# #1511 R1 combined review

Author Rocko. Frozen candidate /tmp/task-attribution-r1-frozen-sRoqqr5m.
15-file manifest: r1-manifest.sha256, SHA256
0185cc65c973f6d89c394e2e9fba67fccd794b8ad2be2720a8bb3700b2b018a3.
Darkwing independently matched every author pin against frozen and working files.
The author snapshot contains selected files, not a standalone runnable checkout.

Both independent lanes returned before correction authorization.

## Filbert backend verdict

APPROVE AS SOURCE for exact R1, subject to separate presentation review.
Reported independent serialized seat/board/WebUI 141/141 in both working tree
and dependency-complete overlay /tmp/filbert-task-attribution-review-EaqP6CYc.
Log: TASK-ATTRIBUTION-TESTS.txt in overlay. Working launcher regressions 6/6,
/tmp/filbert-task-attribution-launchers.txt. Additional invalid-environment and
control-character probes passed. All 15 pins matched after tests.

Confirmed optional v1 compatibility, precedence/refusal rules, preservation of
other fields and task-selected attribution only. No backend blocker.
Nonblocking comment correction: bounded identifier syntax does not guarantee
absence of private identifiers. Numeric IDs and email-like names still fit.
Remove that inaccurate privacy claim in a separately pinned R2.

## Dewey UX verdict

REQUEST CHANGES, R1-U1. WebUI inspector maps null/inapplicable attribution to
unknown, conflating a transcript/connector task with a legacy registered task
whose setter is unknown. Preserve null as not applicable or a missing-value
marker. Keep unknown for a selected legacy registration. Add assertions for
legacy unknown, transcript/Discord null, and transition from a known setter
without stale attribution. Existing edge expectation currently enshrines the bug.

Dewey independently ran matching working-tree browser, browser-edge and Discord
suites, 3/3 passed, 330 contrast samples. Frozen/working pins matched before and
after. No screenshots, live observation or full backend verdict claimed.
Escaping, placement and reply boundaries otherwise passed his scoped review.

## Disposition

R1 is not approved for integration. Preserve its snapshot and manifest. Rocko
corrects R1-U1 and the inaccurate comment, reruns applicable checks, and supplies
R2 with changed/inherited pins. Both review lanes then verify the exact R2.
The missing docs/TOOLS.md usage flag is required additive documentation; preserve
other owners' dirty edits when adding it. No Gate F, live change or publication.