diff --git a/agents/webby/work/case2-q226/REVIEW-prd.md b/agents/webby/work/case2-q226/REVIEW-prd.md index bfeaf1788..377fdf8e9 100644 --- a/agents/webby/work/case2-q226/REVIEW-prd.md +++ b/agents/webby/work/case2-q226/REVIEW-prd.md @@ -64,3 +64,31 @@ Verdict: APPROVE. The gate is `packages/tasks/tests/requirements.test.mjs` and the `scripts/test-*.sh` that read the PRD or requirements.json, on Sage's run. + +## Round 3: row 282 candidate 6b5b06819 on 94c33a43c, and Scrooge's row 285 blocker (18:40Z) + +The rebase is clean: range-diff shows both commits as `=` (1841f7d4e, 6b5b06819), and none of the three +paths moved between aca16404c and 94c33a43c. But Scrooge's row 285 report (scrooge-285-routing-q1-webby) +shows a gap I missed in both earlier rounds, so the approval does not carry. Read with git, nothing run. + +Verdict on 6b5b06819: CHANGES (B2). + +B2. 1.15 gives creative agents a write (REQ-LIB-6, prd.md:1253-1260), and design f6e3e7f20:259 and the +C2-08b brief (883f78f14 rows :1821-1822) put the new action `library.write` in each creative role's +`withinRole`. PRD 1.15 never says that action is routed: +- REQ-WAIT-3 (prd.md:698-707): a new action is a hard wait "until a PRD version says it isn't", and the + paragraph after it lists each routed addition by version. 1.15 adds no line there. +- REQ-WAIT-2 (:692-697): no role file may grant a hard-wait action. The list changes only "under a new + PRD version that Jason approves". +- Code agrees. vocabulary.mjs:62-66 and broker.mjs:51-52 add an action to ROUTED only by the reviewed + commit that names it routed. Scrooge cites role.mjs:43 as the refusal. +So C2-08b cannot be built to its brief under 1.15 as written. The fix belongs in this PRD row, the +version that creates the write. Add a REQ-WAIT-3 line in the existing pattern, for example: +"`library.write` was added as a hard wait and routes under REQ-LIB-6 since version 1.15." Also name the +bounds that make it routable: creative sessions only, supporting `.md` paths only, a live chief grant, +one commit per write with the notice and revert. Then record it in the 1.15 version note. +REQ-WAIT-2 makes this Jason's approval, not mine, and Mos's mos-1322 acceptance covered the LIB-1/LIB-2 +widening, not a hard-waits change. Mos or Jason has to say yes to the routing sentence before it lands. + +My miss: in rounds 1 and 2 I checked REQ-LIB-6 against Q223/Q226 and the design, but never against the +REQ-WAIT rules that govern any new action. The design and brief rounds (webby-0151, -0155) missed it too. diff --git a/docs/SESSIONS.md b/docs/SESSIONS.md index 247552a62..d11a6b594 100644 --- a/docs/SESSIONS.md +++ b/docs/SESSIONS.md @@ -1494,3 +1494,4 @@ are never rewritten or removed; corrections are new entries. 2026-10-22T17:32Z | Webby (Opus 5.5, reviewer seat) | Q226 round 3 f6e3e7f20 and 883f78f14 (gosalyn-0171), and row 198 r3 844f25659 (Bushroot) | Q226 APPROVE (R4 met, events-table check); row 198 APPROVE as read (B4 met), gate is Sage's run and M1-M17; webby-0159 2026-10-22T17:33Z | Webby (Opus 5.5, reviewer seat) | PRD 1.15 round 2 6742cf5ad (gosalyn-0173), and row 198 f6dc0fded (doc-only) | PRD APPROVE (B1, N1 met); row 198 approval carries to f6dc0fded; webby-0160 2026-10-22T17:48Z | Webby (Opus 5.5, reviewer seat) | row 198 r3 rebase onto 253, 1fb66792e: range-diff all =, approval carries, M9 scan clean on the new base (webby-0162) | approve +2026-10-22T18:41Z | Webby (Opus 5.5, reviewer seat) | row 282 PRD 1.15 on 6b5b06819: CHANGES B2, library.write has no REQ-WAIT-3 routing line (Scrooge row 285 blocker, my earlier miss) (webby-0164) | changes