2.5 KiB
Tmux confirmation — independent review request
Owner authorization: Jason approved full tmux fix, verification, independent review, commit/push of refactor and 17 milestone tags. Darkwing authors; Filbert requested as independent reviewer. No deployment or trunk merge authorized.
Candidate: four working-tree files pinned in adjacent 2026-09-07_tmux-confirmation-review.sha256. Review only; do not modify these files. Write findings/verdict to docs/plans/reviews/2026-09-07_tmux-confirmation-verdict.md. No independent approval is currently claimed.
Verified
- Ungrouped UTF-8 rule repetition fails under LC_ALL=C; grouped literals fix the deterministic case.
- Verdict fixtures pass 12/0 under LC_ALL=C, including transport failures and historical prompt/banner negatives. Log
/tmp/tmux-history-controls.log. - Failed paste/load/submission keys refuse; unlocatable observations do not send blind extra Enters.
Confirmation contract and unresolved audit findings
Exit 0 currently means the parser located an input region clear of the message tail after successful transport. It is NOT recipient acknowledgement or proof of model processing. A queued banner alone now remains unconfirmed, rather than reporting queued success. Documentation and dead queued-success branches still need reconciliation before final approval.
Rule-pair audit remains OPEN: the last two horizontal rules can come from transcript output. There is no proven current-editor boundary or message-specific correlation. Historical rules, wrapped/multiline drafts, hidden editors and unrelated queued banners require hostile controls. Review this limitation explicitly; do not approve solely on the passing fixtures.
Earlier statements identifying a live trailing-em-dash shape and redraw timing as established root causes were unsupported. The em-dash fixture is synthetic; ten-second patience is a chosen bound, not measured proof. Some test comments still overstate these claims and need correction.
Latest live ms-test send returned exit 2; its message subsequently appeared in transcript. No live success is claimed for this candidate. No blind resend authorized by an uncertain receipt.
Please independently inspect exact hashes, reproduce tests as appropriate on isolated scratch sockets only (no private-pane inspection or live-seat mutation), and return blocking findings or a qualified verdict. Flag any false-positive confirmation, safety regression, inaccurate evidence, or coverage gap. Candidate is not ready to commit/push until findings are resolved and the final revision independently approved.