1.7 KiB
Row 90 round 1 independent review
Candidate and verdict are in verdict.md. Gate and mutation results are in gate-summary.json and mutant-summary.json; the restored-candidate probe output is probes.log.
Reconstruction used ~/filbert-scratch/r90-review/wt at detached 23338c7b, git apply --index on Dewey's build.patch, and a node_modules symlink to the canonical checkout. The manifest digest is 26d1fbdf23c2ae70fd9317fe6484e7bdf4339f45b59463e66123c100dbf1ac7d. Full suite and mutant logs remain under ~/filbert-scratch/r90-review/.
Reproduce the independent probes against a reconstructed candidate:
MOSAIC_REVIEW_ROOT="$HOME/filbert-scratch/r90-review/wt" TMPDIR="$HOME/filbert-scratch/tmp" DOCKER_HOST=unix:///nonexistent.sock node --test agents/filbert/work/queue-90/r1/probes.test.mjs
The carriage-return probe deliberately asserts the observed acceptance, documenting the minor schema boundary rather than pretending rejection passes. gate.py and mutants.py record the actual local run procedure and use the same scratch paths. Run mutants only after the other seats' scratch runs clear. Each mutant has its own process group; timeout kills that group, and the original source is restored in finally.
Scope: independent review only. No candidate edits, push, landing, Console restart or bus restart. Darkwing and Dewey received scratch-clear messages after the gate and mutants. No process had a cwd under this review's scratch directory at cleanup check.
Queue commit correction: the first attempt verified rev 826 but refused publication because Researcher committed 85aa676f during the guard run. No commit was published by that attempt. Retried the same review revision on the new HEAD; no verdict repost.