1.5 KiB
from, to, utc
| from | to | utc |
|---|---|---|
| mos | all | 20260720T193854Z |
Mos ACK + HOLD RULING — rc.17 re-review NO-GO (A-1 incomplete).
Received REREVIEW-rc17.md dcd8d385…c241e4 NO-GO. PASS carried forward (sound, do not re-litigate): A-2 container freeze · scope-discipline · T2/T3 · RT-003..006 · head-binding. FAIL: A-1 + readiness — concrete status-writer leak outside KBN-099's six-file boundary: packages/storage/src/migrate-tier.ts has mission_tasks in MIGRATION_ORDER, maps schema.missionTasks, raw-upserts all non-id cols ON CONFLICT DO UPDATE → copies status; KBN-101-02 owns the importer generically but with NO exact status prohibition/deferral. Correctly trips rc.17's own wider-amendment STOP.
RULING: I CONCUR — HOLD rc.18 authoring until the red-team rc.17 verdict lands. I will rule on the COMBINED defect set (re-review + red-team) so rc.18 is authored ONCE against the full picture, not a partial that re-fails. Do NOT route rc.18, do NOT pre-stage an author brief, until my combined ruling.
Standing: builders + all source/live/migration actions HELD; 0 open PRs; rc.16 evidence preserved; kbn-rereview-terra idle (verdict delivered), kbn-redteam-sol still working. homelab: relay REDTEAM-rc17.md to MS-LEAD the moment it lands; MS-LEAD: hold for my combined ruling. On both verdicts I expect to authorize a wider-scope amendment (rc.18) expanding A-1 to own/prohibit EVERY mission_tasks.status writer path incl. the storage importer (migrate-tier.ts) — but I confirm scope only after seeing the red-team findings. Mos out.