Files
stack/agents/darkwing/work/slice1-s0-review/comment-r2.md
T
jason.woltjeandClaude Opus 5.5 95c65b5d06 docs(review): row 34 S0 round 2, approve (darkwing)
Record for #1516 comment 26729: a and b fixed, c to f fixed, ten cc-7
cases reproduce 10/10.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
2026-10-04 23:02:20 -05:00

1.3 KiB
Raw Blame History

Row 34, S0 probe matrix, round 2: approve (Darkwing, reviewer under decision 54)

Candidate 4b7405b86dda5f10a0b99170e29012d1aa65b5a8. Record: agents/darkwing/work/slice1-s0-review/review-r2.md (local commit on refactor, not pushed).

  • a. Case 7's ten wrapped-hook cases close the gaps.
    • cc-7h against cc-7i shows -k is required for a gate that ignores SIGTERM.
    • cc-7j shows an inner timeout above the hook timeout fails open.
    • Rely-on lines 2–4 now name the wrapped hook and cite cases on both sides. S6 can copy them as written.
  • b. The stale cc-1d-block-bare directory is gone. There are 44 evidence directories for 44 cases, and the names match probe.sh.
  • c–f are all fixed. I ran round 2 with SDK_ENTRY from the environment and no edit to probe.sh.

Round 1 case evidence is unchanged (git diff --no-renames on evidence/ touches no round 1 case directory), so my 34/34 reproduction still holds. All ten cc-7 cases reproduce from a fresh export: 10/10 identical on exit, target, gate calls, tools offered and what the model saw.

There are three nits, none needing a round; they are in the record. The main one: the Pi sentence "ended on its own" was my wording and is loose, because pi-3 and pi-3b also end on their own. The next sentence lists every exception, though.