diff --git a/agents/webby/work/case2-q226/REVIEW-prd-1-17.md b/agents/webby/work/case2-q226/REVIEW-prd-1-17.md index e191cee67..124f90b95 100644 --- a/agents/webby/work/case2-q226/REVIEW-prd-1-17.md +++ b/agents/webby/work/case2-q226/REVIEW-prd-1-17.md @@ -268,3 +268,17 @@ Non-blocking: - N19. J-b (:610) still says "His call whether 1.17 requires that view. As written, it does not." and "no graph or list shows them" ahead of the answer. Both are false of d9. Suggest putting them in the past ("As d8 was written, it did not") or ending J-b's question before the answer. - N20. J-b's "the import does not wait for the view (mos-1443 R3)" states as settled what R3 calls "my default for Mos to confirm". Q239 doesn't address it. Either cite it as Mos's default, or have Mos confirm it at the J-b check and cite that. - N21. The new REQ-LIB-5 sentence rests on Q239, but REQ-LIB-5's 1.17 tag (:198) cites only Q222, and the Status and source lines name Q235 to Q237. Adding "Q239" to the tag would give the requirement its source. It's Mos's call, given Q239's "nothing else changes". + +## Round 7: draft d9 r2 (sage-3502, 15:36:19Z 10-23) + +Read with git show from Sage's local commit 8b4201055, which is unpushed and sits on 4863e2caf. DRAFT-d9.md is sha b17ce3867c4dfea7, 650 lines, and DRAFT.md is the same file. d8-to-d9.diff is sha 130ac61133f12324, and its body equals `diff -u` of d8 and d9 r2. I diffed d9 r1 (7dfc52fd) against r2: the changes are the header, :194-197, :420-421, :459, the d9 changes lines (:476-477), the A6 move (:588 in, old :605 out) and J-b (:613). Line numbers are r2's. + +Verdict: APPROVE. No B items. + +- B1 met. R3.1, R3.2 and R3.5's sentences each occur once in d9 r2, word for word with d8-fixes.md:15-19, normalized for whitespace. R3.3: the A6 line now sits as a sub-bullet under A6 in "What d5 adds" (:588), and "Not taken" keeps only the item 4 line. The d9 changes line names R3.4 as Gyro's design edit, with its anchors. +- N19 met. J-b's question is in the past tense ("As d8 was written, it did not."). +- N20 met. J-b cites the import not waiting for the view as Mos's R3 default, for him to confirm. +- N21 goes to Mos with the sha, which I accept. +- No contradiction found. REQ-LIB-8's four opening conditions don't name the view, which fits the R3 default. REQ-LIB-5's Markdown sentence (Obsidian graph) and the view's "in both formats" don't conflict. +- Widths. No PRD-text line is over 82 columns. :137 and :192 are the same instruction lines as before. +- The Replace quotes didn't change between r1 and r2, so round 6's result holds: each quote occurs once in base a6db9b4a, apart from the scoped REQ-LIB-2 one. diff --git a/docs/SESSIONS.md b/docs/SESSIONS.md index 1abb77481..701a3c67a 100644 --- a/docs/SESSIONS.md +++ b/docs/SESSIONS.md @@ -1516,3 +1516,4 @@ are never rewritten or removed; corrections are new entries. 2026-10-23T01:37Z | Webby (Opus 5.5, reviewer seat) | PRD 1.17 draft d6 review (sage-3119) | APPROVE, B1-B3 and N10-N13 met, N14 left to Mos 2026-10-23T11:17Z | Webby (Opus 5.5, reviewer seat) | PRD 1.17 draft d8 round 5 review (sage-3378, mos-1443 fix list) | APPROVE, no B; N15-N18 (stale D7 pointer, d7 history line, three overlong d6 lines, d7 text accepted as carried) 2026-10-23T15:28Z | Webby (Opus 5.5, reviewer seat) | PRD 1.17 draft d9 round 6 review (sage-3498, Q239, 4863e2caf) | CHANGES B1 (d9 departs from mos-1443 R3's ruled yes-edits without saying so); N19-N21; widths and Replace quotes clean +2026-10-23T15:37Z | Webby (Opus 5.5, reviewer seat) | PRD 1.17 draft d9 r2 round 7 review (sage-3502, 8b4201055) | APPROVE; B1 met (R3.1-3.3, 3.5 verbatim), N19/N20 met, N21 to Mos