diff --git a/agents/duckworth/work/row280/REVIEW-r1.md b/agents/duckworth/work/row280/REVIEW-r1.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..771c5d129 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/duckworth/work/row280/REVIEW-r1.md @@ -0,0 +1,57 @@ +# Row 280 (#1785) manifest review (duckworth-0121) + +- Reviewer: Duckworth (Opus 5.5), 2026-10-22. +- Request: Rocko, 07:51:04Z, and sage-2539. +- Candidate: source commit b765f5cb812e60789e4129ed2ab8009f5439a5be and packet commit d6c924764 on rocko/row280-da5d-20261022. The base is da5d3651d, which is still the origin/refactor tip. +- Method: git reads only. Nothing ran. The run evidence is Rocko's packet, plus Sage's bus gate (running now). + +## Verdict: approve b765f5cb8, manifest digest 27806c05. No blockers. Design conditions C1-C3 are met. + +## Checks + +- **Manifest.** + - candidate-manifest.sha256 hashes to 27806c0579c7…99e6f5, and all four lines match their blobs at b765f5cb8. The four paths are DEFERRED.md, grant-executor.test.mjs, host-run.test.mjs and scratch-sshd.mjs. + - d6c924764 adds only packet files. No path outside agents/rocko/work/queue-280/ differs between b765f5cb8 and d6c924764. + - Neither commit has an attribution line. + - No packet file holds a private key. The packet contains logs, conf files, JSON and runner scripts. +- **Proof (scratch-sshd.mjs:61-68).** + - Each 30 ms poll within the 3 s deadline needs three things: a connect, the child still alive (exitCode and signalCode null), and the exact `Server listening on 127.0.0.1 port N.` line in this attempt's own log. + - The log is re-read on every poll, so the line being written just after `listen()` can't make the helper give up. + - The optional trailing `\r` is right. Rocko's saved bytes (diagnostic-bytes.json) show that `sshd -E` ends its lines in CRLF, which is why the first green attempt exhausted. + - The line names the port, so a foreign listener can't satisfy it. +- **Retries (:44-72).** + - Each attempt writes `sshd-.conf` and an emptied `sshd-.log`. + - Every child gets a `t.after(stop)`, and a failed child is killed and awaited before the next attempt. + - When every attempt fails, the helper throws `scratch sshd did not start: `, which also covers N2. Never a skip. +- **Pick (:8-25).** + - The range is read from /proc. A read error or bad text throws. + - The two segments are 1024 to lo-1, and max(hi+1, 1024) to 65535. Both edges are right, and so is the case where the range sits below 1024. + - An empty set or a bad sample throws. +- **C1.** M2 is the old formula on the injected `rand` (mutants.json). The 0.6384 sample maps it to 32768, which is inside the 32768-60999 range, so the picker test kills M2 on every run on this host. +- **C2.** The regression asserts three things: `sshd-0.conf` starts with `Port `, `sshd-0.log` has no listening line for that port, and a later attempt's log has the listening line for the returned port. An override that's silently ignored can't pass. M1 returns the occupied port, so `notEqual` kills it. +- **C3 and N1.** + - `installSleepStub` (:76-88) handles exactly one argument of 30 or 60. It lasts that long while the test dir exists, polling every 50 ms, and exits once the dir is gone. + - Everything else goes to `exec /usr/bin/sleep "$@"`, including the hold stubs' `sleep 0.05` and host-run's `sleep 3`. + - Both fixtures install it, so N1 is covered. G22's `sleep 30` argv and the sudo.log check at :990 are unchanged. + - final-sweep.json shows empty cwd and pgrep sweeps. +- **DEFERRED.md.** X5 gets four appended lines and no earlier text changes. +- **Evidence.** + - Whole files: 41/41 and 26/26. + - The final M1 and M2 runs on the committed bytes fail with `AssertionError` in both files, 4/4. None of them is a timeout or a syntax error. + - Repeat: 60 whole-file runs, 2010/2010, with the cli load at 1588/1588. No skips and no timeouts (repeat-summary.json, skips.txt). + - assertion-preservation.json shows no existing assertion changed. +- **Drift.** The base equals origin/refactor. I grepped `packages/*/tests/*` and `scripts/*`: neither test file has a hash pin or a path reference outside itself. + +## Notes (don't block) + +- N1. d6c924764 commits 3,422 attempt logs and conf files, about 48k lines. Landing takes the four manifest paths. Whether the evidence tree reaches refactor is Sage's call. BUILD.md and the summary JSON carry the proof, so I recommend landing those without the per-attempt tree. +- N2. The M2 kill depends on the host's range: the 0.6384 sample hits it only when lo ≤ 32768 ≤ hi. The test itself stays correct anywhere. On a host with another range, the M2 kill would need different samples. +- N3. The `MOSAIC_SSHD_EVIDENCE` hook ships in the helper. It's inert when unset and useful for diagnosing a gate red. One line in the helper comment naming it would help. +- N4. Each file gains new double blank lines (Sage's nit). + +## Next + +1. Rocko makes the in-review move, and Sage posts the request. +2. Sage's bus gate goes green, and Sage posts this note and names a gap. +3. I record approve on the manifest digest 27806c05 in that gap. +4. The row lands, then 194 b17 rebases onto it and runs its whole gate. diff --git a/docs/SESSIONS.md b/docs/SESSIONS.md index a76f018a9..da0bd31bb 100644 --- a/docs/SESSIONS.md +++ b/docs/SESSIONS.md @@ -1461,3 +1461,4 @@ are never rewritten or removed; corrections are new entries. 2026-10-22T05:13Z | Duckworth (Opus 5.5) | #1782 owner thread claims design r1 on Morgana 3e9939b7b (duckworth-0118) | approve D1 with C1-C3 (tester path, --json shape, item 5 note); Q2 follow-up row with same bind | 2026-10-22T05:27Z | Duckworth (Opus 5.5) | row 277 (#1782) build early static look on Morgana c050bb90b, digest eedc783f (duckworth-0119) | no blockers, C1-C3 met, M1-M7 each have a killing test; approve waits on gate; N1-N2 | 2026-10-22T07:19Z | Duckworth (Opus 5.5) | row 280 (#1785) scratch sshd port design r1 (duckworth-0120), Rocko BUILD.md 22653ed8 on da5d3651d | approve with C1 (M2 on the injected random source, deterministic kill), C2 (regression asserts attempt one used P), C3 (X5 stub keeps ~30 s, exits once dir gone); N1 host-run remote sleeps :280/:372/:382/:437, N2 attempt log names, N3 live ports below range | +2026-10-22T07:54Z | Duckworth (Opus 5.5) | row 280 (#1785) manifest review (duckworth-0121), Rocko b765f5cb8 + packet d6c924764 on da5d3651d | approve, manifest 27806c05; C1-C3 met; M1/M2 assertion kills 4/4, repeats 2010/2010 + cli 1588/1588, 0 skips; N1 evidence tree size, N2 M2 kill range-bound, N3 evidence hook comment, N4 blank lines |