docs(review): record independent glm-5.3 auth-registry spec review (#50)

Verdict ACCEPT WITH CHANGES. Persist ten-gate recommendations and three
P0 blockers: per-seat launch provider/model resolution; rotating OAuth
persistence for long-running seats; role auth ceiling ∩ settings profile
plus data-map/reset alignment. Reviewer made no repo edits.

Implementation remains blocked pending owner/conductor adjudication.
Prior gate remains green: suites 24/15/90/14/17 + verify.
This commit is contained in:
2026-09-04 12:14:48 -05:00
parent d9a94f51ba
commit 9ea7dea711
2 changed files with 22 additions and 0 deletions
+21
View File
@@ -614,3 +614,24 @@ root.
Spec is ready for owner/conductor review; CURRENT.md points only to that
review. Implementation remains blocked until all ten gates are resolved.
## Phase 25 independent review receipt (#50)
- Reviewer: live ms-test seat, zai/glm-5.3; read-only, no files edited.
- Verdict: ACCEPT WITH CHANGES. Taxonomy and reusable-profile/no-seat-
registration model are sound; two technical P0 gaps plus one policy P0
block implementation.
- P0: define per-seat launch provider/model resolution; resolve rotating
OAuth-token persistence for long-running seats with read-only generated
auth; enforce role auth ceiling ∩ settings profile in phase 1 and repair
AGENTS.md data map/reset warnings.
- Ten-gate recommendations persisted in Gitea #50. Important additions:
mandatory settingsProfile for v2 seats; session account pinning sidecar;
Node secret-handling core; remote Ollama HTTPS; dataRoot reset semantics;
hard-delete stale generated credentials; per-account refresh locking.
- Comms note: acknowledgment returned rc=2 (submission not confirmed), but
pane evidence showed it was submitted, read, and acted on. No retry was
sent because duplicate delivery would be worse; watch retired.
Implementation remains blocked pending owner/conductor adjudication and a
revised spec.