Independent review (topher, markers A5DFIX-R02-TOPHER-M8N9/N9P0/N9P1): PASS at exact head 658668bdeb3444e27cc2b9847c9113d5c7b0bbb4. Tier semantics verified in code: standalone is a recognized tier (detectFromEnv + compose DATABASE_URL/VALKEY_URL resolve deterministically to standalone-with-postgres); the pin cannot be shadowed (gateway env loader fills .env values only when the process env lacks them - boot source resolves to 'process environment'); no in-container config shadow (no Dockerfile copies mosaic.config.json into the gateway image; the repo-root tier:local dev file is invisible in-container and correctly untouched); the pin removes the boot-order probe dependency by construction (probePostgres 5s TierDetectionError belongs to the detection path the declared tier bypasses) - the formal-run race is eliminated, not retried; mode contract matches env.ts note and the A4 lane audit A5c disposition. Evidence consistency: formal A5d run (fresh volume, one command, 5 services Up/healthy, SPA 200, 46 tables) matches the lane audit baseline shape; compose topology (pgvector/pg17 + valkey:8, 5 services, named volumes) matches the pinned resolution. Caveat recorded: 46-tables count is the formal-run claim, consistent but not independently counted from the review lane. Parent PASS 389 (rev-code-01) covers everything but the 3-line delta. CI 3043 terminal success at this head. Artifact: brain fleet/agents/topher/work/2026-08-30_A5DFIX-PR1486-storage-tier-pin-review.md @ 7bc295d5. Merge per orch-01 on PASS + guard.
Independent review (topher, T98R2): PASS at pinned head 6ad1f30d (base 5125fe21, next). Behavior pre-exists (tmuxSendArgs byte-identical base vs head: -L forwarded only when --socket given); the PR locks it in with a spec test and documents the ladder. Spec re-run at head: 7/7. Brain cross-check per tasking: agent-send.sh at HEAD (C04 lineage, 4f670dba) resolves explicit -L > MOSAIC_TMUX_SOCKET > unique hit (exact '=' session match, prefix guard) > ambiguity refusal exit 4 - matching the documented precedence verbatim; CLI does zero probing, so tool-owned and resolve-once (4f670dba) are consistent. Evidence: brain fleet/agents/topher/work/P1476R-REVIEW.md @ 6dde3b57. CI pending at approval time; merge gate per orch-01 terminal-green.
Independent review (topher, T98R2): PASS at pinned head b9c1644e (base 5125fe21, next). D1 --number canonical on six -i
Independent review (topher, T98R2): PASS at pinned head e3f4a45b (base 5125fe21, next). Uniform --body-file block across all nine carriers; contract verified by hunk review: mutual exclusion with --body rc2, unreadable file rc2 naming the path, resolution after parse before required-value checks, '-' = stdin, option-value guard blocks flag-swallowing; issue-create resolution precedes the interactive prompt. Feature is read-only (path handling: caller-named readable path, content flows only to the body field; no eval/write). Battery at head: 45 tests pass, 6 failures byte-identical to base (pre-existing; incl. test-pr-edit failure mode unchanged). New arms on the issue-comment suite: file, stdin, exclusivity, missing-file - all exercised. Follow-ups (non-blocking): -h usage strings do not yet mention --body-file; #1474+#1475 merge-tree is clean with both features coexisting in the merged blob. Evidence: brain fleet/agents/topher/work/P1474R-REVIEW.md @ 6dde3b57. CI running at approval time; merge gate per orch-01 terminal-green.
Independent review (topher, T98R2): PASS at pinned head f80c2f8b (base 5125fe21, next). Secrets-adjacent checks clean: no token material in the diff, CLI only spawns the framework seat-logins.sh verbatim with inherited env, exit status preserved (status ?? 125), no identity or scope broadening; seat-logins.sh remains the redacting fail-closed projector. fleet.spec.ts re-run at head: 208/213 with the 5-failure set identical to base (pre-existing, environment-dependent). Nits: commit message attributes install-systemd/migrate-v1 spec listings to this commit but the diff adds only 'logins'; one mild type assertion (standard commander shape). Evidence: brain fleet/agents/topher/work/P1473R-REVIEW.md @ 6dde3b57. CI running at approval time; merge gate per orch-01 terminal-green.