false };
const ROUTE = { harness: "pi", model: "claude-opus-5-5" };
function rootDir(t) {
const root = tmp();
t.after(() => rmSync(root, { recursive: true, force: true }));
return root;
}
function hireSetup(t) {
const root = mkdtempSync(join(tmpdir(), "so-"));
t.after(() => rmSync(root, { recursive: true, force: true }));
const rolesDir = rolesCopy(root);
writeJson(join(root, "businesses/demo.json"), { ...businessDoc(root, "demo"), plugins: { harness: ["pi"] } });
const writer = organizationWriter({ dir: root, rolesDir });
const dataRoot = join(root, "data");
mkdirSync(dataRoot, { mode: 0o700 });
const service = hireDecisions({ writer, rolesDir, configDir: root, dataRoot, assertClean: () => {} });
const triage = { template: "triage", sha256: templateHash(rolesDir, "triage") };
let n = 0;
const prepare = (extra) => service.prepare("demo", { op: "hire", level: "org", name: "sorter", role: triage, route: ROUTE, reason: "Sort the inbox", ...extra },
{ id: `1111111${n++}-1111-4111-8111-111111111111`, expiresAt: "2099-01-01T00:00:00.000Z" });
return { root, rolesDir, writer, service, prepare, triage };
}
function settingsSetup(t) {
const root = rootDir(t);
const rolesDir = rolesCopy(root);
const dir = join(root, "config");
const doc = businessDoc(root, "acme");
doc.plugins = { harness: ["pi", "claude-code"] };
writeJson(join(dir, "businesses", "acme.json"), doc);
return { rolesDir, settings: instanceSettings({ dir, rolesDir, system: systemFor(root) }) };
}
function verbsSetup(t) {
const root = rootDir(t);
const dir = join(root, "config");
const rolesDir = rolesCopy(root);
writeJson(join(dir, "businesses/acme.json"), businessDoc(root));
const writer = organizationWriter({ dir, rolesDir });
return { root, dir, rolesDir, writer, verbs: definitionVerbs({ writer, rolesDir, assertClean: () => {} }) };
}
test("the list is one name, triage, and its refusal code is template-system-only", () => {
assert.deepEqual([...(vocabulary.SYSTEM_ONLY ?? [])], ["triage"]);
assert.equal(vocabulary.SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL, CODE);
assert.equal(vocabulary.systemOnly?.("triage"), true);
assert.equal(vocabulary.systemOnly?.("coder"), false);
assert.equal(vocabulary.systemOnly?.(undefined), false);
});
test("triage still loads and validates as a template", (t) => {
const rolesDir = rolesCopy(rootDir(t));
const role = loadRole(rolesDir, "triage");
assert.equal(role.roleVersion, 2);
const source = readTemplate(rolesDir, "triage");
assert.match(source.sha256, /^[a-f0-9]{64}$/);
assert.ok(templateHashes(rolesDir).some(({ template }) => template === "triage"));
});
test("hire refuses a triage template at org level", async (t) => {
const f = hireSetup(t);
await assert.rejects(f.prepare(), coded);
});
test("hire refuses a triage template at project level", async (t) => {
const f = hireSetup(t);
await assert.rejects(f.prepare({ level: "project", project: "stack" }), coded);
});
test("hire refuses a triage template at root level", async (t) => {
const f = hireSetup(t);
await assert.rejects(f.prepare({ level: "root" }), coded);
});
test("a change refuses to move an org instance onto triage", async (t) => {
const f = hireSetup(t);
await assert.rejects(f.prepare({ op: "change", name: "coder" }), coded);
});
test("the hire template list a page offers omits triage and keeps every other template", (t) => {
const f = hireSetup(t);
const offered = f.service.templates().templates.map(({ name }) => name);
assert.ok(!offered.includes("triage"));
assert.deepEqual(offered, templateHashes(f.rolesDir).map(({ template }) => template).filter((n) => n !== "triage"));
});
test("instances add refuses triage for the human and the tester", (t) => {
const f = settingsSetup(t);
for (const actor of ["jason", "tester"]) {
const revision = f.settings.read("acme").revision;
assert.throws(() => f.settings.set("acme", { revision, instance: "sorter", op: "add", definition: "triage" }, actor), coded, actor);
}
});
test("instances change of definition refuses triage", (t) => {
const f = settingsSetup(t);
const revision = f.settings.read("acme").revision;
assert.throws(() => f.settings.set("acme", { revision, instance: "coder", op: "change", definition: "triage" }, "jason"), coded);
});
test("the instances add list omits triage", (t) => {
const f = settingsSetup(t);
assert.equal(Object.hasOwn(f.settings.read("acme").definitions, "triage"), false);
});
test("an organization file whose roles name triage is refused", (t) => {
const root = rootDir(t);
const rolesDir = rolesCopy(root);
const doc = businessDoc(root);
doc.roles.sorter = { definition: "triage" };
assert.throws(() => validateBusinessDocument(doc, join(root, "acme.json"), { rolesDir }), prefixed);
});
test("an organization definition copied from triage is refused", (t) => {
const rolesDir = rolesCopy(rootDir(t));
const entry = entryFromTemplate(readTemplate(rolesDir, "triage"));
assert.throws(() => checkDefinition("sorter", entry), prefixed);
});
test("a root agent naming triage is refused", (t) => {
const rolesDir = rolesCopy(rootDir(t));
assert.throws(() => checkRootAgents({ agentsVersion: 1, agents: { sorter: { definition: "triage" } } }, { rolesDir }), prefixed);
});
test("a project agent naming triage is refused", (t) => {
const rolesDir = rolesCopy(rootDir(t));
assert.throws(() => checkProjectAgents({ sorter: { definition: "triage" } }, { rolesDir, where: "projects.stack.agents" }), prefixed);
});
test("a pack record proposing a triage hire is refused", (t) => {
const root = rootDir(t);
const rolesDir = rolesCopy(root);
const doc = businessDoc(root);
doc.packs = [{ id: "coding", version: "1.0.0", sha256: "a".repeat(64), origin: "shipped", scope: "org", project: null,
at: "2026-11-12T20:00:00.000Z", by: "jason", added: [], proposedHires: [{ name: "sorter-1", pin: { template: "triage", sha256: "a".repeat(64) } }] }];
assert.throws(() => validateBusinessDocument(doc, join(root, "acme.json"), { rolesDir }), prefixed);
});
test("import refuses triage and the definitions template list omits it", (t) => {
const f = verbsSetup(t);
const revision = f.writer.read("acme").revision;
assert.throws(() => f.verbs.import("acme", { revision, template: "triage" }, DEF_OWNER), coded);
const listed = f.verbs.templates().map(({ template }) => template);
assert.deepEqual(listed, templateHashes(f.rolesDir).map(({ template }) => template).filter((n) => n !== "triage"));
});
test("a starter pack naming triage is refused when checked", async (t) => {
const rolesDir = rolesCopy(rootDir(t));
const { starterPack } = await import("../../plugins/starter-pack/coding/index.mjs");
const doc = starterPack();
doc.definitions = { ...doc.definitions, triage: { template: "triage", sha256: templateHash(rolesDir, "triage") } };
assert.throws(() => checkPack(doc, { origin: "installed", rolesDir, name: doc.id }), coded);
});
// The guard: the fence changes nothing for any other template or any shipped pack.
test("every other shipped template imports as before and every shipped pack loads unchanged", async (t) => {
const f = verbsSetup(t);
const all = templateHashes(f.rolesDir).map(({ template }) => template);
const others = all.filter((n) => n !== "triage");
assert.equal(others.length, all.length - 1);
// Each template's import outcome, measured on 5c7194e05 before the fence: chief-of-staff carries
// role.hire, which a hired agent may not hold, so its import refused before and still does.
const refusedBefore = ["chief-of-staff"];
const outcome = {};
for (const template of others) {
try {
f.verbs.import("acme", { revision: f.writer.read("acme").revision, template }, DEF_OWNER);
outcome[template] = "imported";
} catch (e) {
assert.ok(!String(e.message).includes(CODE) && e.code !== CODE, template);
outcome[template] = "refused";
}
}
assert.deepEqual(Object.keys(outcome).filter((n) => outcome[n] === "refused"), refusedBefore.filter((n) => others.includes(n)));
const defs = f.writer.read("acme").document.definitions;
assert.deepEqual(Object.keys(defs).sort(), others.filter((n) => outcome[n] === "imported").sort());
const { packs, refused } = await installedStarterPacks({ dataRoot: null });
assert.deepEqual(refused, []);
assert.deepEqual(packs.map((p) => p.id).sort(), ["business-management", "coding", "creative-writing", "marketing", "montage"]);
});
+4 -1
View File
@@ -20,7 +20,7 @@ import { fileURLToPath } from "node:url";
import { types } from "node:util";
import { ENTRY_KEYS, checkDefinition, readTemplate } from "../../organization/src/definitions.mjs";
import { parseJsonFileText } from "../../organization/src/util.mjs";
import { ID_PATTERN, NETWORKS } from "../../organization/src/vocabulary.mjs";
import { ID_PATTERN, NETWORKS, SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL, systemOnly } from "../../organization/src/vocabulary.mjs";
import { NAME, PluginError } from "./kinds.mjs";
import { hasModule, loadInstalled } from "./loader.mjs";
@@ -163,6 +163,9 @@ function checkDefinitions(definitions, { origin, rolesDir, id }) {
const at = `starter pack definitions.${name}`;
const entry = definitions[name];
if (!plain(entry)) fail("starter-pack-invalid", `${at} must be a JSON object`, id);
// #1873 triage-fence: a pack never carries a system-only template, as a reference or as a from.
const named = entry.template ?? (plain(entry.from) ? entry.from.template : undefined);
if (systemOnly(named)) fail(SYSTEM_ONLY_REFUSAL, `${at} names template ${named}, which no organization may hold`, id);
const keys = Object.keys(entry);
if (keys.length === REF_KEYS.length && REF_KEYS.every((k) => keys.includes(k))) {
// A template reference: the whole template, pinned by its hash.
+2
View File
@@ -165,6 +165,8 @@ const STATUS = {
// Row 155 (#1649): the assistant's settings, seat names and stop. A name in use or no run to stop
// is the user's to resolve by reading again.
'organization-not-assistant': 400, 'organization-definition-refused': 400, 'unknown-model': 400,
// #1873 triage-fence: a template no organization may hold.
'template-system-only': 400,
'name-taken': 409, 'name-is-instance': 400, 'name-is-role': 400, 'not-assistant': 400, 'not-held': 409,
// Row 165 (#1662): role instances. An id already taken is the user's to resolve by reading again.
'organization-instance-exists': 409, 'organization-unknown-instance': 400,
+1
View File
@@ -67,6 +67,7 @@ const HIRE_START_REFUSALS = {
'unknown-model': [409, 'This model is not one of the organization\'s models. Pick a model listed under Settings > Model proxy.' + NONE],
'harness-off': [409, 'This harness is not switched on for the organization. Pick a harness listed under Settings > Routing, or ask the owner to switch it on.' + NONE],
'harness-refused': [409, 'The harness refused this route. Clear Thinking, or pick another model or harness under Settings > Routing.' + NONE],
'template-system-only': [409, 'This role template is for the system, not for an organization. Pick another template.' + NONE],
'definition-not-hireable': [409, 'This organization does not hire agents from this role template. Pick another template.' + NONE],
'definition-shared': [409, 'Another agent uses the same role definition, so this change cannot replace it.' + NONE],
'definition-rev-conflict': [409, 'The role definition changed since it was read. Reload the page and propose again.' + EITHER],
+1 -1
View File
@@ -41,7 +41,7 @@ const REVISION = /^[a-f0-9]{64}$/;
// A board or workflow body stays small; the organization config caps both (WORKFLOWS_MAX, board columns).
const LIMIT = 65536;
const codes = {
'invalid-request': 400, 'credential-leak': 400, 'starter-pack-invalid': 400, 'definition-invalid': 400,
'invalid-request': 400, 'credential-leak': 400, 'starter-pack-invalid': 400, 'definition-invalid': 400, 'template-system-only': 400,
'starter-pack-not-found': 404, 'project-not-found': 404, 'pack-not-applied': 404,
'pack-plan-stale': 409, 'revision-conflict': 409, 'organization-busy': 409,
'human-required': 403, 'read-only': 403, 'right-required': 403,
+1
View File
@@ -20,6 +20,7 @@
'starter-pack-template-changed': 'A role template this pack pins has changed. The pack needs a new version.',
'starter-pack-invalid': 'This pack does not pass its checks against the organization.',
'definition-invalid': 'A role in this pack does not pass the organization checks.',
'template-system-only': 'This pack names a role template that is for the system, not for an organization. It cannot be applied.',
'project-not-found': 'That project is not in the organization file.',
'credential-leak': 'The pack carries a value the credential store holds. It cannot be applied.',
'read-only': 'This Console was started without send. Packs can be previewed, not applied.',
+1
View File
@@ -425,6 +425,7 @@ const INSTANCE_REASONS = {
'organization-unknown-instance': 'the business has no such instance; add it instead',
'organization-definition-refused': 'this form neither adds nor changes an assistant, and moves no instance to the assistant definition; an assistant changes only in the Assistant section',
'organization-launch-not-configured': 'the business file has no launch block, so launch membership can\'t change',
'template-system-only': 'that role template is for the system, not for an organization; pick another definition',
'organization-no-change': 'the business file already says that',
'organization-project-mismatch': 'a project file\'s id differs from its key in the business file; mosaic org config validate shows it',
'organization-unresolvable-instance': 'an instance wouldn\'t resolve against a project file; mosaic org config validate shows why',