Commits agents/codex/work/queue-333/r1-repair/ (packet, receipts, review and author files) and the append-only BUILD-LOG.md and docs/SESSIONS.md entries. The packet INDEX.json sha256 is 3eb9b8d10445aa328be3b854385e4792dda2c5712b19d443d485d1b00a18d0f8 and source-tests.patch is a78bc385801b64be270fb9d6e84672c443738a5fce8eb68f7d2a01359a57a770; the product commit for these bytes is2627321f. Two packet tarballs are deliberately not committed: packet/baseline-input-bytes.tar.gz and packet/fixed-input-bytes.tar.gz. The secret check reported a -----BEGIN marker in each (members packages/bus/src/credentials.mjs and packages/discord/src/tools.mjs, byte-identical to503b91e56and with no PEM body). They stay untracked until the lead rules on them.
7.8 KiB
P5 independent R1 response
Starting candidate: 503b91e561.
Original base:09a847edaa25b609bac7728ff83f224708a29399.
Review: REVIEW-R1.md, copied without edits; SHA2567c95672a30c0d5c39189c7c7d610ada89cd539dcb9413617071fbb81200fd008.
All findings preserved as CHANGES until fixes have actual RED/GREEN evidence.
Source verification:
- Confirmed unconditional client callback permits queue reads after ModelKeys sentinel refusal.
- Confirmed regex-only key classification changes valid legacy account limits and chief resets; host lookup also runs for zero checks. Accepted scope requires daily model quotas, not cumulative model namespace takeover. Repair will use the validated daily shape consistently and drop the invented cumulative model interpretation.
- Confirmed startup awaits proxyUsage.tick and may wait the existing management-client timeout for optional telemetry. Repair will supervise first poll in background with unchanged deadlines/singleflight/close.
Original candidate, runner, raw receipts and source pins remain unchanged. R1 repair evidence is separate in this directory. No independent approval/self-review, heavy/full/browser gate or deployment authority claimed.
Priority evidence correction (Mos1971): command text nice -n19 is insufficient on this workstation (ananicy node16/bash-4). Earlier R1 receipts01–06 are behavior observations with priority unverified; no strict19 acceptance claim attaches to them. New bounded checks use OWN-process native setPriority(0,19) plus readback before modules and at beforeExit/exit, and wrapper native getPriority(child.pid) before/after the direct child. A setup failure, any observed drift or incomplete capture returns78 UNVERIFIED/STOP; it is never treated as intended RED or GREEN. No scheduler/daemon mutation, repeated renice, deadline change or retry around a priority refusal is authorized.
Native priority STOP (receipt07)
Actual trace07-priority-native.jsonl: wrapper PID2643577 before=19, after=16; test PID2643590 before-modules=19, after-modules=16, exit=16. Six behavior assertions completed, but the test runner reports a file failure because priority guard changed exit status. This is UNVERIFIED/STOP exit78, not intended RED and not GREEN. Node --test forwarded --import to its test subprocess, so the direct test-runner parent did not execute that preload: the requested direct-child handshake/capture is also incomplete. No priority or provenance proof is inferred from command text or the six assertions. No further local test runs are authorized after this observed drift; no scheduler mutation or retry was attempted. Admitted runner verification is required. Source/regression preparation continues under the user's explicit fallback mandate.
Finding 1 source response / priority-unverified behavior observations
Added ModelKeys.verifyIdentity(), serialized by the existing controller. It requires the existing ready state, performs a fresh sentinel-only management-list check, never issues an agent credential, never reconciles, and honors sticky proxy-open refusal. Collector now awaits client acquisition; the P5 runtime usage callback verifies that identity before returning its management client. Boot refusal and later failure retain the human surface, unavailable telemetry and value-free receipt, with zero queue drain. Matching sentinel requires no issued agent key.
Receipts01/02: actual behavior REDs under nice-relative priority, later reclassified priority-UNVERIFIED. Boot observed queue1 vs expected0; later refusal queue2 vs expected1; changed-listener predrain control likewise failed. Receipt03 recorded12/12 behavior passes after the fix (identity, proxy collector, native quota runtime files), also priority-UNVERIFIED. These are observations only, not strict19 acceptance. Current identity controls now await the initial poll's actual receipt to preserve the same assertions after the nonblocking startup change; current bytes have not run.
Finding 2 source response / priority-unverified behavior observations
A shared pure isDailyModelQuota() validates key ID and the full daily {limit,since,reset,timeZone} leaf. Business schema, daily and cumulative checks, host metadata lookup and both old/new organization fences use it. Plain {limit,since} keys stay legacy account leaves regardless of twelve-hex spelling; token-limit matches/reports account only. Zero loaded checks returns before any model metadata lookup. Daily model changes, plain→daily, daily→plain/removal and reset remain human-only; plain legacy chief resets remain permitted. The invented cumulative model-key interpretation is removed, not moved into a new namespace.
Receipts04/05 captured actual legacy failures (lookup refusals, wrong account matching, empty checks, chief reset) under nice-relative priority. Receipt04 also contained a new fixture missing-system error; receipt05 corrects the fixture and demonstrates the actual chief-reset refusal. Receipt06 recorded6/6 behavior passes after source repair, priority-UNVERIFIED. Receipt07 later observed strict-priority drift and STOP. Candidate503-specific cumulative-model test fixtures are retargeted to accepted daily leaves with every enforcement assertion retained; the appended token-limit test now asserts legacy account semantics. Pre-P5/base assertions and deadlines remain unchanged. No post-STOP execution is claimed.
Finding 3 source response / execution pending
Prepared p5-background.test.mjs with a queue response held open, explicit queue-arrival/event-loop barriers (no sleeps or racing deadlines), native readiness/control/key-preflight/usage/limit work while held, scheduled singleflight, success/failure release, and cleanup at the original5000ms management deadline using virtual timers. First guard is that f.bus is nonnull while the queue is still held; original503 awaits that held response and should fail this behavior assertion. These controls have NOT RUN locally, not RED/GREEN evidence.
Saved exact immediately-pre-fix runtime bytes in baselines/runtime-before-background-fix.mjs. Fixed runtime uses one supervised usageTick function for the initial call and later interval. The first call is background; the same collector singleflight and original close/pending/client deadline apply. Only P5 usage wiring/tick hunks changed; no launcher/session/harness/business route edits. Admitted runner must establish genuine priority-verified RED then GREEN on the pinned baseline/fixed overlays before any new product commit.
Static packet handoff — no product commit
Per latest owner direction, HEAD remains original503 and all repairs stay UNCOMMITTED. No local tests or Node product execution followed receipt07 STOP, including no syntax-check substitute. New background controls and final current source bytes are pending execution. The packet contains the complete source/test diff from503 (including untracked controls/helper), controls-only baseline overlay, baseline→fixed remainder, exact baseline/fixed bytes with SHA256/size/Gitblob IDs, static module/dependency edges and full28-file list. Its input map is explicitly STATIC, not a fresh consumed-source observation. Genuine strict19 baseline RED/fixed GREEN and actual consumed-source capture must come from the admitted runner before any product commit. The parent may request new read-onlyR2 on these exact bytes before execution; this author issues no independent/self-review verdict.
Gate entry/root and root+actual-testchild native preexec/readback requirements are in GATE-ENTRY.md. Existing diagnostic drivers are preserved only as failed/incomplete priority evidence and are not authorized for retry. Dedicated1014 admission/profile and private gate-tool entry remain pending with the parent. Cleanup from every actual test run used private mktemp EXIT/test fixture cleanup. No scheduler, live proxy/account/credential/provider, P3 launcher/session/harness/business-route, queue, remote or landing state was changed.