24 lines
3.6 KiB
Markdown
24 lines
3.6 KiB
Markdown
# GATE7-FINAL-FILBERT-1 — verdict
|
||
|
||
Reviewer: Filbert (independent). Author of the draft edits: Darkwing; investigation author: Rocko (PI-REFRESH-ROCKO-1). Frozen snapshot `/tmp/gate7-final-znmnih6v` at manifest SHA-256 `ea9c539d4ca030278440332fe3f1291e2494e50b475f4a2c46b35b39c290b628`, pin `224147ec…`; all four hashes verified before and after review; snapshot unchanged. Read-only: no live pi commands, no package fetches, no private reads.
|
||
|
||
## Verdict: APPROVED
|
||
|
||
Committing exactly these four reviewed files is approved. This closes gate 7 as documentation; it authorizes no implementation, package change, or credential operation.
|
||
|
||
## Findings by assigned check
|
||
|
||
1. **Draft deltas confined.** Against pin `224147ec…`, the registry draft changes only: the mechanics-section sentence resolving the refresh trigger via PI-REFRESH-ROCKO-1 with owner approval; the refresh-driver paragraph inside the verification/suites bullet list; gate 7 moving PARTIALLY RESOLVED → RESOLVED (owner, 2026-09-10, mechanism (a)); and the remaining-open-item text. Nothing else moved.
|
||
|
||
2. **Investigation consistent, cited, and corroborated.** The 0.85.1 claims are internally consistent (shasum `4cd00f65…` appears identically in three places; the `refresh: false` function default vs `refresh: !noRefresh` CLI wiring contradiction is explicitly reconciled; the two independent 5-minute layers — stored-value safety margin and read-time validity window — are explained coherently; the browser/PKCE login flow is correctly separated from the POST-only refresh). Citations name concrete files and unique anchors. Because the investigation itself establishes the capability as pre-existing since 0.83.0/0.84.1, I corroborated read-only against this repository's pinned 0.84.4 install: the same command set (`check`/`print-api-key`/`print-bearer-token`/`--no-refresh`), the verbatim help sentence, the `0o600`/`proper-lockfile`/read-only-refusal anchors in `auth-storage.js`, the refresh timeout constant, and the Anthropic token URL all exist locally as described. One claim the investigation supports only by inference — that `pi auth check` produces no credential output — is corroborated by the pinned package's own help text: "`--credentials` emits the credential," i.e. only on explicit opt-in. Limit recorded honestly: I could not re-derive the 0.85.1-specific evidence (no fetches permitted); the tarball identity rests on the investigation's recorded npm outputs, and my corroboration covers the shared pre-existing behavior.
|
||
|
||
3. **Mechanism (a) matches the findings.** The owner-selected `pi auth check --provider <p>` is exactly the entry point the investigation verifies as noninteractive, refresh-if-expiring (5-minute default window), no browser/TTY, with the in-place locked `auth.json` rewrite; `print-*` exclusion matches their documented credential-export semantics.
|
||
|
||
4. **No gate silently moved.** Gates 1–6 and 8–10 read RESOLVED at the pin and are unchanged; only gate 7 changed, per the owner's Q15(a) ruling. The new remaining-open text ("none — all gates resolved; implementation needs a separately chartered increment") states the boundary correctly and infers no implementation authority.
|
||
|
||
5. **No credential material or new identifiers.** The candidates contain no secrets; the investigation records only a public token URL, package digests, and code anchors. The UUID hits in SESSIONS.md are baseline published history; the added registration line carries none.
|
||
|
||
## Condition
|
||
|
||
Commit exactly the four reviewed units at manifest `ea9c539d…`. Any byte change, including any later 0.85.1 pin bump or refresh-service work, requires its own chartered and reviewed increment.
|