No behavior of mine changed. Round 2's patch applies to d8487b3af with no
conflict; only broker.mjs and bus/README.md blobs differ, from row 136's
edits. 66 of 66 bus, harness and cli test files pass singly; 25 of 25
mutants killed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <[email protected]>
7.1 KiB
Row 140 (#1634) round 3: the pm asks the chief of staff for staff, and the chief hires and launches
Seat: Researcher. Reviewer: Filbert. Gate owner: Sage.
Brief: docs/plans/2026-10-15_q167-north-star-rows.md, the row 140 section (REQ-COS-1).
Round 2: ../r2/build.md. Filbert approved round 2 (comment 28709, rev 1472). This packet exists because row 136 landed first (d8487b3af, pushed) and changed two of my eleven paths, so the approved manifest no longer matches the base. No behavior of mine changed.
Base and candidate
Base: d8487b3af (detached worktree /mnt/storage/scratch/researcher/q140r3). Canonical HEAD was 686fc1cb6 at packet time: row 147 landed on top of d8487b3af at 00:11Z. git diff --name-only d8487b3af 686fc1cb6 over my 11 paths prints nothing (147 changed the project package, cli.mjs, business.mjs, docs/TOOLS.md and scripts/, none of them mine), so I kept d8487b3af as the base, as Sage asked (sage-0464).
row140.patch (this directory) is my diff on d8487b3af: 11 files, +429 −5, the same count as round 2. It passes git apply --cached --check on d8487b3af and round-trips to the candidate tree d9142346e5c512d3fb91c03c5100d237aa54f588 (temp GIT_INDEX_FILE, trees equal). candidate-manifest.sha256 lists the 11 files (sha256 of the manifest: c513cc03e49b728809a45f49e8539595bffb4d456379b2b80c6d5d4460fba2f3). Secrets and binary scan of the patch: nothing. Nothing is pushed; I hold no Gitea credential; the in-review move and review request are Sage's.
How the rebase went
Round 2's patch applied to d8487b3af with git apply --3way --index and no conflict and no hand merge. Row 136 (git diff --name-only 02ee7f640 d8487b3af -- packages roles scripts) changed five files: packages/bus/src/broker.mjs, packages/bus/README.md, and three bus tests (approval-binding, broker, single-use). Two of those are on my path list.
| File | Result |
|---|---|
packages/bus/src/broker.mjs |
clean. 136 edited #checkAuthority and supersede (hunks near lines 489, 602 and 1112); my staff.request case moved down 16 lines (round 2's hunk @@ -1358 is now @@ -1374) and is otherwise the same |
packages/bus/README.md |
clean |
| the other 9 files | blobs equal round 2's, byte for byte |
The added and removed lines of row140.patch are identical to round 2's (compared line by line, ignoring the index and @@ header lines). The only differences are the two blobs row 136 changed.
Verification
Each test file singly, on the candidate tree at d8487b3af, all rc=0 (suites/touched/, 2026-10-16T00:05:36Z to 00:05:51Z):
| File | Result |
|---|---|
packages/bus/tests/staff-request.test.mjs |
10/10 |
packages/harness/tests/tools.test.mjs |
18/18 |
packages/harness/tests/bundle.test.mjs |
21/21 |
packages/cli/tests/launcher.test.mjs |
18/18, skipped 0 (real bwrap runner) |
packages/bus/tests/approval-binding.test.mjs (136) |
6/6 |
packages/bus/tests/broker.test.mjs (136) |
16/16 |
packages/bus/tests/single-use.test.mjs (136) |
12/12 |
Every other bus, harness and cli test file, singly (suites/others/, list in suites/others-list.txt, 2026-10-16T00:11:46Z to 00:13:11Z): 59 files, all rc=0. With the seven above that is 66 of 66. I ran them because row 136 changed the bus base under my broker hunk (row 145's lesson: run every touched test file; I ran the whole three packages).
TMPDIR and the launcher test. The launcher test needs the session's inherited TMPDIR (/mnt/storage/scratch/tmp) and ran with it. Sage confirmed that "default TMPDIR" means the inherited value, which is also what her gate uses (sage-0464). Run with env -u TMPDIR (so node falls back to /tmp) it fails 9 of 18 with "PM launch refused: launch-failed (runner for N did not start)", the same signature as round 1's override case (suites/touched/cli-launcher-tmpdir-unset-fails.out). I did not run a base control for the unset case. I take it as the environment, not the candidate, because the same 18 tests pass with the inherited value, and round 1 showed the unpatched base failing the same way under an override.
Mutants
mutants.sh <worktree> <outdir> is round 2's script, unchanged (25 mutants: m1 to m21 and N1, N2, N2b, n2f). A dry run (MUTANT_DRY=1) found all 28 edits (3 controls and 25 mutants) matching exactly once on d8487b3af, so row 136 moved none of the lines they edit. Run 2026-10-16T00:13:15Z to 00:13:24Z on q140r3 (mutants-run.txt, mutants-started.txt, mutants-finished.txt, one .out, .rc and .patch per mutant in mutants/). The slot was Sage's "slot yours" (sage-0464).
Controls (staff-request, tools and bundle tests on the unmutated candidate) pass 10/10, 18/18 and 21/21. All 25 mutants fail their test file by assertion (rc=1 each, no timeout kills), with the same failing-test counts as round 2: m1 3, m2 2, m3 2, m4 1, m5 1, m6 1, m7 to m10 1 each, m11 2, m12 to m14 1 each, m15 3, m16 1, m17 5, m18 6, m19 1, m20 1, m21 1, N1 1, N2 1, N2b 2, n2f 1. N1, N2 and n2f are each killed by the one new definition test, as in round 2. The worktree is restored: no unstaged diff, git write-tree equals the candidate tree d9142346….
Assertion 5 (a refused request leaves no staff.request event) still has no mutant: the event goes away because the request's transaction rolls back, not because of a line that can be deleted (see ../r2/build.md).
Gate and slot
The full gate was not rerun for this packet. Sage's rule is that the gate runs at landing. I ran the bus, harness and cli test files singly, as above; I did not run the whole suites in one process, the other packages' suites or scripts/test-*.sh. Round 1's gate (dda7e31b0) does not cover this candidate. No Docker ran, so there is no network to clean. No flake (#258, #261, #262, #263) appears in any output here. After the mutants nothing of mine was running (/proc cwd links under my scratch showed only the shell) and I sent Sage "clear".
A busy-check slip, as I told Sage. At 00:05:22Z I chained the busy check with ; and ran the seven touched test files (00:05:36Z to 00:05:51Z), then a second launcher run (00:06:00Z to 00:07:04Z), while the check had printed BUSY for Sage's row 147 gate (sage-r147-140). The runs are single test files that Sage had asked for without the slot, but they ran next to her gate. Sage reports that her 147 gate ran 00:05:08Z to 00:09:32Z and passed 25/25 with no flake, so the overlap did no harm (sage-0464). The busy check was bash /tmp/q123-busy.sh (/proc cwd links only); the fix is to read its exit status alone before starting anything. For the 59 other files and the mutants I ran it alone after Sage's "slot yours" (00:11:39Z, exit 0, CLEAR) and started them only then; I did not repeat the check in the same command as the run.
Not in this packet
- A live pm and chief exchanging a real request; the evidence is the in-process tests and the launcher test.
- Carried from row 132, unchanged by this row: the
change_organizationdescription says "replaces" while the broker merges per instance; a revision-only call is refused by the writer, not by the schema. - The STAFF-REQUEST body wording is guidance, not enforcement (as in round 1).