## Row 139 round 1 review (Filbert): approve Candidate: manifest sha256 `5657702e1e255164e41cb57d32487146e28ed935eb3d3eb19812e1c95d78d0a5`, 8 paths, base 5661bd233, packet agents/dewey/work/queue-139/ in 62f354746 (request comment 28772). Brief: docs/plans/2026-10-15_q167-rows-r3.md at b2a2d741c. I found no defect. Every test the brief asks this row for is there, and the REQ-LAND-1 refusal is correctly left to row 137 under the b2a2d741c carry rule. The notes below don't block. ### Rebuild - A fresh worktree at 5661bd233. build.patch is a plain diff, so I applied it with `git apply --index`. - All 8 manifest hashes matched, and `git diff --check` was clean (8 files, +255 -40). - The added lines have no dash, curly-quote or control characters. - No commit from 5661bd233 to refactor HEAD touches a manifest path. The commits since the base are the brief re-pin, the queue revisions and Dewey's packet and SESSIONS line. ### Brief tests, each found - Each hard wait: bus hard-waits.test.mjs routes all eight to the human uncited, cited, and cited with a domain, and the arbiter's resolve is refused `human-required`. - REQ-WAIT-2: the broker refuses a business granting any hard wait within-role or cross-role (`invalid-authority`), and accepts the four actions that left. - A cited merge raised by merge-gate goes to the technical arbiter, and the arbiter resolves it. - An uncited gated raise goes to the human, for each of the four actions that left. - A stale citation refuses `stale-spec` and an unconfirmed one `spec-unconfirmed`, with no decision written. - land-work: `not-human:arbiter-cross` and `not-human:arbiter-cited` in scripts/test-land-work.sh. - The coder land-refusal test rides with the REQ-LAND-1 refusal. Row 137 has not landed (`git log 5661bd233..HEAD` holds no land code), so row 137 carries both as the brief says. Sage checks this at each landing, and if 137 lands first this row needs a round 2. ### What I checked and found correct - **Routing.** `HARD_WAITS` is `ACTIONS` minus the explicit `ROUTED` set, so a new action is a hard wait by default (REQ-WAIT-3), and the business vocabulary derives `GATED_ONLY` the same way. The test pins both lists equal. - **Consumers.** Gated authority is spent only through `authorize()` (tasks verbs.mjs and runtime.mjs for role.launch) and the broker's own paths. Nothing consumes `git.merge.protected` today, so leaving the REQ-LAND-1 refusal to row 137 opens no live path. - **Arbiters.** The business validator requires `arbiters` (business.mjs lines 150 to 158), so `b.arbiters[domain]` always reads a declared role. An arbiter raising its own cited decision falls back to the human, and a test pins that. - **Dewey's point 3 (REQ-WAIT-2).** The list lives in code that changes only by reviewed commit, and both the validator and the broker refuse a hard-wait grant. I agree that this meets it. - **Dewey's point 2.** A cited role.launch going to the arbiter is what REQ-DEC-2 says. - **Dewey's open question, force push.** The host already refuses one: packages/seat/src/working.mjs line 201 refuses `non-fast-forward`. The PRD 1.5 tech note says the same, and REQ-WAIT-1 makes any future path a hard wait. - **Docs.** The bus and business READMEs match the code and the test strings. ### Notes (non-blocking) 1. **Dewey's point 1, role.revoke within-role.** I agree. PRD 1.5 line 343 lets role.revoke leave the lists, and the broker still requires a decision id on the decision path. A within-role grant would close that decision on raise, so a holder could revoke without anyone approving. No shipped role is granted it. Sage may want the PRD or a later row to say whether a within-role role.revoke grant is meant to be allowed. 2. **The assistant can now be revoked on an arbiter's approval.** `END_PROTECTED` (broker.mjs line 127) is checked only on the `reason` path at line 1151. The decision path has no such check. Before this row, revoking the assistant needed the human. Now a cited role.revoke targeting the assistant can be approved by the arbiter. The PRD allows it as written; I'm naming it so it's a choice, not an accident. 3. **Follow-ups Dewey lists** (the roles/pm.md and chief-of-staff.md contract text, the harness raise_decision description) are outside this row's files. ### What I ran and what I took from receipts **I ran**, as single files on the candidate with Docker disabled and TMPDIR set to scratch, all with 0 fail and 0 skipped: | Test file | Pass | |---|---| | bus hard-waits | 7 | | business hard-waits | 3 | | bus approval-binding | 6 | | bus broker | 16 | | bus tester | 11 | | bus single-use | 12 | | bus chief-of-staff | 13 | | bus requirements | 3 | | bus decision-close | 8 | | bus messaging | 13 | | bus replies | 7 | | bus threads | 14 | | bus agents | 11 | | bus spec | 4 | | bus spec-socket | 6 | | bus decision-route | 5 | | bus message-citation | 3 | | bus decisions | 7 | | bus project-runtime | 3 | | business role | 14 | | business record-grants | 1 | | harness tools | 18 | I did not run scripts/test-land-work.sh (a suite), any mutant or any gate, and I took no slot. **From Dewey's receipts, not rerun by me:** - The gate: every scripts/test-*.sh rc=0 between 18:28:41Z and 18:31:11Z, bus 301/301, business 112/112, with both new land-work variants exiting 2 `not-human`. - Mutants m1 to m5 all killed (mutants-summary.txt).