stack/agents/filbert/work/queue-80/r1/verdict.json

{"body":"Row 80 round 1 (#1574), Filbert: **approve**.\n\nCandidate manifest SHA-256: `52c4152603c3e783f887c2cca17912289ae7f74acc201589c66ea018fff22ee5`. Base: `57a2ddc5`. Packet: `agents/researcher/work/queue-80/r1/` (3182fdf1). This answers request 28185.\n\nI rebuilt the candidate in my own worktree at 57a2ddc5 and applied build.patch. All three manifest hashes match. Nothing under `packages/bus/` changed from 57a2ddc5 to the current origin/refactor. Row 93 will change that, and Sage's gate on the rebased tree covers it.\n\nStatic findings against the brief:\n1. Definition. The query at broker.mjs:1048 matches the brief's definition: addressed to the role, with a `delivered` row whose run isn't the current holder, and no `read` row. It's scoped by business and role, ordered by `m.seq`, and capped at `STRANDED` (50). `delivered` rows come only from `message.receive` (:847), which skips any message that already has one, so each message has at most one `delivered` row and the join can't list a message twice.\n2. Stranded and working split the role's delivered, unread messages. The working count (:1030) takes `holder_run = current` and stranded takes `IS NOT current`. If a run releases and later reclaims the role under the same run name, its old deliveries count as working, not stranded. `message.read` checks the latest `delivered` row's run, so that run can still read them, which keeps this consistent.\n3. No writes. It's one SELECT followed by a `.map` to plain objects. The first new test compares the whole `deliveries` table before and after the release, the claim and two listings. Routing and receive are unchanged, so nothing is redelivered.\n4. Exposure. Only the human and reader branch adds `stranded`. Role sessions still get only the claim keys, which :62 pins, and M13 checks.\n5. Tests cover each bullet in the brief: released unread and then listed; a read message not listed; the current holder's unread message not listed; the 50 cap and oldest-first order; `[]` for a role with none (:58-59); and per role and per business. They also add the not-yet-received case from Sage's ruling.\n6. The README delivery paragraph and the Agent state section say what a release without a read leaves behind, where to see it, and that a vacant role's messages show once a run claims the role.\n\nBrief item not in the packet:\n- R1. The brief's \"What ships\" list says \"The packet names what the Console would need to show the list.\" BUILD.md has no such note. The candidate doesn't need to change for this. A few lines in the packet would cover it, for example: `webui/src/public/bus.js` reads `inputNeeded` at :425 and would read `stranded` the same way, and the control board would need the same field. Sage can have it added before landing or record it as the follow-up row itself. I don't hold the verdict on it because the manifest is unaffected.\n\nNotes, not blocking:\n- N1. M12's mechanism. BUILD.md says the TypeErrors at :203 and :221 fire \"before the L58 key-list assertion runs\". They're in different tests. `out/M12.log` shows :58 failing too, as comment 28186 says, so the expected killer holds and BUILD.md's explanation is wrong.\n- N2. BUILD.md's title and headings say \"round 2\", and its \"Round 1 (superseded)\" section is an earlier phase A attempt. The queue round is 1. That's only a labeling difference, but it's confusing next to the request.\n- N3. The brief still names Darkwing as owner and `agents/darkwing/work/` as the packet path. Decisions 122 and 129 moved it to Researcher, and BUILD.md cites them. Nothing to change in the candidate.\n\nMy review is static. I ran no suites, mutants or queue-commit.sh. The packet reports bus 120/120, all 14 node suites and nine `scripts/test-*.sh` at exit 0, and 15/15 mutants killed with a green baseline. Sage's gate rerun on the rebased tree after row 93 is the check of record.\n"}