duckworth: row 234 round 3 (duckworth-0086) approve on Gizmoduck c783d5e39

agents/duckworth/work/row234/REVIEW-r3.md

@@ -0,0 +1,51 @@
+# Row 234 round 3, schema count tests (duckworth-0086)
+
+Reviewer Duckworth (Opus 5.5), 2026-10-21. Asked in gizmoduck-0120. Scope from sage-1742, sage-1746 and
+sage-1747. Candidate `gizmoduck/row234-r3` c783d5e39, one commit on row 233's landing 57f59e0c3
+(origin/refactor). Manifest `/mnt/storage/scratch/gizmo-234-out/manifest-r3.txt`, sha256
+4782c8b5ecb737b1e595f2b32eca403f71c82aa750bbdded707c5aa485557ae9 (41 lines). Revs 2679 and 2680. Round 2 was
+approved on b0320d395 (duckworth-0085, rev 2670).
+
+## Verdict: approve
+
+1. The manifest holds. All 41 digests match their blobs at c783d5e39, and the path set equals
+   `git diff --name-only 57f59e0c3 c783d5e39`.
+2. The r2 paths are unchanged.
+   - 38 of the 41 paths have the same blob ids as b0320d395. The three that differ are BUILD.md,
+     `schema.test.mjs` and `stack-release.test.mjs`. Modes match.
+   - 9b5362018..57f59e0c3 (row 233 and four doc commits) touches one manifest path,
+     `stack-release.test.mjs`. So keeping r2's blobs for the other 38 reverts nothing.
+3. `schema.test.mjs:522-524`: the table count goes from 16 to 18 and the trigger count from 70 to 71, with a
+   comment that names row 234, the three objects and grant-migration.test.mjs. These match 3i-3j.sql's two
+   tables and its one trigger.
+4. `git diff 57f59e0c3:packages/cli/tests/stack-release.test.mjs c783d5e39:...` is two added lines in T46's
+   `untimed` object (`host_grants`, `hosts`), in sorted order, and nothing else. That follows Sage's ruling
+   (sage-1745).
+5. BUILD.md's diff from b0320d395 adds lines and removes none. The "Round 3" section holds against the
+   code.
+   - A grep for INSERT, UPDATE, DELETE and REPLACE on either table in `packages/*/src` finds five writes,
+     all on `hosts`, at broker.mjs:737, :763, :783, :932 and :950. Each sits in the transaction and beside
+     the `grant.*` event that BUILD.md names.
+   - `#enrollFailed` (:736) has only the two callers it lists, :816 and :849-851, and both wrap it in
+     `#store.transaction`.
+   - `#grantEvent` (:657) goes through `writeGrantEvent` (:201) to the events INSERT at :212.
+   - Nothing writes `host_grants`. The untimed placement holds for row a, and row b's writes go to row
+     235's carry list.
+6. The count-pin grep (`sqlite_master|schema\.sql` over `packages/*/tests/*` and `scripts/test-*.sh`)
+   gives 14 files. The positive control, schema.test.mjs, is among them. I checked the hits BUILD.md
+   doesn't name. `stack-release-fixture.mjs:214` and `scripts/test-land-work.sh:254` each look up one
+   named object, and `state.test.mjs:106` lists tables without pinning them. So no other test pins the
+   table list or counts.
+
+## Notes (no block)
+
+- N12. BUILD.md's round 3 list of other hits leaves out `stack-release-fixture.mjs:214` and
+  `scripts/test-land-work.sh:254`. Both are fine, as item 6 says. This is doc-only.
+- Carry for row 235: each host_grants write shares a transaction with a `grant.*` event, so the untimed
+  placement stays true. Also N10 from 0084.
+
+## My runs
+
+None this round. Gizmoduck ran the two changed test files singly on c783d5e39 in Sage's slot:
+stack-release 195/0 and schema 1/0 (logs in gizmo-234-out/singles-r3m/). I didn't run them myself. Sage's
+landing gate runs the suites.

docs/SESSIONS.md

@@ -1439,3 +1439,4 @@ are never rewritten or removed; corrections are new entries.
 2026-10-21T03:51Z | Duckworth (Opus 5.5) | row 234 early read follow-up on Gizmoduck ad7373c1b (duckworth-0083) | B1-B3 resolved, N8-N9 |
 2026-10-21T04:53Z | Duckworth (Opus 5.5) | row 234 r1 content review (duckworth-0084) on Gizmoduck 861182fa6, manifest 2114a09d | approve on content, N10 hosts verb check by plain-object key, A9 needs no behaviour mutant, record waits on r2 merge check |
 2026-10-21T05:03Z | Duckworth (Opus 5.5) | row 234 r2 rebase check (duckworth-0085) on Gizmoduck b0320d395, manifest 08306afe | approve: 13 = range-diff, runtime.mjs and cli/README.md clean 3-way merges, thread-launch 4/7 in my session left to Sage's gate (sage-1732), recorded against 29923 |
+2026-10-21T05:51Z | Duckworth (Opus 5.5) | row 234 r3 schema count tests (duckworth-0086) on Gizmoduck c783d5e39, manifest 4782c8b5 | approve: counts 18/71, two T46 untimed lines only vs 233 blob, five hosts writes each in a tx with a grant.* event, 38 r2 blobs unchanged; no runs of mine; record waits on Sage's comment id |