docs(fleet): tier the north star and declare the tier-0 operator surface (#1337)

docs/fleet/NORTH_STAR.yaml

@@ -6,7 +6,7 @@
 # packages/mosaic/src/commands/fleet.ts (renderNorthStarMarkdown). Edit the YAML,
 # never the .md.
 #
-# Self-contained Mosaic. NO Hermes runtime dependency. The backlog of record is
+# Self-contained Mosaic. The backlog of record is
 # the Mosaic Backlog on Mosaic's OWN native Postgres storage service.
 
 version: 1
@@ -24,7 +24,7 @@ substrate:
   note: >-
     The Mosaic Backlog is the backlog of record + dispatch engine, built on
     Mosaic's native Postgres storage service (@mosaicstack/db drizzle;
-    PGlite-embedded by default, full Postgres by config). NOT Hermes.
+    PGlite-embedded by default, full Postgres by config).
 
 standing_objectives:
   - id: NS-1
@@ -69,32 +69,53 @@ standing_objectives:
       business/operations) and the orchestrator provisions the matching persona
       roster and org structure from a cross-domain baseline persona library; the
       delivery/coding fleet is one profile among many.
+  - id: NS-10
+    text: >-
+      An adoption is not complete until the mechanism it replaces is removed.
+      Two live conventions for one concern is the defect, not a transition
+      state. Measured 2026-08-20: brain-home adopted by 9 modules and not 10;
+      MOSAIC_HOME honored in 4 places, each re-deriving it; backlog cards
+      declared while TASKS.md files stayed authoritative. Every one was decided
+      correctly and left half-applied.
 
 success_criteria:
+  - id: AC-NS-0
+    tier: 0
+    text: >-
+      The operator launches an agent on any configured harness with one
+      command, observes its state and sends it work without attaching to a
+      terminal multiplexer.
   - id: AC-NS-1
+    tier: 1
     text: >-
       The supervisor keeps a two-agent floor (1 orchestrator + >=1 enhancer)
       healthy across reboot.
   - id: AC-NS-2
+    tier: 1
     text: >-
       A goal added to this YAML is decomposed to cards and either merged or
       escalated, with no human in the loop.
   - id: AC-NS-3
+    tier: 1
     text: >-
       No PR merges with failure/error/no-status/timeout CI, and none bypass
       pr-merge.sh.
   - id: AC-NS-4
+    tier: 1
     text: >-
       TTL is enforced on claims; token caps remain advisory until a real meter
       exists.
   - id: AC-NS-5
+    tier: 1
     text: >-
       Flipping fleet/run/PAUSED halts dispatch and merges within one tick.
   - id: AC-NS-6
+    tier: 2
     text: >-
       A user can declare a system type and the fleet provisions the matching
       persona roster + topology from the baseline library, with no code change.
   - id: AC-NS-7
+    tier: 2
     text: >-
       A user-customized persona (edited or added via the orchestrator) survives
       mosaic update: baseline reseed never clobbers user overrides.
@@ -112,80 +133,186 @@ workstreams:
     title: Meta-loop — session-review + enhancer improvement PRs
   - id: F
     title: Safety-rails — TTL claims, advisory spend, PAUSE kill-switch
+  - id: G
+    title: Kill-switch — operator PAUSE honored before dispatch and merge
   - id: H
     title: Personas & system profiles — cross-domain library, system-type provisioning, update-surviving customization
+  - id: I
+    title: Operator surface — launcher, fleet visibility, reliable steering (tier 0)
+  - id: J
+    title: Web control plane — browser surface over the gateway (tier 1)
+  - id: K
+    title: Clients — desktop and mobile over the same backend (tier 2)
+  - id: L
+    title: Auth profiles — per-provider accounts, per-session selection (tier 2)
+
+# NOTE: workstreams C, D, E and F are declared but currently project no goals.
+# That is planning debt, not an editing error: their goals have not been written
+# yet. The A5 validator below reports it rather than letting it stay invisible.
 
 goals:
   - id: A1
     title: Machine-readable NORTH_STAR.yaml + Markdown projection
     phase: 1
+    tier: 1
     priority: must-have
     depends_on: []
   - id: A2
     title: Mosaic Backlog schema + storage-service card store (drizzle/PGlite)
     phase: 1
+    tier: 1
     priority: must-have
     depends_on: [A1]
   - id: A3a
     title: Card lifecycle — create/claim/release with stable ids + depends_on DAG
     phase: 1
+    tier: 1
     priority: must-have
     depends_on: [A2]
   - id: A3b
     title: TTL-bounded claim enforcement (wall-clock) on cards
     phase: 1
+    tier: 1
     priority: must-have
     depends_on: [A3a]
   - id: A4
     title: Advisory spend projection per card (degrades to TTL, no real meter)
     phase: 1
+    tier: 1
     priority: should-have
     depends_on: [A3a]
   - id: B1
     title: Supervisor tick — readiness scan, two-agent-floor health check
     phase: 2
+    tier: 1
     priority: must-have
     depends_on: [A3a]
   - id: B2
     title: Native dispatch/claim — assign ready dependency-satisfied work
     phase: 2
+    tier: 1
     priority: must-have
     depends_on: [A3b, B1]
   - id: B3a
     title: Planner decompose — goal added to YAML → cards
     phase: 2
+    tier: 1
     priority: must-have
     depends_on: [A2, B1]
   - id: B3b
     title: Replan request on empty backlog; escalate on no-decompose
     phase: 2
+    tier: 1
     priority: should-have
     depends_on: [B3a]
   - id: G1
     title: PAUSE kill-switch + merge-gate honored before dispatch and merge
     phase: 2
+    tier: 1
     priority: must-have
     depends_on: [B2]
   - id: H1
     title: Cross-domain baseline persona library (exec, marketing, ops, research, assistant + engineering roles)
     phase: 1
+    tier: 2
     priority: must-have
     depends_on: [A1]
   - id: H2
     title: System-type profiles — declarative mapping of system type to persona roster + topology
     phase: 2
+    tier: 2
     priority: must-have
     depends_on: [H1]
   - id: H3
     title: System-type provisioning — user declares type; orchestrator instantiates the matching roster + structure
     phase: 2
+    tier: 2
     priority: must-have
     depends_on: [H2]
   - id: H4
     title: Update-surviving persona customization — ad-hoc edits/additions persisted in a PRESERVE-protected override layer (baseline merged with overrides)
     phase: 2
+    tier: 2
     priority: must-have
     depends_on: [H1]
+  - id: A5
+    title: NORTH_STAR schema validator — every goal's workstream declared, every workstream has a goal, every depends_on id exists, every tier has a success criterion; runs in CI beside the Markdown regeneration check
+    phase: 1
+    tier: 0
+    priority: must-have
+    depends_on: [A1]
+  - id: I1
+    title: One home resolver — a single function resolving MOSAIC_HOME with a sane default, adopted by every module. Today brain-home.ts is imported by 9 modules while 10 still use DEFAULT_MOSAIC_HOME, and MOSAIC_HOME is re-derived ad hoc in 4 places. NS-10 applies - finish the adoption and delete the second path
+    phase: 1
+    tier: 0
+    priority: must-have
+    depends_on: []
+  - id: I2
+    title: 'mosaic fleet ps sees the fleet that is actually running. Three measured blockers: the roster declares socket `mosaic-fleet` which does not exist, the 18 live sessions are on the default socket, and nothing writes a roster because seats are launched outside the CLI. Make the socket configurable and the roster written at launch, or make ps read tmux + seat dirs directly'
+    phase: 1
+    tier: 0
+    priority: must-have
+    depends_on: [I1]
+  - id: I3
+    title: Migrate fleet steering onto mosaic agent send --verify (exists, FLEET-OBS-005, spec FR-5) and retire tools/tmux/agent-send.sh, which forges the sender (D33) and returns an uninformative rc (D16, D34). FR-5 predates those defects by a month
+    phase: 1
+    tier: 0
+    priority: must-have
+    depends_on: [I1]
+  - id: I4
+    title: 'mosaic fleet absorbs what launch-seat.sh does and launch-seat.sh is deprecated: compose the prompt file set, force the skill set, wire the style hook, fail closed on any unreadable input, export per-seat git identity, and register the seat in the roster. launch-seat.sh was a manual method; it is the reference implementation, not the destination'
+    phase: 1
+    tier: 0
+    priority: must-have
+    depends_on: [I1, I5]
+  - id: I5
+    title: Harness probe matrix — verify a working prompt-injection path for claude, codex, opencode and pi, and refuse any runtime whose path is unverified. AC-NS-0 clause 1 ("any configured harness") rests on this. The probe work in docs/plans/2026-08-19_launch-seat-multi-runtime.md (brain, untracked) transfers; its launch-seat.sh target does not
+    phase: 1
+    tier: 0
+    priority: must-have
+    depends_on: []
+  - id: I6
+    title: Finish the heartbeat responder (FLEET-OBS-002, the only Phase-2 task still in-progress; spec FR-2). Health must mean "answered a heartbeat", not "pane alive" — pane state measured two seats wrong on 2026-08-20
+    phase: 1
+    tier: 0
+    priority: must-have
+    depends_on: []
+  - id: I7
+    title: Independent review and live-fleet dogfood of the Phase-2 verbs (FLEET-OBS-008), then land them (FLEET-OBS-009). Implementation is done and verification is not; "done" in a task file frozen five weeks is not evidence
+    phase: 1
+    tier: 0
+    priority: must-have
+    depends_on: [I2, I3, I4, I6]
+  - id: I8
+    title: Neutralize misleading documentation — supersede headers on docs that state a stale status, a false blocker or a retired mechanism. Cheap, and it is tier 0 because a stale doc does not merely fail to help an agent, it actively misroutes one. Rebuilding the documentation is a separate and later job
+    phase: 1
+    tier: 0
+    priority: must-have
+    depends_on: []
+  - id: I9
+    title: Study t3code's agent-attach and multi-provider auth methods and record what transfers. Reference only — Mosaic implements its own within the stack, never adopts the code and never takes the dependency. Informs HOW I/J/K/L are built, not whether
+    phase: 1
+    tier: 0
+    priority: should-have
+    depends_on: []
+  - id: J1
+    title: Web control plane over the gateway — fleet visibility and steering in a browser, same data source as I2
+    phase: 3
+    tier: 1
+    priority: must-have
+    depends_on: [I2]
+  - id: K1
+    title: Desktop and mobile clients against the gateway, authenticated
+    phase: 4
+    tier: 2
+    priority: must-have
+    depends_on: [J1]
+  - id: L1
+    title: Per-provider auth profiles with per-session selection
+    phase: 4
+    tier: 2
+    priority: must-have
+    depends_on: [I4]
 
 assumptions:
   - id: ASM-1