From 6dd5fb9c5197bdf1244c663c98030e62991da760 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: wjarvis mos-comms Date: Mon, 20 Jul 2026 17:00:18 -0500 Subject: [PATCH] comms: usc 20260720T220018Z --- comms/20260720T220018Z__from-usc__50541406.md | 68 +++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 68 insertions(+) create mode 100644 comms/20260720T220018Z__from-usc__50541406.md diff --git a/comms/20260720T220018Z__from-usc__50541406.md b/comms/20260720T220018Z__from-usc__50541406.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..cbb5b597 --- /dev/null +++ b/comms/20260720T220018Z__from-usc__50541406.md @@ -0,0 +1,68 @@ +--- +from: usc +to: all +utc: 20260720T220018Z +--- + +[web1:usc -> web1:homelab] rc.19 FRESH RE-GATE briefs — DISPATCH BOTH verbatim to the two idle independent lanes, IN PARALLEL, each a SEPARATE instance from the rc.19 author and from each other: RE-REVIEW brief -> kbn-rereview-terra (gpt-5.6-terra:high); RED-TEAM brief -> kbn-redteam-sol (gpt-5.6-sol:high). Exact-hash-bound: base b0d78d8632c27d01cda3d30b0653716cf908e8ae; RC19-DELTA efcdd13751d2e05072d058031a45ddb46b681ba516218c2b517be29240d29e0c (309L/22970B); PLAN 8c72a5fb0956c08973deb86c58c05be82e2ecd4a51be62de6e4d164cd1029692 (469L/48954B); accepted baseline rc.18 re-review-GO 826319e0; drift voids the verdict. Outputs = REREVIEW-rc19.md and REDTEAM-rc19.md ONLY (do NOT overwrite prior-round artifacts); rc.18/rc.17 evidence preserved. Dispatch source-label ms-lead-kbn --verify, provider-read intact, provenance stamped. Builder fanout requires BOTH GOs. On both verdicts landing: identity-verify, relay sha256 + line/byte counts, I relay consolidated to Mos for combined GO. HARD HOLD: builders/physical adoption/commit/deploy/DB/Vault/live until BOTH-GO + Mos combined GO; rc.19 trunk-commit coordinator-gated AFTER BOTH-GO; fanout on Mos named GO only. CRITICAL STOP (Mos tightened): this is the LAST within-class round — if the rc.19 red-team AGAIN returns non-GO with residuals STILL confined to B1/B2 (two consecutive within-class non-converging rounds), that escalates the B1/B2 ENVELOPE to Jason as UNDERSPECIFIED (NOT another patch round); a THIRD distinct new defect class escalates contract-design to Jason. Both briefs carry this trigger. + +===== BEGIN VERBATIM rc.19 RE-REVIEW BRIEF (-> kbn-rereview-terra) ===== +You are an INDEPENDENT CONTRACT-CERTIFICATION RE-REVIEWER for the native Mosaic Kanban mission, FOURTH ROUND (rc.19 narrow residual-tightening). Same independent re-review role as prior rounds: you did NOT author the rc.19 amendment and you are NOT the adversarial red-team; independence from both is MANDATORY. Work read-only. This round certifies a NARROW amendment authorized to resolve EXACTLY five named residuals within the B1/B2 envelopes on top of the accepted rc.18 re-review-GO baseline, and nothing else. Write your verdict to REREVIEW-rc19.md in your working dir. Do NOT overwrite prior-round REREVIEW artifacts. + +CONTEXT — the rc.18 re-gate was SPLIT: re-review GO at sha256 826319e0dab361caf49283ac35a02d1c8e5a16454cb5df8e3940659ce0f87062, red-team NO-GO with FIVE residuals all confined WITHIN B1/B2 (no third defect class). The coordinator ruled CONTINUE to rc.19: the rc.18 re-review-GO delta is the ACCEPTED BASELINE, and rc.19 adds ONLY the five resolutions below. Everything the rc.18 re-review certified GO carries forward UNTOUCHED (except bounded consistency replacements strictly required by the exact mission_tasks ACL change). + +TARGET (bind these EXACT hashes; any drift voids this certification): +- RC19-DELTA.md sha256 efcdd13751d2e05072d058031a45ddb46b681ba516218c2b517be29240d29e0c (309 lines / 22970 B) — the PROPOSED contract delta against base head b0d78d8632c27d01cda3d30b0653716cf908e8ae, NOT committed. +- Regenerated PLAN.md sha256 8c72a5fb0956c08973deb86c58c05be82e2ecd4a51be62de6e4d164cd1029692 (469 lines / 48954 B). +- Accepted baseline (do NOT reopen): rc.18 delta 5c7da18f51cccc542037dfff2dc2e7cafc8b5f8fc4325f3d3c36b642c9db7b5e, rc.18 PLAN 488b48ec4af73e8b0762c23e728d970f0598d7c8d15d5224334e671120b681fd, rc.18 re-review GO 826319e0dab361caf49283ac35a02d1c8e5a16454cb5df8e3940659ce0f87062. Driving residual list: rc.18 red-team NO-GO b1b2f5f40cd7e8293524e620a728e00b399a7040cce3ac73a3df37ed1bc0c299. +- Base SSOT rc.16 at head b0d78d86 in docs/native-kanban-sot/, contracts/kanban-schema.v1.ts, code ground truth packages/db/src/schema.ts + packages/db/drizzle/** (latest 0016) + packages/storage/src/migrate-tier.ts. + +CERTIFY (each item PASS or FAIL with file + sub-card citation) — the FIVE residuals: +1. B1(a) RAW-SINK: the raw-SQL mission_tasks.status writer sink (public storage exports / raw sink) is mapped to a FROZEN owner card OR an explicit justified compatibility exception, zero-remainder, WITH a negative test proving no unowned raw path can mutate status. FAIL if any raw path remains unowned or the negative test is absent/thin. +2. B1(b) GRANTS: the exact grant set backing every mapped writer is enumerated and PINNED; NO implicit or ambient grant may satisfy a mapping. FAIL if any mapping relies on an unstated/ambient grant. +3. B1(c) W13 EQUALITY: writer W13 mapping is internally consistent — ONE coherent model, not two contradictory equalities; the prior scanner W13 rule contradicted the two-way zero-remainder equality by requiring a future nonexistent KBN-100 path. Confirm the delta states which side is AUTHORITATIVE and removes the contradiction. FAIL if the contradiction persists. +4. B2(d) PRE-MAIN LOADER-INJECTION: the code-injection surface that can execute BEFORE main() in the migrator entrypoint (loader/init path) is closed by a named mechanism. FAIL if the surface remains open or the mechanism is unspecified. +5. B2(e) DIRECT-UID-10003 WRAPPER-BYPASS: identity enforcement HOLDS when the migrator is invoked directly as UID 10003 WITHOUT the wrapper — enforcement does NOT depend solely on the wrapper being in the call path. Confirm ONE coherent model that survives wrapper-absent invocation. FAIL if enforcement can be bypassed by skipping the wrapper. + +ALSO CERTIFY: +6. SCOPE DISCIPLINE: the amendment changed NOTHING beyond the five residuals and the bounded consistency replacements strictly required by the mission_tasks ACL change. Walk every delta line; any change outside is a FAIL (scope-creep) + STOP+escalate. +7. BASELINE PRESERVED + T2/T3 UNDISTURBED: every rc.18-re-review-GO item carries forward untouched — T2 (KBN-101-03 owns 0017), T3 (07-before-06), first card KBN-101-00, RT-003..006, head-binding, rc.17 A-2 container surface, KBN-099. FAIL if any is perturbed beyond the required bounded consistency replacement. +8. IMPLEMENTATION-READINESS + HEAD/HASH BINDING: KBN-101-00, KBN-099, and every dependency-ready card are buildable WITHOUT any further contract change; and you reviewed the EXACT hashes above at base head b0d78d86. Name any card still needing a contract change. + +OUTPUT (REREVIEW-rc19.md): VERDICT one of GO / GO-WITH-FIXES / NO-GO; a per-item PASS/FAIL table with citations; any FAIL needing a further contract change = NO-GO plus STOP+escalate to the coordinator. Builder fanout requires BOTH your GO and the red-team GO. This runs IN PARALLEL with the adversarial red-team. + +STOP-CONDITION AWARENESS (coordinator, updated): this is the LAST authorized within-class refinement round. If a residual is still unresolved within B1/B2 after this round, that is a convergence-failure signal escalating the B1/B2 ENVELOPE itself to the human as underspecified — so certify strictly and completely. Separately, a THIRD distinct NEW defect CLASS (not a B1/B2 residual) = flag a contract-design escalation. + +RULES: OPERATOR-AGNOSTIC output — role terms only (builder lane, reviewer lane, coordinator); no personal names, session ids, or hostnames. Cite file paths and sub-card ids; prefer tables. You are a certification gate, not a rewrite: certify or fail with reasons; do not redesign the contract. + +===== END RE-REVIEW BRIEF ===== + +===== BEGIN VERBATIM rc.19 RED-TEAM BRIEF (-> kbn-redteam-sol) ===== +You are the ADVERSARIAL RED-TEAM agent for the native Mosaic Kanban mission, FOURTH ROUND (rc.19 narrow residual-tightening) — an INDEPENDENT skeptic, a SEPARATE instance from the amendment author AND from the re-reviewer. You are NOT a builder. Assume the amendment is wrong until proven otherwise. Work read-only. This round adversarially tests a NARROW amendment authorized to resolve EXACTLY five named residuals within B1/B2 on top of the accepted rc.18 re-review-GO baseline. Write your verdict to REDTEAM-rc19.md in your working dir. Do NOT overwrite prior-round REDTEAM artifacts. + +CONTEXT — you (red-team) returned rc.18 NO-GO at sha256 b1b2f5f40cd7e8293524e620a728e00b399a7040cce3ac73a3df37ed1bc0c299 with FIVE residuals all WITHIN B1/B2 (no third class). The coordinator ruled CONTINUE to rc.19, taking the rc.18 re-review-GO delta (826319e0) as accepted baseline and adding ONLY the five resolutions below. Your job: verify each residual is ACTUALLY and COMPLETELY closed, and hunt for any bypass that survives the fix. + +TARGET (bind these EXACT hashes; drift voids this verdict): +- RC19-DELTA.md sha256 efcdd13751d2e05072d058031a45ddb46b681ba516218c2b517be29240d29e0c (309 lines / 22970 B) — PROPOSED delta vs base head b0d78d8632c27d01cda3d30b0653716cf908e8ae, NOT committed. +- Regenerated PLAN.md sha256 8c72a5fb0956c08973deb86c58c05be82e2ecd4a51be62de6e4d164cd1029692 (469 lines / 48954 B). +- Accepted baseline: rc.18 delta 5c7da18f51cccc542037dfff2dc2e7cafc8b5f8fc4325f3d3c36b642c9db7b5e, rc.18 re-review GO 826319e0dab361caf49283ac35a02d1c8e5a16454cb5df8e3940659ce0f87062. Prior red-team NO-GO b1b2f5f40cd7e8293524e620a728e00b399a7040cce3ac73a3df37ed1bc0c299 (your driving residual list). +- Base SSOT rc.16 at head b0d78d86; contracts/kanban-schema.v1.ts; code ground truth packages/db/src/schema.ts + packages/db/drizzle/** (latest 0016) + packages/storage/src/migrate-tier.ts. + +ADVERSARIAL AXES — attack each residual; it is closed ONLY if you cannot break it: +1. B1(a) RAW-SINK. Independently sweep for ANY raw-SQL mission_tasks.status writer path (public storage exports, raw sink, any ORM bulk/upsert, any raw execute). Is EVERY raw path mapped to a frozen owner OR an explicit justified exception with ZERO remainder? Attack the exception: can it mutate status on an existing row? Attack the negative test: does it actually bite, or is it aspirational? +2. B1(b) GRANTS. Is the grant set backing every mapped writer enumerated and PINNED, with NO implicit/ambient grant satisfying a mapping? Hunt an ambient/inherited/default grant that lets an unmapped principal write status. Confirm the runtime role cannot write status via an unpinned grant. +3. B1(c) W13 EQUALITY. Is the W13 mapping now ONE coherent model, contradiction removed? Verify the authoritative side is stated and that no residual reference to a nonexistent future KBN-100 path remains. Attack for a NEW inconsistency introduced by the fix. +4. B2(d) PRE-MAIN LOADER-INJECTION. Is the pre-main() code-injection surface in the migrator entrypoint actually closed? Hunt any remaining loader/init/preload/constructor/env-driven path that executes before main(). Confirm the named mechanism genuinely prevents it, not just documents it. +5. B2(e) DIRECT-UID-10003 WRAPPER-BYPASS. Invoke the migrator directly as UID 10003 WITHOUT the wrapper in your threat model: does identity enforcement STILL hold? Confirm enforcement is in-process/fail-closed at connect time and does NOT depend on the wrapper being in the call path. Hunt a bypass: any path that connects to the DB with the wrapper absent and enforcement not asserted. + +ALSO ATTACK: +6. SCOPE-CREEP. Did the amendment change ANYTHING beyond the five residuals + the bounded consistency replacements strictly required by the mission_tasks ACL change? Any out-of-scope edit = blocker + STOP+escalate. Diff line by line. +7. BASELINE/T2/T3 REGRESSION + NEW-DEFECT. Confirm no rc.18-GO item was perturbed (0017 slot, 07-before-06, KBN-099 placement/DB-only, RT-003..006, A-2 surface). Does closing any residual introduce a NEW security or sequencing defect (new fail-open, new DDL entrypoint, new slot collision, new confused-deputy)? Is KBN-101-00 still the safe first card? + +OUTPUT (REDTEAM-rc19.md): VERDICT one of GO / GO-WITH-FIXES / NO-GO; a DEFECT TABLE (id, axis, severity blocker/major/minor, sub-card, concrete failure, minimal fix); CONFIRMATIONS of what you actively verified SOUND; any blocker unfixable without a further contract change = NO-GO + STOP+escalate. If artifacts are missing/incomplete/inconsistent, return NO-GO rather than guessing. Builder fanout requires BOTH your GO and the re-review GO; runs IN PARALLEL with re-review. + +STOP-CONDITION AWARENESS (coordinator, updated + CRITICAL): this is the LAST authorized within-class refinement round. If you again return non-GO with residuals STILL confined to B1/B2 (i.e. a SECOND consecutive within-class non-converging round), that itself is the convergence-failure signal — say so explicitly: it escalates the B1/B2 ENVELOPE to the human as UNDERSPECIFIED rather than triggering yet another patch round. Distinguish clearly in your verdict: (i) residuals fully closed = GO; (ii) still-open B1/B2 residuals = NO-GO that escalates the envelope as underspecified; (iii) a THIRD distinct NEW defect CLASS = contract-design escalation. Be precise about which case you are in. + +RULES: OPERATOR-AGNOSTIC output — role terms only (builder lane, reviewer lane, coordinator); no personal names, session ids, or hostnames. Be concrete: cite file paths and sub-card ids, prefer tables. You are the last gate before builders touch code — bias toward finding the defect. + +===== END RED-TEAM BRIEF =====