REQUEST CHANGES reviewer-of-record [W-jarvis:reviewer] head 31a5973808
Verified at exact head 31a59738089f0784428833fc5a0192c6c7c43261; CI reports green for PR pipeline 1764, and apps/gateway/src/commands/command-authorization.service.ts is byte-identical to origin/main (hash a9f829e7ecec721c6c585fe0da56fb5d6a6441e9). The Optional import is present in agent.service.ts, so that is not a defect.
Blockers:
The required server-derived scope proof is not covered by the new tests. memory-tools.test.ts calls createMemoryTools(...) directly with a pre-built { plugin, scope }, so it bypasses the production AgentService.createSession -> buildToolsForSandbox -> createMemoryTools path where { tenantId, ownerId, sessionId } is supposed to be derived. This would still pass if the production call site stopped deriving the right scope.
The consumer tests do not assert cross-tenant / cross-owner isolation or denial. There is no divergent authenticated owner/tenant case proving a foreign actor cannot reuse a session and reach another tenant/owner's operator-memory scope before the plugin is called. Existing package-level plugin tests prove scoped key construction, but not that the gateway/AgentService consumer binds and enforces the server-derived scope.
Positive findings: the production code does wire OPERATOR_MEMORY_PLUGIN into AgentService and routes memory_search / memory_save_insight through the plugin when configured; adapter/namespace come from MOSAIC_OPERATOR_MEMORY_INSTANCE_ID and MOSAIC_OPERATOR_MEMORY_NAMESPACE; no live creds or hardcoded Tess identity were found.
Marker: ROR-739-REQUEST-CHANGES-31a59738
REQUEST CHANGES reviewer-of-record [W-jarvis:reviewer] head 31a59738089f0784428833fc5a0192c6c7c43261
Verified at exact head `31a59738089f0784428833fc5a0192c6c7c43261`; CI reports green for PR pipeline `1764`, and `apps/gateway/src/commands/command-authorization.service.ts` is byte-identical to `origin/main` (hash `a9f829e7ecec721c6c585fe0da56fb5d6a6441e9`). The `Optional` import is present in `agent.service.ts`, so that is not a defect.
Blockers:
- The required server-derived scope proof is not covered by the new tests. `memory-tools.test.ts` calls `createMemoryTools(...)` directly with a pre-built `{ plugin, scope }`, so it bypasses the production `AgentService.createSession -> buildToolsForSandbox -> createMemoryTools` path where `{ tenantId, ownerId, sessionId }` is supposed to be derived. This would still pass if the production call site stopped deriving the right scope.
- The consumer tests do not assert cross-tenant / cross-owner isolation or denial. There is no divergent authenticated owner/tenant case proving a foreign actor cannot reuse a session and reach another tenant/owner's operator-memory scope before the plugin is called. Existing package-level plugin tests prove scoped key construction, but not that the gateway/AgentService consumer binds and enforces the server-derived scope.
Positive findings: the production code does wire `OPERATOR_MEMORY_PLUGIN` into `AgentService` and routes `memory_search` / `memory_save_insight` through the plugin when configured; adapter/namespace come from `MOSAIC_OPERATOR_MEMORY_INSTANCE_ID` and `MOSAIC_OPERATOR_MEMORY_NAMESPACE`; no live creds or hardcoded Tess identity were found.
Marker: ROR-739-REQUEST-CHANGES-31a59738
VERIFIED APPROVE reviewer-of-record [W-jarvis:reviewer] head c26b3b7752
Findings: CI pipeline 1765 is green at the exact head, and apps/gateway/src/commands/command-authorization.service.ts remains byte-identical to origin/main (hash a9f829e7ecec721c6c585fe0da56fb5d6a6441e9). The Optional import is present; no live creds or hardcoded Tess identity were found.
The prior blockers are closed: agent-service-ownership.test.ts now exercises the production createSession -> buildToolsForSandbox path and asserts the derived { tenantId, ownerId, sessionId } scope, while the foreign-scope reuse test rejects before tool construction and before any plugin search/capture call. Production wiring is reachable: MemoryModule configures createOperatorMemoryPlugin only from MOSAIC_OPERATOR_MEMORY_INSTANCE_ID / MOSAIC_OPERATOR_MEMORY_NAMESPACE, AgentService injects it, derives scope from session owner/tenant/session id, and memory_search / memory_save_insight route through the plugin when configured.
Marker: ROR-739-APPROVE-c26b3b77
VERIFIED APPROVE reviewer-of-record [W-jarvis:reviewer] head c26b3b775279575276c6ebe8955a9146bfc61413
Findings: CI pipeline `1765` is green at the exact head, and `apps/gateway/src/commands/command-authorization.service.ts` remains byte-identical to `origin/main` (hash `a9f829e7ecec721c6c585fe0da56fb5d6a6441e9`). The `Optional` import is present; no live creds or hardcoded Tess identity were found.
The prior blockers are closed: `agent-service-ownership.test.ts` now exercises the production `createSession -> buildToolsForSandbox` path and asserts the derived `{ tenantId, ownerId, sessionId }` scope, while the foreign-scope reuse test rejects before tool construction and before any plugin `search`/`capture` call. Production wiring is reachable: `MemoryModule` configures `createOperatorMemoryPlugin` only from `MOSAIC_OPERATOR_MEMORY_INSTANCE_ID` / `MOSAIC_OPERATOR_MEMORY_NAMESPACE`, `AgentService` injects it, derives scope from session owner/tenant/session id, and `memory_search` / `memory_save_insight` route through the plugin when configured.
Marker: ROR-739-APPROVE-c26b3b77
Blocking a user prevents them from interacting with repositories, such as opening or commenting on pull requests or issues. Learn more about blocking a user.
Summary
Verification
TURBO_FORCE=true pnpm typecheckTURBO_FORCE=true pnpm lintTURBO_FORCE=true pnpm format:checkTURBO_FORCE=true pnpm testPart of TESS-M4-W / #710.
REQUEST CHANGES reviewer-of-record [W-jarvis:reviewer] head
31a5973808Verified at exact head
31a59738089f0784428833fc5a0192c6c7c43261; CI reports green for PR pipeline1764, andapps/gateway/src/commands/command-authorization.service.tsis byte-identical toorigin/main(hasha9f829e7ecec721c6c585fe0da56fb5d6a6441e9). TheOptionalimport is present inagent.service.ts, so that is not a defect.Blockers:
memory-tools.test.tscallscreateMemoryTools(...)directly with a pre-built{ plugin, scope }, so it bypasses the productionAgentService.createSession -> buildToolsForSandbox -> createMemoryToolspath where{ tenantId, ownerId, sessionId }is supposed to be derived. This would still pass if the production call site stopped deriving the right scope.Positive findings: the production code does wire
OPERATOR_MEMORY_PLUGINintoAgentServiceand routesmemory_search/memory_save_insightthrough the plugin when configured; adapter/namespace come fromMOSAIC_OPERATOR_MEMORY_INSTANCE_IDandMOSAIC_OPERATOR_MEMORY_NAMESPACE; no live creds or hardcoded Tess identity were found.Marker: ROR-739-REQUEST-CHANGES-31a59738
VERIFIED APPROVE reviewer-of-record [W-jarvis:reviewer] head
c26b3b7752Findings: CI pipeline
1765is green at the exact head, andapps/gateway/src/commands/command-authorization.service.tsremains byte-identical toorigin/main(hasha9f829e7ecec721c6c585fe0da56fb5d6a6441e9). TheOptionalimport is present; no live creds or hardcoded Tess identity were found.The prior blockers are closed:
agent-service-ownership.test.tsnow exercises the productioncreateSession -> buildToolsForSandboxpath and asserts the derived{ tenantId, ownerId, sessionId }scope, while the foreign-scope reuse test rejects before tool construction and before any pluginsearch/capturecall. Production wiring is reachable:MemoryModuleconfigurescreateOperatorMemoryPluginonly fromMOSAIC_OPERATOR_MEMORY_INSTANCE_ID/MOSAIC_OPERATOR_MEMORY_NAMESPACE,AgentServiceinjects it, derives scope from session owner/tenant/session id, andmemory_search/memory_save_insightroute through the plugin when configured.Marker: ROR-739-APPROVE-c26b3b77