Jason's 2026-11-12 ruling: the only deployed system is the dev environment on
dragon-lin, so the system-type plug-in kind goes with no retired kind, fence,
conversion or new refusal code.
- plugins: system-type leaves KINDS; system-types.mjs and the five modules are
deleted. An org file naming the kind refuses unknown-kind.
- organization: the plugins.system-type check, systemTypesFence and the
system-types.console right are removed.
- bus: system-types.console, project.system-types[.set], the system-type half
of the tester check, the runtime reads and system-type-not-enabled are
removed. Step 3v-3w drops project_system_types, its index, its four guards
and its rows; SCHEMA_VERSION is 3w (32 tables, 126 triggers, 5 views).
- cli: mosaic org system-types and mosaic project system-types[-set] are
removed; stack-release COUNTED and the budget supervisor's closed list move
to 3w.
- channel: the project.system-types verbs are removed.
- webui: the System types page, route, dashboard row, chips and project
selection are removed.
- docs: REQ-SYS-1/2 now describe starter packs; README system-type text and
the requirements titles follow.
Jason approved draft 2 on 2026-11-09 at 22:57Z: "The file looks fine
other than that." The exception is the Montage module name, deferred
since 19:26Z. Amends REQ-ASSIST-1, REQ-USER-1, REQ-TASK-1 and REQ-WEB-3
and adds 17 requirements (101 to 118): REQ-WS-1..8, REQ-AGENT-1..3,
REQ-SYS-1..2, REQ-ACCT-1..2, REQ-SETUP-1..2. requirements.json and the
tasks and bus count pins follow.
Tests: 68 pass, 1 fail. The failure is stack-copy.test.mjs (20/1), which
fails the same way on origin/refactor 483eccb3d: npm's pinned install
can't find node-gyp/bin/node-gyp.js in the test Node installation.
Row 335 landed PRD version 1.18 first, for the REQ-INST-2 correction. The
disk-space governance text that Jason approved as 1.18 in Q289 therefore
lands as 1.19. Only version labels move: the status line, the disk version
source bullet, the "since version" labels in the disk sections, the disk
milestone, and requirements.json "version". The requirement text, IDs,
order, defaults, settings and the 101 records are unchanged.
The prior approval history bullet now runs through version 1.18 and carries
the row 335 lines. The two test pins follow the renumbering.
Follows Jason's Q211 ruling and Mos's reading. Adds to v1 and removes nothing.
- Status and a Version 1.11 source bullet quoting Q211.
- Users: two v1 users on their own instances (Q176). Where it runs: two PVE VMs, dragon-lin dev only (Q180, Q181).
- Out of scope: minting credentials (Q188, Q190), SSO (Q175) and access beyond localhost (Q176, Q179, Q180) move into v1. The bundled Pocket ID stays out (REQ-INST-2, Q203). Codex and SetSpark stay out. Case 2's own organization is v1.
- REQ-CRED-1: Gitea per seat through a grant (Q190).
- REQ-FED-1: person-to-person v1, agent-to-agent post-v1 (Q179, Q180).
- New REQ-INST-3: one-command install and upgrade, Console unit enabled in both v1 profiles (Q187, Q189).
- Acceptance: the 10-27 goal (Q176). The 1.10 note at :1217 now points to Q211. A Version 1.11 technical note keeps the old list text.
requirements.json goes to 1.11 with 71 ids. Both requirements tests are updated to match.
Adds REQ-INST-2 after REQ-INST-1 as drafted in sage-2144 and ruled in mos-1204: Jason's Q203 sentence verbatim, marked post-v1 the way REQ-FED-1 is, with Mos's reading (mos-1202) labelled as his. A Version 1.10 technical note records, as fact, that REQ-WEB-2 uses the Console's own OIDC sign-in while the out-of-scope list still names 'Pocket ID and SSO', which Jason hasn't ruled on (vikunja:19/459). The list and the Pocket ID technical note are unchanged. requirements.json goes to 1.10 with 70 ids, and both requirements tests are updated to match. Design row 255 (#1760, Vikunja 458).
Jason approved the buttons in decision 00ed58e2 (vikunja:19/266) and chose
O6 in Q203 (OIDC-only), relayed by Mos in mos-1202 with "Land PRD 1.9 with
REQ-WEB-2 as written". The wording is sage-2067's draft. requirements.json
goes to 1.9 with 69 ids; tasks suite 97/0 and bus requirements.test.mjs 3/0
on Sage's slot.
1.7 is PRD-1.7-DRAFT.md (sha256 e896746d), approved by decision d52febb5 (prd.approve, yes). 1.8 is r7
82df17347 (sha256 de079281), approved by Jason in T3, relayed by Mos (mos-1154, DECISIONS Q192), so it has no
in-Stack prd.approve. packages/tasks/requirements.json moves to version 1.8 with 68 ids: COS-3, CRED-3, CRED-4,
GRANT-1 to 4, TRUST-1, TRUST-2 and LAND-2 are new. The tasks and bus requirement pins move to 68 and 1.8.
Written by Honker (honker/prd-17-18 2884ee496), reviewed by Duckworth (duckworth-0075, -0076, -0077).
Row 139 round 2, Dewey's candidate a4c5657f (14 paths) on 5661bd233.
Filbert approved round 2 (comment 28786) after round 1 changes. Dewey's
gate: 14 runs rc 0. Mutants m1-m9 killed. Filbert ran 7 files singly:
0 fail, 0 skipped.
The broker's GATED and the business's GATED_ONLY are now the hard waits.
A cited gated decision goes to the domain arbiter unless it is a hard
wait, which always goes to the human. Under Jason's ruling Q169, a
role.revoke of the assistant is a hard wait. Its end gets past
END_PROTECTED only for the chief of staff, or when the cited decision
was resolved by the human through the CLI. PRD version 1.6 records Q169.
Mos approved the 1.6 text, including the REQ-ROLE-2 sentence on the
chief's end and revoke. scripts/test-land-work.sh adds the not-human
cases for arbiter-resolved merges. land-work's read.mjs is unchanged.
Row 137 lands second, so it carries the gated-merge refusal and the host
land op's arbiter acceptance. Making an end or revoke stop an assistant
run, and configuring the assistant, are row 155 (#1649).
Sage's landing gate ran on 26b78d483 plus the candidate: 25 steps, all rc 0 (15 packages, 10 script suites), 19:23:57Z to 19:28:28Z, network sage-r139_default removed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
Version 1.5 records Jason's Q167 ruling and added text as its source
block. It replaces REQ-DEC-2 routing: a gated decision citing the
project's current spec commit goes to the domain arbiter, and only an
uncited decision or a hard wait goes to the human. It adds the hard
waits (REQ-WAIT-1 to 3, with data.delete, network.expose and
account.create), projects and the spec file (REQ-PROJ-1 to 4), agent
landing (REQ-LAND-1), approvals that outlive the run (REQ-DEC-5),
settled decisions under a new spec (REQ-DEC-6), the four workflow roles
and proactive contracts (REQ-ROLE-5, 6), staff requests (REQ-COS-2),
assistant summaries (REQ-ASSIST-3) and name addressing (REQ-MSG-2).
docs/acceptance/314.md is the run Jason does in the Stack once the
rows are live.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
Jason-approved merge, landed unchanged: git diff 07c12b51b..b3dd8de83
from work/vikunja-19-297. Business reviewer verdict 0d4c1c68 approve on that
commit; Jason resolved merge decision 29ff6589 via the CLI. No commit on
refactor since 07c12b51b touches these paths.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
PRD version 1.3 records Jason's rulings Q153 to Q155, relayed by Mos
(lead decision 143), and Mos reviewed the text before it landed. Adds
REQ-LIMIT-4 (usage sources and limit checks as the first plug-in kinds;
an unknown turn is never zero, no source switched on means every turn is
unknown, an unenforced limit shows as not enforced) and a Plug-ins
section with REQ-PLUG-1 (kind registry and loader in packages/plugins,
in-repo modules only until Jason rules, Vikunja #286) and REQ-PLUG-2
(new call-outs go through a kind; hard-coded parts convert as rows touch
them). REQ-LIMIT-2 and REQ-LIMIT-3 count through usage sources.
Technical considerations list where each kind is hard-coded today.
requirements.json moves to 1.3 with 41 ids; the tasks and bus id-count
tests follow. The PRD 1.2 build plan gains step 6b, the plug-in layer
(#1626), and rows 124 to 127 ship their counting and checks as modules.
Jason approved the conversion order for hard-coded parts in Q156. Lead
decision 143 and the build plan record it, and the managed-session
config brief notes that row 65 now runs before 64 and 66.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
PRD version 1.2, approved by Jason through Mos on 2026-10-14 (lead
decisions 141 and 142). Adds REQ-COS-1, REQ-ASSIST-1/2, REQ-LIMIT-1/2/3,
REQ-USER-2 and REQ-THREAD-2, rewrites the role, launch, message, CLI and
WebUI requirements, and quotes Q147 to Q151 in the source line.
REQ-LIMIT-2 marks the token unit for the daily quota as a draft position.
requirements.json moves to 1.2 with 38 ids; the tasks and bus id-count
tests follow. Full gate green at bea5dfa47 plus these four files.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
Squash of the PM's work/vikunja-19-265 branch, net diff 0c3826910..8ae5a1491
(patch sha256 47b34e6054a74eedd8a5b6577e40537a07b2fb8fe5846f309e100146238ef743).
The PRD moves to version 1.1. "Business" becomes "organization" in
REQ-ROLE-3, REQ-ROLE-4 and REQ-LAUNCH-1. REQ-DEC-3 and REQ-DEC-4 name an
authorized human instead of Jason. Non-goal D adds that v1 has no hosted
SaaS, and "Where it runs" says Mosaic Stack stays self-hosted open source.
A new Organizations section adds REQ-ORG-1, REQ-ORG-2, REQ-USER-1,
REQ-THREAD-1, REQ-TPL-1 and REQ-FED-1. packages/tasks/requirements.json
matches at version 1.1 with 30 ids, and the tasks and bus requirements
tests expect 30.
The branch's 010d30cbe (parseRequirementId, task 19/229) is reverted on
the branch and is not part of this squash.
Jason approved the PRD in decision 03130d08 and the merge in decision
f71c73c9 (resolved yes via the CLI, 2026-10-14T16:35:32Z). The stack
reviewer's verdict d3f97f9d approves 8ae5a1491. Sage's gate on 1c9a4910d
plus the patch passed: every package suite and every scripts/test-*.sh.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
Row 90, round 2. Dewey built it, Filbert approved it (comment 28068) on
manifest 95611274 (21 paths, base b8539480). The approved PRD's
requirement ids live in packages/tasks/requirements.json. task_create
refuses an id outside it, and the PM session gets a list_requirements
tool. Round 2 adds requirements.mjs to the sandbox's RUNNER_FILES
(decision 127). Sage gate on c047d028 plus the patch, 23:50:16Z to
23:54:26Z: tasks 89, bus 111, harness 66, webui 101, cli 123, seat 33,
business 60, control-board 124, queue 150, conversation 182, discord 178,
ledger 78, runs 43, mosaic 69, all fail 0. Every scripts/test-*.sh
exited 0.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
jason.woltje
