Untested: retain library notice after push when publication fails (#1793)

agents/bubba/work/queue-288/BUILD.md

@@ -179,3 +179,37 @@ existing plain Gitea-user pattern. The omission at mapping level is valid; human
 All tests above are newly authored by row288 and remain unrun; no changes to baseline/dependency
 tests. RED/GREEN and mutants await CLEAR. Proposed fixes are not claimed verified. The new host-only
 library write module imports the existing pure ID_PATTERN to match the broker's accepted instance ids.
+
+## 2026-10-23 mos-1520 ruling: post-push notice is required
+
+Correction to the E4 interpretation above: Mos rejected the known-gap treatment. The requirement
+stays: a pushed agent commit has the exact notice even if local publication then fails. This is not
+an outbox or retry. The writer now calls the broker's trusted synchronous onPushed callback as soon
+as push returns pushed:true, before publication. The callback records the exact library-write notice
+and action.allowed in the normal Console-store transaction. Publication failure still answers
+outcome-unknown. The notice's Revert can refuse library-revert-not-agent until sync makes that commit
+reachable from served; README now says that explicitly and removes the rejected gap description.
+
+The row's own real-push corruption test now pins the exact notice body with the pushed id, old
+served and outcome-unknown; after restoring readable state it pins Revert's refusal before sync and
+success after sync. The successful-write adapter fixture calls onPushed too, matching runtime's
+writer contract. No existing baseline/dependency test changed (mos-1520 explicitly authorizes this
+row's test correction without mos-1272).
+
+Residual Console-store failure: if notice insertion/routing/its event transaction fails, the broker
+calls a separate host log sink with {event:library-notice-store-failed,code:outcome-unknown,business,
+instance,op,commit}. It logs no args, path content, credential, raw SQL or exception output. Runtime's
+new library.log adapter writes this metadata to stderr. The caller gets outcome-unknown even if
+recording action.refused in that same broken store fails. A new real-push test uses temporary SQLite
+abort triggers on notice insertion and refusal evidence, checks remote advanced/served unchanged,
+no message, the exact external log and outcome-unknown. It does not claim a notice can be stored in
+a failed Console store. If the host log sink itself also fails, no durable log can be promised; the
+caller still receives outcome-unknown. The runtime log hunk is the required residual-failure wiring.
+
+Mutant added: move `options.onPushed?.({ project: context.project, path: change.path, commit });`
+from before `await publishLibraryWrite(...)` to immediately after that await inside the same try.
+Successful operations keep their notice, but the outcome-unknown publication path drops it. The
+C2-02 E4 real-push corruption test must fail on its exact notice assertion. Run on CLEAR and restore.
+
+No Node/tests/build/mutants run. Static git diff --check clean. Della's first284 head0ed4fbab9 is
+explicitly incomplete and not a finished dependency; waiting for her complete-head pin before tools.

packages/bus/src/broker.mjs

@@ -5231,13 +5231,21 @@ export class Broker {
       if (agent) {
         const op = verb === 'library.doc.delete' ? 'delete' : 'write';
         result = await this.#library.writeDoc({ ...context, ...args }, { ...writer, op,
-          beforePush: () => { this.#processingWork(); this.#libraryWriter(s, project); } });
-        try {
-          this.#store.transaction(() => {
-            this.#libraryWriteNotice(s, op, result);
-            this.#event(s, 'action.allowed', { action: 'library.write', class: 'within-role', project, path: result.path, commit: result.commit });
-          });
-        } catch { fail('outcome-unknown'); }
+          beforePush: () => { this.#processingWork(); this.#libraryWriter(s, project); },
+          onPushed: saved => {
+            try {
+              this.#store.transaction(() => {
+                this.#libraryWriteNotice(s, op, saved);
+                this.#event(s, 'action.allowed', { action: 'library.write', class: 'within-role', project, path: saved.path, commit: saved.commit });
+              });
+            } catch {
+              // A separate metadata-only sink survives a Console store failure. Never log args,
+              // file text, credentials or raw SQL/exception output.
+              try { this.#library.log?.({ event: 'library-notice-store-failed', code: 'outcome-unknown',
+                business: s.business, instance: s.role, op, commit: saved.commit }); } catch {}
+              fail('outcome-unknown');
+            }
+          } });
       } else if (verb === 'library.file.save') {
         this.#processingWork();
         result = await this.#library.saveFile({ ...context, path: args.path, base: args.base, content: args.content });
@@ -5255,7 +5263,11 @@ export class Broker {
       return result;
     } catch (error) {
       const Failure = this.#library?.LibraryError;
-      throw this.#refused(s, Failure && error instanceof Failure ? new BusError(error.code) : error, request);
+      const mapped = Failure && error instanceof Failure ? new BusError(error.code) : error;
+      const refused = this.#refused(s, mapped, request);
+      // Once a push succeeded the remote effect is uncertain to the caller even if the store
+      // cannot record refusal evidence. Do not replace that with an ordinary storage refusal.
+      throw mapped instanceof BusError && mapped.code === 'outcome-unknown' ? mapped : refused;
     }
   }
   // The eight task verbs reach the trusted S3 handler here. It runs outside any transaction, gets the

packages/bus/src/runtime.mjs

@@ -316,6 +316,7 @@ export async function startBroker({
       store,
       businesses,
       library: {
+        log: entry => process.stderr.write(`library: ${JSON.stringify(entry)}\n`),
         readFile: context => libraryModule.readLibraryFile({ ...context, dataRoot }),
         status: context => libraryModule.libraryStatus({ ...context, dataRoot }),
         sync: (context, { accept }) => processing.work(() => libraryModule.sync({ ...context, dataRoot }, { ...syncOptions(context.business), accept })),

packages/bus/tests/library-write.test.mjs

@@ -14,6 +14,7 @@ import { mappingEntry } from '../../library/tests/helpers.mjs';
 import { LibraryError } from '../../library/src/problems.mjs';
 import { grantDecision } from './host-fixtures.mjs';
 import { world as bareWorld } from '../../library/tests/write-fixture.mjs';
+import { sync } from '../../library/src/sync.mjs';
 import { SYNC_STATE_FILE, servedCommit } from '../../library/src/mirror.mjs';
 import { writeLibraryDoc, saveLibraryFile, revertLibraryCommit } from '../../library/src/write.mjs';
 import { git } from '../../library/tests/helpers.mjs';
@@ -29,10 +30,10 @@ function world(t, options = {}) {
   options.changeRole?.(roles.bean);
   const business = { id: 'acme', human: 'jason', vars: { 'bus.tester': true }, projects, roles,
     arbiters: { technical: 'chief', delivery: 'chief' }, definitions: { companion: {}, 'chief-of-staff': {}, proofreader: {} } };
-  const seen = [], held = new Set();
+  const seen = [], held = new Set(), logs = [];
   const result = { project: 'books', path: PATH, commit: NEXT };
-  const library = { LibraryError, readFile: async () => ({}), status: async () => ({}),
-    writeDoc: async (context, options) => { seen.push({ context, options }); options.beforePush(); return result; },
+  const library = { LibraryError, log: entry => logs.push(entry), readFile: async () => ({}), status: async () => ({}),
+    writeDoc: async (context, options) => { seen.push({ context, options }); options.beforePush(); options.onPushed(result); return result; },
     saveFile: async context => { seen.push({ context }); return result; },
     revert: async context => { seen.push({ context }); return { ...result, reverted: context.commit }; } };
   const broker = new Broker({ store, businesses: { acme: business }, library, giteaKeys: { held: (b, a) => held.has(a) } });
@@ -52,7 +53,7 @@ function world(t, options = {}) {
   };
   grant();
   const call = (who, verb, args = {}) => Promise.resolve().then(() => broker.request(caps[who], { verb, args }));
-  return { root, store, broker, caps, call, seen, held, business, grant, library };
+  return { root, store, broker, caps, call, seen, held, business, grant, library, logs };
 }
 const args = () => ({ universe: 'harbor', path: PATH, base: SHA, content: 'fixture\n' });
 
@@ -263,7 +264,7 @@ test('C2-02 F2/E6 runtime: human saves/reverts use editor.user; no login never u
 });
 
 
-test('C2-02 E4: post-push publication failure is outcome-unknown and has no stored notice', async t => {
+test('C2-02 E4: post-push publication failure stores the exact notice and returns outcome-unknown', async t => {
   const bare = await bareWorld(t), f = world(t, { projects: bare.context.business.projects });
   const state = join(bare.mirror, SYNC_STATE_FILE), original = readFileSync(state);
   const previous = await servedCommit(bare.mirror), head = bare.remoteHead();
@@ -279,6 +280,32 @@ test('C2-02 E4: post-push publication failure is outcome-unknown and has no stor
       { code: 'outcome-unknown' });
     assert.notEqual(bare.remoteHead(), head);
     assert.equal(git(bare.mirror, 'rev-parse', 'served'), previous);
-    assert.equal(f.store.get("SELECT count(*) n FROM messages WHERE from_role='bean'").n, 0);
+    const messages = f.store.all("SELECT body FROM messages WHERE from_role='bean' AND to_role='human'");
+    assert.deepEqual(messages.map(m => JSON.parse(m.body)), [
+      { notice: 'library-write', op: 'write', path: PATH, commit: bare.remoteHead() }]);
   } finally { writeFileSync(state, original); }
+  const commit = bare.remoteHead();
+  const human = { credential: { ...bare.credential, kind: 'human' }, command: bare.command };
+  await assert.rejects(revertLibraryCommit({ ...bare.context, commit }, human), { code: 'library-revert-not-agent' });
+  await sync(bare.context, { credential: bare.credential, command: bare.command });
+  assert.equal((await revertLibraryCommit({ ...bare.context, commit }, human)).reverted, commit);
+});
+
+
+test('C2-02 mos-1520: failed notice insert logs metadata and returns outcome-unknown even if refusal evidence fails', async t => {
+  const bare = await bareWorld(t), f = world(t, { projects: bare.context.business.projects });
+  const previous = await servedCommit(bare.mirror), head = bare.remoteHead();
+  f.library.writeDoc = (context, options) => writeLibraryDoc({ ...context, dataRoot: bare.dataRoot },
+    { ...options, credential: { ...options.credential, file: bare.file }, command: bare.command });
+  f.store.run(`CREATE TEMP TRIGGER fail_library_notice BEFORE INSERT ON messages
+    WHEN NEW.from_role='bean' BEGIN SELECT RAISE(ABORT, 'fixture store failure'); END;`);
+  f.store.run(`CREATE TEMP TRIGGER fail_refusal_log BEFORE INSERT ON events
+    WHEN NEW.kind='action.refused' BEGIN SELECT RAISE(ABORT, 'fixture evidence failure'); END;`);
+  await assert.rejects(f.call('bean', 'library.doc.write', { ...args(), base: git(bare.mirror, 'rev-parse', `served:${PATH}`) }),
+    { code: 'outcome-unknown' });
+  assert.notEqual(bare.remoteHead(), head);
+  assert.equal(await servedCommit(bare.mirror), previous);
+  assert.equal(f.store.get("SELECT count(*) n FROM messages WHERE from_role='bean'").n, 0);
+  assert.deepEqual(f.logs, [{ event: 'library-notice-store-failed', code: 'outcome-unknown', business: 'acme',
+    instance: 'bean', op: 'write', commit: bare.remoteHead() }]);
 });

packages/library/README.md

@@ -314,7 +314,12 @@ commit remains; callers must inspect status rather than retry blindly.
 The human push login is `editor.user` (optional in the mapping, required
 for save/revert), distinct from `user`, which names the fetch bot.
 An absent editor login refuses `library-human-missing`; no fallback uses
-the bot's login. If remote push succeeds but local publication fails,
-`outcome-unknown` is returned before a write notice is stored. That
-exceptional commit can therefore lack a Console notice; after sync it is
-still revertible by commit id. No notice outbox or replay is provided.
+the bot's login. Once an agent push succeeds, the broker stores the exact
+write notice with that pushed commit id before local publication. If
+publication then fails, the agent receives `outcome-unknown` and the
+notice remains. Revert can refuse `library-revert-not-agent` until a sync
+makes the commit reachable from served. No notice outbox or retry is
+needed. If the Console store itself refuses the notice insert, the caller
+still receives `outcome-unknown` and a separate metadata-only host log
+records `library-notice-store-failed` with the business, instance, operation
+and pushed commit id; it contains no file text or credential.

packages/library/src/write.mjs

@@ -164,6 +164,8 @@ async function write(context, options, human, revert = false) {
         if (!result.pushed) { tip = result.tip; continue; }
         pushed = true;
         try {
+          // The broker records the pushed commit even if publication fails next (mos-1520).
+          options.onPushed?.({ project: context.project, path: change.path, commit });
           await publishLibraryWrite(mirror, { mapping, commit, previous: served, readSyncState: lock.readSyncState, now: options.now });
         } catch { fail('outcome-unknown'); }
         return { project: context.project, path: change.path, ...(revert ? { reverted: change.reverted } : {}), commit };