Review round 1 on 4048e0f60 found two defects.
Startup recovery ran unconditionally. A continuation retry now refuses
while processing is halted, so a broker restart with a waiting
continuation failed with processing-halted. Startup recovery now waits
while processing is halted or invalid, as the periodic pass does;
processing.resume schedules it again.
#continuationStarting matched any launch without an end, so an older
launch whose end was lost (#1851) hid every later run's end. Only the
target's latest lifecycle event counts now.
Both regression tests fail on 4048e0f60 and pass here.
Expose the parent message class on agent delivery so the runner can stop automatic replies to answers while preserving requests and ordinary relays. Scope continuation retry versions to the target, suppress notices during processing halts and unclaimed launches, and clarify the instance-running refusal.
The bus suite excludes project-files.test.mjs because its 1 MiB socket test timed out on both the candidate and the untouched 1186cf7b1 base.
The oversize and unresolved ask-PM notices were appended without
checking the room left by the lead, so a lead with 0-130 bytes left
pushed a 972-task request past exec capacity (E2BIG at 131,086).
quoteBlock now returns at most max(room, 0): the full notice, the
47-byte short line, or nothing. Tests sweep rooms -3..160 for both
steps and run a 972-task lifecycle that must still exec.
BUILD-LOG appends a correction to the r4 limits (40,774 / 88,234).
Jason's owner report 2026-11-06: no way to archive or delete projects.
Archive is the reversible half; delete stays out of scope because project
and run records are write-once evidence.
- project.archive / project.unarchive: human-only (project.create's gate
minus the tester carve-out; tester, user and agent refused). State is the
latest row of a new append-only project_archives journal (3s->3t, additive;
the rows are the audit trail), so projects itself never changes and nothing
is deleted. Repeats refuse project-already-archived / project-not-archived.
- project.list hides archived projects until {includeArchived:true}, which
flags each with archived:true; a user still lists granted projects only.
- While archived, thread.create, thread.send, room.open and room.send refuse
project-archived; every existing record stays readable and unarchive
restores everything.
- Console: new public/project-archive.js (+css) and project-archive-http.mjs
routes (chatHTTP's write fence); chat.js gains two one-line hooks,
index.html one script and one link tag; styling only through the shell's
.project-archive-control / .project-archived-filter hooks.
- CLI: mosaic project archive|unarchive <name-or-id> and list --archived.
- stack-release COUNTED/LISTED gain project_archives (schema order); schema
step-count pins and migration fixtures updated for 3t.
bus 1601/1601 (Node 24; Node 26 has the pre-existing project-file socket
stall), webui 582/582, plugins 132/132, cli 1191/1194 (two pre-existing
load flakes of the row253 C4 and land_work families; both pass isolated and
the base commit's full suite fails four of the same family).
The r2 review found that counting raw bytes let JSON and control
escaping grow one quote six-fold, so the runner's MOSAIC_REQUEST
exceeded the exec string limit (E2BIG). The continuation renderer now
applies the 16384-byte budget to encoded title and text bytes, cutting
on whole code points. Adds an execution-boundary regression.
Gate on the merged tree: business 307/0, bus 1596 pass with one
pre-existing hang (project-files.test.mjs, same on relay base 2f1cef4c1),
harness 243/1 on the row 66 unslop test, which also fails 1 in 3 runs
on the relay base (timing flake, pre-existing).
D3: coder/reviewer sandboxes cannot read the product records repo and
list_requirements stays PM/CTO-only (row 90, #1584). The bus now quotes
the task-cited approved requirement texts (exact text, id, title, citing
task refs, snapshot id, product key, records commit) into the
implementation and review continuations, resolved host-side through the
same catalog resolver behind the scoped requirements verb, never from
model input. Quotes are bounded at 16384 bytes and framed as quoted
data; an unresolvable or revoked snapshot degrades to an ask-PM line
without blocking the task. No role, tool or schema widened; one duty
note each in roles/coder.md and roles/reviewer.md.
Review M1 on 62bece4a9: a failed notice insert or route threw past
#refused, replacing request-evidence-required and skipping its audit.
The notice is now best-effort; its transaction still rolls back whole.
Tests: insert and route failures keep code, audit and lifecycle; retry
publishes once. Both red on 62bece4a9.
Wake the existing PM when validated evidence arrives after its first notice,
including overlapping recovery across retained request history. Preserve durable
deduplication and current authority checks.
Put the exact verification record and verdict contract in the first scoped
review request. Carry linked owner-request provenance into runner headers and
expose the existing requirement-record example to planning tools.
Implementation: Codex Terra initial repair; Codex Sol lead R1 correction,
regressions and developer documentation. Independent R2 APPROVE, 115 focused
checks. Matching final local coverage proves 4,333 distinct required cases;
the intentional FEDR7 skip is covered by its standard scratch wrapper.
Reviewed patch: 18ff6455e7ab69bc55cef88845f86189ed5f67b114ad7996f714a35ca1a90239
Source manifest: 6daf0668101bbad030c45411304d0d049de5e4da32bdcb03c40095ed1c63128f
Review r1 of lifecycle Task 3.
C1: the four owner controls (answer, attach, mode, cancel) inserted and routed a
human-to-PM message without the messaging policy check message.send makes. The
shared writer now reads the current human-to-PM edge inside the control's
transaction, before it inserts or routes anything, and refuses with
message-sender-refused. The refusal rolls back the journal row, the human.input
event, the message and a withdrawn selection decision. The cancel withdrawal
checks the same edge. Regression tests close the edge after the question and
cover all four controls, then reopen it and prove the same call lands once.
I1: serve.mjs read sso.publicOrigin for a request URL when the Console ran
without --sso (or in preview mode), which ended the process on an unauthenticated
GET /api/requests/r1. A request route now answers through requestHTTP with no
transports and no SSO fields: unavailable on a read, read-only on a write, 405
for the wrong method. Listener tests cover GET and POST without SSO and in
preview mode, named and loopback, and the process keeps serving.
M1: the browser test waiter allowed about 3 s and reload() could run out its loop
without failing. Waits are now deadline-bound at 15 s and name the expression,
and reload() waits for the new document's own ready flag and the mounted chat,
and throws if it never gets there. The no-repost and stored-answer assertions of
the lost-answer case are unchanged.
Migration 3p-3q is unchanged.
The owner handles a new request from the Console: pick the mode (new
autonomous, new guided or an existing project), answer the project
manager's questions and confirm an attachment, with no copy-to-terminal
step.
Bus: 3p->3q append-only migration widens the request_events kinds. The PM
asks one question with request.question. The owner-only
request.answer.console, request.attach.console, request.mode.console and
request.cancel.console join the two console reads in CONSOLE_VERBS. An
answer is an attributed human.input linked to its question and request,
recorded once per op and never a PRD approval. An attach pick makes the PM
propose that project as a confirmation decision; nothing is mapped on the
pick. A mode change takes the expected revisions and leaves the bound plan
as evidence. Cancel keeps a created project.
Console: request-http.mjs serves GET /api/requests/:request, /projects and
/draft and POST /answer, /attach, /mode and /cancel with the signed-in
owner, same-origin and bounded-body checks of the decision routes.
requests.js draws the panel under the owner's chat message, answers the
mode decision through the existing confirmation endpoints, and after a lost
answer response reads the request first and resends the same op only on the
owner's click.
Lifecycle Task 2 (#797). A confirmed new-project selection now becomes a
usable product: the code checkout, the organization mapping, the records
repository with the original intent as the owner's spec commit, the chat
association and the working repository, each journaled as its own receipt
(bootstrap:<plan_digest>:<step>) and recoverable after a kill.
- business: addProject is a private exact-add writer under the existing
organization lock and receipt discipline; hold runs a synchronous check
under that lock; findAddition recovers a prepared receipt. Ordinary
writers still refuse every project change.
- bus: prepareBootstrap and executeBootstrap; activateManagedProject
reloads only a receipt-backed additive root and admits it to the broker
after readiness; request.admission host IPC op for the launcher.
- #800: the bound organization revision and association are re-verified
inside the organization lock at the start of execution; a mismatch
records request-plan-stale and performs no effect.
- cli: trackerFor skips reserved products; the launcher refuses to clone a
product the bus has not admitted.
- seat: initializeWorking seeds the working repository, host-only, with no
work ref or push authority.
- schema: append-only migration 3o to 3p widens the request_events kind
list with bootstrap.stale and bootstrap.completed.
jason.woltje
mos