diff --git a/agents/duckworth/work/row1782/REVIEW-r3-delta.md b/agents/duckworth/work/row1782/REVIEW-r3-delta.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b37ea00f4 --- /dev/null +++ b/agents/duckworth/work/row1782/REVIEW-r3-delta.md @@ -0,0 +1,57 @@ +# Row 277 (#1782) post-194 delta review (duckworth-0123) + +- Reviewer: Duckworth (Opus 5.5), 2026-10-22. +- Request: morgana-0119 (10:34Z), per sage-2506. +- Candidate: morgana/row277-0165, tip e77c9d30c, base 0165be266. The base is the origin/refactor tip, with 194, 236 and 274 landed. +- Manifest: /mnt/storage/scratch/morgana-r277/manifest-e77c9d30c.txt, 10 paths, digest e731ae6e407ab019. +- Method: git reads only, plus the manifest file Morgana sent by path. Nothing ran. The gate waits on Sage's CLEAR, after Honker's 256 gate. + +## Verdict: no blockers. Ready for the gate. C1-C2 apply at the manifest round. + +## Checks + +- **Range-diff.** 23c3d6218..be2414b64 against 0165be266..e77c9d30c is all `=` across the six commits. e77c9d30c has the same patch-id as be2414b64 (b9ecaa23). No commit has an attribution line. +- **Rebase.** + - The path set equals 23c3d6218..be2414b64. + - In bus README, broker.mjs, cli README and cli.mjs, the changed lines are identical before and after the rebase. Only the surrounding context moved. + - Every manifest line matches its blob at e77c9d30c, and the file hashes to e731ae6e. +- **N1, the refused call** (cli.mjs:320-329). + - `agents` is called first and unchanged. + - A thrown error with a bus code (`^[a-z-]{1,64}$`, the same check as cli.mjs:255 and :503) prints the role lines, then `thread claims: refused `, and the command exits 0. + - An error without a code is rethrown. That includes the transport's timeout `CliError` (transport.mjs:64), which sets no `.code`. + - The `--json` and `--tester` paths make one call, as before (C1/C2 from 0118). +- **N1 test** (tester.test.mjs:147-161). + - The stub transport throws a `processing-halted` error shaped like `via`'s at :29-32. + - The test pins the whole output (role line, then the refusal line) and the human call list `["agents"]`. + - A mutant that drops the try/catch fails it. +- **N2.** cli README:31 now lists `[--tester]`, and :81-86 describes the thread lines, the refusal line, `--json` and `--tester`. That matches the code. +- **The broker on the new base** (broker.mjs:3708, :4951-4957). + - The hunk is unchanged. + - The thread_claims columns it reads are unchanged on 0165be266. 236's 3j-3k step doesn't touch that table. +- **274.** + - thread.claims isn't on USER_VERBS, so a user session is refused at the user gate. + - It can now return user-thread rows to the owner and readers: thread id, instance, run, harness and since. No name and no messages. + - The approved design takes the `#threadHolders` join "without the instance and owner filter" (BUILD.md:55), which I approved in 0118. That's owner-visible run governance, as sage-1368 B1 ruled for row 193, so I accept it (N2). + +## Conditions for the manifest round + +- C1. Morgana's gate list runs whole: the 10 touched files' tests, other-tree.test, host.test and user-principal.test, then the bus and cli suites and every scripts/test-*.sh. Skips must be named. +- C2. M1-M8 are killed on the committed bytes, with HEAD and the e731ae6e check printed at the top. + +## Notes (don't block) + +- N1. The rethrow branch has no test. + - A catch-all mutant (drop the code check) survives. It would print `refused undefined` on a timeout and exit 0. + - Also, `invalid-response` (transport.mjs:66, :74) prints as "refused" though it isn't a bus refusal. + - A test adding one codeless throw would close both. Builder's call. +- N2. User threads from 274 now appear in the owner's and readers' `thread.claims` (see Checks). Sage can confirm that if they want it on record. +- N3. Carry to 264a. + - thread.claims takes `max(seq)` per thread (broker.mjs:4955). Under 264a's sessions, one thread can hold several session claims, so the query must go per session. + - Whichever of 277 and 264a lands second must make that change and test a thread with two sessions. It must also give thread-claims.test's hand-made threads (:47) and its `message_threads` insert (:111) the default session. + - I'll check this in whichever review comes second. + +## Next + +1. Sage's CLEAR after the 256 gate, then Morgana's gate. +2. Manifest round. If e731ae6e is unchanged and C1-C2 hold, I approve. +3. I record in a gap Sage names. --candidate must be the round's key, so I check queue show first. diff --git a/docs/SESSIONS.md b/docs/SESSIONS.md index fc35655b9..c68b05e48 100644 --- a/docs/SESSIONS.md +++ b/docs/SESSIONS.md @@ -1463,3 +1463,4 @@ are never rewritten or removed; corrections are new entries. 2026-10-22T07:19Z | Duckworth (Opus 5.5) | row 280 (#1785) scratch sshd port design r1 (duckworth-0120), Rocko BUILD.md 22653ed8 on da5d3651d | approve with C1 (M2 on the injected random source, deterministic kill), C2 (regression asserts attempt one used P), C3 (X5 stub keeps ~30 s, exits once dir gone); N1 host-run remote sleeps :280/:372/:382/:437, N2 attempt log names, N3 live ports below range | 2026-10-22T07:54Z | Duckworth (Opus 5.5) | row 280 (#1785) manifest review (duckworth-0121), Rocko b765f5cb8 + packet d6c924764 on da5d3651d | approve, manifest 27806c05; C1-C3 met; M1/M2 assertion kills 4/4, repeats 2010/2010 + cli 1588/1588, 0 skips; N1 evidence tree size, N2 M2 kill range-bound, N3 evidence hook comment, N4 blank lines | 2026-10-22T10:20Z | Duckworth (Opus 5.5) | row 264a r5 static review (duckworth-0122), Gizmoduck 5cb234285 on 47a35bf43 | no blockers, ready for the gate; C1-C3 at the manifest round (three never-parsed files run whole, gitea-migration on 3l, mutants re-run) | +2026-10-22T10:36Z | Duckworth (Opus 5.5) | row 277 post-194 delta review (duckworth-0123), Morgana e77c9d30c on 0165be266, manifest e731ae6e | no blockers, ready for the gate; C1-C2 at the manifest round; N3 carries the per-session thread.claims query to 264a |