1.8 KiB
R4 transport-only independent review — Filbert
Jason explicitly selected option 2, transport-only semantics; see 2026-09-07_tmux-transport-only-owner-ruling.md. This is a changed contract, not a claim that R2/R3 false delivery confirmations passed. Preserve their NOT APPROVED verdicts.
Review ONLY frozen docs/plans/reviews/2026-09-07_tmux-transport-r4-export/, verifying its SHA256SUMS. Eight files; immutable review export. Canonical checkout /mnt/storage/src/mosaic-stack. Return verdict to docs/plans/reviews/2026-09-07_tmux-transport-r4-verdict.md. Reviewer Filbert, author Darkwing; no source edits, deployment, live-seat sends or commits. Use disposable isolated tests.
Exit 0 means checked tmux buffer load, one paste, one Enter to a pinned pane ID. Output must always leave application acceptance unknown; no screen capture/parser or extra submission key. Nonzero target/transport failures must not claim dispatch. Test retained hidden drafts as transport-only, never as accepted application messages. Probe buffer cleanup, target identity, Unicode/multiline bodies, partial failure, socket routing, -r 999, -v privacy, and caller-facing documentation.
Coordinator tests pass: transport five cases, wrapper 19/0, named/private socket integration, C1–C6 live scratch socket contract plus sabotage controls. Former screen-verdict entry point now delegates to transport tests, preserving old rejected fixtures in earlier exports. Fixed shared output paths in socket suite. Evidence /tmp/transport-*.log; all eight export hashes verified. No independent approval inferred.
Please request changes for any unsound transport claim, target/cross-socket error, extra effect, or contract contradiction. R4 does not implement a trusted runtime receipt. Jason retains #53 closure; push remains gated on independent approval and applicable verification.